Live data from Hacker News

Facebook shut down German research on Instagram algorithm

theverge.com

1–10 of 36 posts

Re: Facebook shut down German research on Instagram algorithm

#3

Is it “A chilling echo of NYU ad observatory issues” or did this prevent the German version of Cambridge Analytics? Or is it the response we would have seen out of CA, if they had been stopped before 2016?

Funny that Facebook had no issue with Cambridge Analytica until Cambridge Analytica became an issue. Let's also ignore the fact that Cambridge Analytica was a private foreign company illicitly compiling data to influence US elections. But yes by all means, it's no different than a research group and volunteers studying an algorithm. You definitely nailed it.

Re: Facebook shut down German research on Instagram algorithm

#4
post #3

Is it “A chilling echo of NYU ad observatory issues” or did this prevent the German version of Cambridge Analytics? Or is it the response we would have seen out of CA, if they had been stopped before 2016?

Funny that Facebook had no issue with Cambridge Analytica until Cambridge Analytica became an issue. Let's also ignore the fact that Cambridge Analytica was a private foreign company illicitly compiling data to influence US elections. But yes by all means, it's no different than a research group and volunteers studying an algorithm. You definitely nailed it.

They learned from the mistake and now doesn't want to make the same mistake. Sounds fair though.

How do you guarantee it is just a research group?

Didn't Cambridge analytics look innocent as well in the beginning?

Re: Facebook shut down German research on Instagram algorithm

#6
post #3

Is it “A chilling echo of NYU ad observatory issues” or did this prevent the German version of Cambridge Analytics? Or is it the response we would have seen out of CA, if they had been stopped before 2016?

Funny that Facebook had no issue with Cambridge Analytica until Cambridge Analytica became an issue. Let's also ignore the fact that Cambridge Analytica was a private foreign company illicitly compiling data to influence US elections. But yes by all means, it's no different than a research group and volunteers studying an algorithm. You definitely nailed it.

It should be remembered that the Obama administration carried out the same type of research as Cambridge Analytica to influence the 2012 election.

If this research is going to be criticised, it should be done evenly, not just when it's politically convenient.

Re: Facebook shut down German research on Instagram algorithm

#9
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Funny that Facebook had no issue with Cambridge Analytica until Cambridge Analytica became an issue. Let's also ignore the fact that Cambridge Analytica was a private foreign company illicitly compiling data to influence US elections. But yes by all means, it's no different than a research group and volunteers studying an algorithm. You definitely nailed it.

They learned from the mistake and now doesn't want to make the same mistake. Sounds fair though. How do you guarantee it is just a research group? Didn't Cambridge analytics look innocent as well in the beginning?

FB’s response to imagine the worst and outright ban is awfully convenient. Do you really think FB is so on top of their user’s privacy otherwise?

Re: Facebook shut down German research on Instagram algorithm

#10
"In May, researchers say Facebook asked to meet with the project leaders and accused them of violating the platform’s terms of service. Another objection was that the project violated the GDPR, since it collected data from users who had not consented to participate."

Aww, GDPR keeps on giving – to those who can afford the legal manhours. Thank you, Jan Philipp Albrecht. You've ruined the internet.

Post reply on HN