Live data from Hacker News

Page Speed Service

googlecode.blogspot.com

31–40 of 63 posts

Re: Page Speed Service

#31

Just another example of Google trying to improve the world. I would personally be a bit worried about the level of control this would mean giving up. But I just like to tinker. I know plenty of people for whom this is perfect.

Seems hard to believe their motivation for seeing a ton of consumer web traffic on third party sites is to improve the world. I mean, obviously google analytics isn't some altruistic attempt to help people track their web usage better.

Re: Page Speed Service

#32
I really don't see the point of passing it through them. Instead I'd rather they just tell me how to optimize it so I can apply the improvements myself.

Re: Page Speed Service

#34
post #14

Anyone notice all the testing locations are AWS Regions? I was assuming webpagetest was a Google property and figured they would use their own data centers.

That doesn't prove much though, does it? "Northern Virginia" is a pretty broad region.

Weird that their default test browser is IE8 too. Hello Chrome ?

Re: Page Speed Service

#35
post #32

I really don't see the point of passing it through them. Instead I'd rather they just tell me how to optimize it so I can apply the improvements myself.

They offer that as well. http://pagespeed.googlelabs.com/

Pagespeed is on the soon to be closed Google Labs (http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2011/07/more-wood-behind-fewe...).

Re: Page Speed Service

#36
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cloudflare does a LOT more than this. In fact, the area where they cross-over is the area that interests me the least - I am quite capable of making a website balls-to-the-wall fast without either of their products, but Cloudflare leverage their size to accomplish things I literally could not accomplish without them. I initially wrote Cloudflare off because of this, they don't do a great job of telling you about the…

Care to elaborate? I've been wondering what the advantages are but haven't had the time to look into it in more depth. What's been your experience?

Well, I can do all the speed improvement things myself, so I'm interested in some of the weirder things. They can detect bots quite reliably because with a network that large it's pretty damn obvious when something is crawling a site - and they can then strip out or mangle email addresses from your HTML before reaching those bots, so you can have email addresses in plaintext without having them harvested. That's a pretty imaginative solution!

Another thing they can do with their size is automatically identify and react to new attacks, so when a DDOS occurs it very quickly routes the traffic away and updates its ruleset to always be protected against that attack from now on, for all sites behind them.

I don't actually have any experience though as I've never used the service, this is all from their website and from talking to their staff on HN :)

Re: Page Speed Service

#38
post #14

Anyone notice all the testing locations are AWS Regions? I was assuming webpagetest was a Google property and figured they would use their own data centers.

Testing from within their own datacenters would be biased _very_ heavily toward their own service, don't you think? These tests are only meaningful if performed on an external ISP. Note also that if you do the test it says "US East (Virginia) - IE 8 - DSL", suggesting that it's on a regular DSL connection, not a EC2 box.

Re: Page Speed Service

#39
post #23

Can end-users somehow opt-out of the pages they are viewing passing through Google? It should be technically possible but I doubt they will offer that.

It is not technically possible because to use the service, a web site has to change their hosting provider to Google. There are no longer any servers outside Google hosting the content, if I understand the bit about DNS change correctly.
Post reply on HN