Live data from Hacker News

Google Bans Adwords use for Facebook

techblog.willshouse.com

11–20 of 38 posts

Re: Google Bans Adwords use for Facebook

#11
Before we jump to conclusions, it's equally possible Facebook is behind this. Google gets lots of nastygrams from companies who view ads containing their name as trademark violations.

A few years ago I had trouble running an iPod related ad on Google, not because of Google but because of Apple. Is there any indication this is Google and not Facebook's doing?

Re: Google Bans Adwords use for Facebook

#12

Google recently suspended all my ads for advertising services (AdWords competitors) and for ad tracking services (Analytics competitors). These are sites Google had advertised for as long as 6 years without issue. The reasons all seem a stretch ( http://www.w3roi.com is suspended for 'misleading claims' - what claims?). Someone's rewriting policies and cracking down over there, and it's a big problem for any business…

Wow, this really looks like an ugly antitrust issue. Since the feds already have an open investigation, it is probably worth letting them know directly about this specific issue.

http://www.justice.gov/atr/contact/index.html

Re: Google Bans Adwords use for Facebook

#13

Google recently suspended all my ads for advertising services (AdWords competitors) and for ad tracking services (Analytics competitors). These are sites Google had advertised for as long as 6 years without issue. The reasons all seem a stretch ( http://www.w3roi.com is suspended for 'misleading claims' - what claims?). Someone's rewriting policies and cracking down over there, and it's a big problem for any business…

This is why you don't stake the well-being of your company on the good intentions of another's.

Re: Google Bans Adwords use for Facebook

#16

Google recently suspended all my ads for advertising services (AdWords competitors) and for ad tracking services (Analytics competitors). These are sites Google had advertised for as long as 6 years without issue. The reasons all seem a stretch ( http://www.w3roi.com is suspended for 'misleading claims' - what claims?). Someone's rewriting policies and cracking down over there, and it's a big problem for any business…

There are quite a few fraudsters that use names beginning with "W3" to suggest a connection with the W3C. Dollars to donuts that's the "misleading claim" they were alluding to. (I'm not saying you were trying to defraud anyone, but you've found yourself in kind of a "bad neighborhood," and Google tend to be a little bit prejudiced when they find you hanging out there.)

Re: Google Bans Adwords use for Facebook

#17
post #13

Google recently suspended all my ads for advertising services (AdWords competitors) and for ad tracking services (Analytics competitors). These are sites Google had advertised for as long as 6 years without issue. The reasons all seem a stretch ( http://www.w3roi.com is suspended for 'misleading claims' - what claims?). Someone's rewriting policies and cracking down over there, and it's a big problem for any business…

This is why you don't stake the well-being of your company on the good intentions of another's.

Monopolistic market share makes that difficult. Every store stakes their business on their electric company providing service.

Poor analogy, but for internet businesses whose prospects find solutions through search, Google refusing service is going to impact you no matter where else you advertise. They're too big to easily substitute competitors.

Re: Google Bans Adwords use for Facebook

#18
humorously, if you search for "facebook ads", the first ad (at least for me) is an ad for facebook.com/ads. If you search with the quotes, that is followed by two sites that promise to optimize your social media ad presence.

Those might be from existing contracts or something, and after the whole email contact "reciprocity" spat I could believe some form of this is happening, but it would be nice to see some actual confirmation.

Re: Google Bans Adwords use for Facebook

#19

One potential reason for this: http://www.byrnehobart.com/blog/a-clever-adwords-hack-how-to... When people run ads pointing to a site they don't own, it's often in an effort to get an implicit endorsement from that site. Note: I have no evidence that this is going on, but it is a risk with any site that has a recognizable URL and allows user-generated content. From what I can see, it looks like ads pointing to FB wer…

> These ads are also growing in popularity. It looks like they doubled between April and June.

Source?

Re: Google Bans Adwords use for Facebook

#20

Before we jump to conclusions, it's equally possible Facebook is behind this. Google gets lots of nastygrams from companies who view ads containing their name as trademark violations. A few years ago I had trouble running an iPod related ad on Google, not because of Google but because of Apple. Is there any indication this is Google and not Facebook's doing?

Interestingly, a search for "find friends" on Google still returns an ad promoting Facebook from Facebook itself. That's one data point in favor of the Facebook-initiated trademark hypothesis.
Post reply on HN