Live data from Hacker News

New Laptop: Thinkpad P14s

domenkozar.com

31–40 of 101 posts

Re: New Laptop: Thinkpad P14s

#31

Good laptop, but with a few small drawbacks: - No vapor chamber cooling, just regular heat pipes - Monitor has thick borders - Not 16:10 - Fn/Ctrl are swapped (all thinkpad laptops) - Thinkpad's fingerprint readers never worked reliably to me - I personally prefer USB-C network adapter instead of the bulky RJ45 - 720p camera, but most of laptops have a bad web cam... - I assume it will have very average speakers. Usu…

Fn/Ctrl can be swapped in BIOS

Re: New Laptop: Thinkpad P14s

#32
I have the same laptop with the 4K IPS display and the AMD 5850U, and I am pretty happy with it. On Ubuntu I had to install the Wi-Fi driver manually [0], tweak the grub config to make the screen brightness control work [1], and install gnome-screensaver to make suspend/resume work properly. Maybe things would work better out of the box on Pop!_OS? Otherwise, it's pretty good. It does not heat up much compared to the previous Intel laptop I had, and it is plenty fast. I was not able to make Howdy [2] work properly, and the fingerprint reader was not reliable compared to my MacBook, however.

[0]: https://github.com/lwfinger/rtw89

[1]: Add this to the grub file : GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX="amdgpu.backlight=0"

[2]: https://github.com/boltgolt/howdy

Re: New Laptop: Thinkpad P14s

#33

Magnificent ThinkPad model. Too bad the soldered-on RAM precludes the possibility of using ECC modules. The Pro version of the Ryzen CPU means ECC compatibility.

afik not a single ryzen laptop uses ECC from the factory and documentation on compatibility is pretty horrible; this is the only thing stopping me from making the leap.

Supposedly someday we're meant to have DDR5 with ECC built in. I've been waiting for that day as well.

Re: New Laptop: Thinkpad P14s

#34
I was in the mood to get a "mobile workstation", and ended up buying an HP Omen gaming laptop, which had an i7, 16GB of RAM, and discrete GPU. The idea was to be able to run one or more VMs and do hardcore development. And maybe play a few strategy games.

In the intervening years, I have hardly used the laptop for the purposes I had initially intended, though I do occasionally play strategy games on it.

I've mostly been using an inexpensive Chromebook as a remote Linux terminal, and then logging into remote machines to do development. With a little GNU screen startup script, it is easy to resume where I left off, regardless of my location.

Re: New Laptop: Thinkpad P14s

#35

I want to love thinkpads, but the fact that in 2021 you still have a display lottery frustrates me to no end. You buy a MacBook Pro you get an A+ display. Thinkpad? You might get one with the good display, you might not.

It's very easy to replace the displays on these business line thinkpads.

Re: New Laptop: Thinkpad P14s

#36
> There's only one company in Slovenia that does warranty repairs and takes the law-specified 40 working days to finish their job (replacing a battery, for example).

Is there a law that says that repairs must be done within 40 working days and so the repair shop takes the full 40 days? Is this because they have no competition or are supply/resource constrained?

Re: New Laptop: Thinkpad P14s

#37
post #20

Are the trackpads anywhere close to macbooks yet? My XPS 13 is still awful and my previous thinkpad is worse than the XPS.

That's the thing which keeps me from buying a new notebook. :( Everything else I care about is on par with intel macbooks but the touchpad is too important.

Re: New Laptop: Thinkpad P14s

#38
post #34

I was in the mood to get a "mobile workstation", and ended up buying an HP Omen gaming laptop, which had an i7, 16GB of RAM, and discrete GPU. The idea was to be able to run one or more VMs and do hardcore development. And maybe play a few strategy games. In the intervening years, I have hardly used the laptop for the purposes I had initially intended, though I do occasionally play strategy games on it. I've mostly b…

That setup sounds really appealing!

How does the startup script work? Does it install software, and does it require root access on the dev machine?

Do you have multiple remote machines, or just one you use often?

Re: New Laptop: Thinkpad P14s

#39

I want to love thinkpads, but the fact that in 2021 you still have a display lottery frustrates me to no end. You buy a MacBook Pro you get an A+ display. Thinkpad? You might get one with the good display, you might not.

Yes, Thinkpad's FHD is horrible. So I put a QHD display on my T480s, and my eyes love 'em. The last Mac I used was Mac Air Retina 2012, switched just because of the matte screen.

Re: New Laptop: Thinkpad P14s

#40
post #35

I want to love thinkpads, but the fact that in 2021 you still have a display lottery frustrates me to no end. You buy a MacBook Pro you get an A+ display. Thinkpad? You might get one with the good display, you might not.

It's very easy to replace the displays on these business line thinkpads.

I shouldn’t have to replace the display on a new computer. Especially when the part numbers are all the same. I’ve swapped the display in my x230 to get away from a ghosting panel just to get another panel that is supposedly ghost free, but still ghosts.
Post reply on HN