Live data from Hacker News

Mac vs PC: Does it matter anymore?

broadcast.oreilly.com

1–10 of 32 posts

Re: Mac vs PC: Does it matter anymore?

#2
Is Mac vs. PC becoming irrelevant because of the maturing of the internet as a platform and cloud computing?

What I find very interesting about this is the possibility that it cuts both ways for Apple. If the two are interchangeable, you can buy based on price and features, which can be an advantage for Windows, since there are many manufacturers who can offer a larger variety of form factors and feature combinations.

But the flip side of that proposition is that if there is no Windows lock-in forcing consumers to buy Windows, so they can also choose Apple based on good design, Apple branding, the iPod halo effect, and perceived security.

Personally, I think that there is a big difference between saying that there are no factors forcing consumers to purchase one or the others and saying that the differences between them don't matter any more.

Re: Mac vs PC: Does it matter anymore?

#3
I think it still does. I use both a mac and a pc. I tend to spend a chunk of time inside a browser. Desktop work on the PC is Outlook and Excel. Desktop work on a mac is mostly spent inside Textmate and a shell. All computing/web hosting is done virtually. I can't wait to get a mac from work so that I don't have to use the PC. Now that is personal preference, but IMO the experience on your host machine does make a difference, regardless of your preference.

Re: Mac vs PC: Does it matter anymore?

#4
Even if the Internet is the "killer app", it still matters how you get there. Is your preferred client available on the platform? Does it work well on that platform?

My web browser, E-mail client and terminal of choice, for instance, are not available on Windows; and no, I'm not using Apple's Safari or Terminal. So when I pull up these applications, I'm seeing what is (to me) a superior Internet experience. Even Firefox on Windows, or PuTTY, just don't quite deliver what I like most.

And cross-platform applications are still platform-dependent. For instance, I love Thunderbird on Linux...it works well. On the Mac, however, despite using Thunderbird for months, it always felt a little clunky (e.g. emulated UI appearance, doing everything itself instead of integrating with OS services such as Keychain). In the end, the combination of platform and application made Apple's Mail more useful to me.

Re: Mac vs PC: Does it matter anymore?

#6
It totally matters. Just ask any Mac or Linux diehard. Personally, I use all three of the primary operating systems: Windows XP, Mac OSX and Linux (Ubuntu in this case). I have separate uses for each and can't imagine getting rid of any of them.

Re: Mac vs PC: Does it matter anymore?

#7
post #6

It totally matters. Just ask any Mac or Linux diehard. Personally, I use all three of the primary operating systems: Windows XP, Mac OSX and Linux (Ubuntu in this case). I have separate uses for each and can't imagine getting rid of any of them.

I'm curious what you use Windows for. The only things I can imagine myself using Windows for are gaming or testing in IE.

Re: Mac vs PC: Does it matter anymore?

#8
post #6

It totally matters. Just ask any Mac or Linux diehard. Personally, I use all three of the primary operating systems: Windows XP, Mac OSX and Linux (Ubuntu in this case). I have separate uses for each and can't imagine getting rid of any of them.

I'm curious what you use Windows for. The only things I can imagine myself using Windows for are gaming or testing in IE.

'Wine' is ok for testing IE under Linux.

Re: Mac vs PC: Does it matter anymore?

#9
Sure it does. I prefer the Mac over a PC. Windows generally treat the user like an idiot (you have unused icons on your desktop!!) while the Mac tends to be a little more user friendly. Sure I have a PC as well, I don't know of a good alternative to EAC for ripping a perfect copy of a CD. And playing games on the PC is great too, not to mention the hardware is more often than not a lot cheaper. But I've been a Mac User since 1984 and haven't felt any need to stop using one. I like the Mac philosophy, and Windows generally erks me to no end. My newest Mac (a MacBook) runs Windows XP on a partition, which is pretty nice, so I get both OS's on one machine. No more Dells from Hell for me. Knowing the average reader on this site, this comment will probably get voted down to about a -15, because I don't trumpet the superiority of Linux.

Re: Mac vs PC: Does it matter anymore?

#10
post #6

It totally matters. Just ask any Mac or Linux diehard. Personally, I use all three of the primary operating systems: Windows XP, Mac OSX and Linux (Ubuntu in this case). I have separate uses for each and can't imagine getting rid of any of them.

I'm curious what you use Windows for. The only things I can imagine myself using Windows for are gaming or testing in IE.

Microsoft Sam text-to-speech. I've never found a more amusing computer voice.
Post reply on HN