Live data from Hacker News

Amazon removes link to Kindle store from iOS app

itunes.apple.com

11–20 of 63 posts

Re: Amazon removes link to Kindle store from iOS app

#11
post #3

On one hand I suppose nobody should get a free ride. Apple put a lot of hard work into building such cohesive and user-friendly ecosystem. If they have their own bookstore they're trying to run why should they enable a competitor's in their own home? On the other hand this stinks for consumers. Slightly. They can still go to the website on their own but Apple made it a bit more inconvenient. If you're already a Kindl…

| If they have their own bookstore they're trying to run why should they enable a competitor's in their own home? If Microsoft spent so much on R&D for Windows 95 and IE, why shouldn't they build it into the OS? Why shouldn't they lock down their APIs to make it difficult to make competing products inside their OS? Really?

I think your argument is flawed (though I also think you are making two somewhat related, yet different points). It isn't about building it into the OS, it's about allowing competitors to provide a service to 'your' users.

Microsoft didn't prevent any browsers from being installed on Windows, they didn't require any special processes or try to prevent any competitors from offering competitive or superior services. Microsoft just figured if the baked in stuff was good enough, most people wouldn't bother to change, and they were right.

I could would agree with Apple taking a cut of in-app purchases where billing is completed through Apple's infrastructure, but forcing application builders (your community builders) to hamstring their products or pay you a cut is anti-competitive in a sense that I think is worse than anything Microsoft has done.

Microsoft helped foster innovation, and then stole it and made it difficult to compete, but you could compete. Apple is just hamstringing the competition so that they can't compete.

Re: Amazon removes link to Kindle store from iOS app

#12
post #8

I'm waiting for Apple to require all things bought through Macs to use Apple's payment system. I mean right now, millions of dollars of products are being purchased on websites being viewed on Macs. Clearly Apple should get 30%. I'm sure it'll be huge. (and screw Karma with this one... Apple appears just greedy and downright anti-competitive doing this)

I 've heard toyota plans to take a 30% cut off petrol stations, too.

Re: Amazon removes link to Kindle store from iOS app

#14
Depressing. This stuff makes me want to get a different tablet. The problems is that IMHO no other tablet is currently competitive with the ipad 2 I own. At least I am in the market for a phone, it will properly be a android phone this time...

Re: Amazon removes link to Kindle store from iOS app

#15
post #8

I'm waiting for Apple to require all things bought through Macs to use Apple's payment system. I mean right now, millions of dollars of products are being purchased on websites being viewed on Macs. Clearly Apple should get 30%. I'm sure it'll be huge. (and screw Karma with this one... Apple appears just greedy and downright anti-competitive doing this)

[deleted]

Re: Amazon removes link to Kindle store from iOS app

#17
post #10

Don't forget to read customer reviews. Depressing.

That's my biggest beef about the whole thing. I guess you could argue it is Apple's prerogative to change rules, but Kobo and Amazon can't even communicate why things are changing to their customers. It really points out how much the App store is sharecropping. Making apps is not a viable business when so much about developing a business is the customer relationship.

Re: Amazon removes link to Kindle store from iOS app

#18
post #13

It makes me very happy to see someone stand up to Apple. I hope some of the other big publishers follow Amazon. Jeff Bezos is my new hero.

There is no stand. Apple required it. Same thing happened to Kobo.

I realize Apple required it. But Amazon still had a choice. They could have complied with Apple's rules and paid 30% of their revenue to Apple for ebooks sold from within the app. And passed the price increase on to consumers.

I view it as standing up to Apple that Amazon did not do this. I think this will be better, if a little inconvenient, for consumers in the long run because it will ultimately keep ebook prices lower.

Re: Amazon removes link to Kindle store from iOS app

#19
The sad thing is that Apple is the kind of company that is deciding to be evil, rather than just doing it accidentally. I'm sure they calculated that they would make more money by enforcing these harmful rules than the good will they would lose, so they did it anyway.
Post reply on HN