Live data from Hacker News

Life before smartphones (2020)

mattruby.substack.com

41–50 of 495 posts

Re: Life before smartphones (2020)

#41
Very nicely written. Made me feel nostalgic of the faint memories when I was a kid.

Not really the main theme of this article, but I guess I do lack the courage of approaching a woman for her number and asking her out these days. Can't imagine how hard that is in real life.

Re: Life before smartphones (2020)

#43
post #6
post #2

I have never truly known a period of time without a smart device. The last watch I had was when I was a small child and it was only a few years ago I found a street "atlas". I have a feeling that I've missed a building block of the digital age by not experiencing an evolutionary phase.

You can always go back, any time! Get a dumb phone. It's great. Engage with others more authentically, more meaningfully, and more consistently.

I have a friend who did that. It's pretty irritating trying to remember his unique constraints on communication that I need to know in order to reach him.

Some people conflate authenticity for interactions with others who are willing to go way out of their way to spend time with you.

Re: Life before smartphones (2020)

#44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tried it, hated it. Everyone is using WhatsApp, Telegram, whatever. Try typing a sms with those tiny buttons, it sucks. There is a reason why some people have a smartphone but not a computer.

That last sentence is the most confusing thing I’ve read today, and I still don’t know what you mean by it.

>> There is a reason why some people have a smartphone but not a computer.

> That last sentence is the most confusing thing I’ve read today, and I still don’t know what you mean by it.

I think ahofmann is referring to people who have a smartphone but not a desktop / laptop or similar.

Re: Life before smartphones (2020)

#45
post #2

I have never truly known a period of time without a smart device. The last watch I had was when I was a small child and it was only a few years ago I found a street "atlas". I have a feeling that I've missed a building block of the digital age by not experiencing an evolutionary phase.

The pre-LTE era was quite the experience as a teenager, and it wasn’t until the iPhone 5 when smartphones became a ubiquitous and affordable thing (or justifiable) for many of my friends. I didn’t have a smartphone until my junior year of high school! SMS feature phones like the sidekick, with physical keyboards, ruled the day and many of my classmates actually disliked smartphones because of the lack of physical key…

> The pre-LTE era was quite the experience as a teenager

You all had it made. I'm sure any younger person can vouch for the social issues that come along with every teenager having a smartphone, but your cohort also missed out on family-shared landlines and all of the issues attendant with them. Calling your date and finding yourself forced to make small talk with her dad the phone bouncer, for example.

Re: Life before smartphones (2020)

#46
post #17

I've been working my way through Seinfeld, and I realized most of the plot lines couldn't have happened if cell phones were commonplace back then.

Also 'Romeo and Juliet' (tragedy occurs because a message isn't delivered), 'Assault on Precinct 13' (gang cuts the phoneline to a besieged police station) and the opening credits of Terry and June (couple can't find each other in a shopping centre)

Re: Life before smartphones (2020)

#47

A couple of things not mentioned: * Half of the population watching the same episodes of the same programme simultaneously. If you missed an episode, it was gone forever * Inane arguments in pubs about facts that couldn't be instantly googled.

Often if you missed an episode you had one more chance usually either at 2 am or during the day time the next day.

Re: Life before smartphones (2020)

#48
post #13
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can always go back, any time! Get a dumb phone. It's great. Engage with others more authentically, more meaningfully, and more consistently.

Unfortunately you can't; society has changed too, in many ways. Even some government services now require either an iOS or Android device to access (like vaccination records here in BC). A dumb phone does less for you now than it did in 2005, just like a horse does less for you now than it did in 1895. Even if you really like horses, you can't ride them on the same streets you once could.

Great example: in 2005 you could text 466-45 (Google) for weather and directions, but that service got canned by 2012 or so.

Re: Life before smartphones (2020)

#49
post #32
post #17

I've been working my way through Seinfeld, and I realized most of the plot lines couldn't have happened if cell phones were commonplace back then.

You know, that's another thing that has changed a lot. Modern TV writer just can't stop himself from using the mobile phone as a device to advance the story. We have to watch some guy in a TV show sending iMessages. That is so boring, and as a caveman from the pre-cellular era it takes me out of the show and makes me want to turn it off. A recent offender in this regard was the Amazon show "Bosch". If you made a supe…

Whats interesting to me is the transition period in screenwriting. From the early 2000s to the early 2010s, characters would be shown carrying phones but would still get into situations which could be solved easily with their mobile. But they’d act as if they didn’t have it. I found interesting watching the writers adjust their tropes over time.

It’s also interesting to me that this problem, of storytelling in a world of instant communication, was first addressed in the original Star Trek. Various adventure story tropes had to be adjusted for communicators and transporters. Roddenberry et al admitted it was a headache sometimes.

Re: Life before smartphones (2020)

#50
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can always go back, any time! Get a dumb phone. It's great. Engage with others more authentically, more meaningfully, and more consistently.

You can go back, but you’re going back alone.

Who's alone? I've got people around me all the time who understand and support my decision.

It may be hard for some people, but if you really want to do it, keep at it and don't give up. Seven generations from now, do you think smartphones will still have this hold on humanity? We just can't continue this way; it's an unsustainable form of society. Even movies made in 2021 do not depict smartphone usage anywhere close to the frequency and intensity they are used now. People will wake up from this collective dream one day; I'd rather wake up now and get started early on building something that works, wouldn't you?

Post reply on HN