Live data from Hacker News

Scarlett Johansson Sues Disney over ‘Black Widow’ Streaming Release

wsj.com

31–40 of 93 posts

Re: Scarlett Johansson Sues Disney over ‘Black Widow’ Streaming Release

#31
post #17

> Ms. Johansson said in the suit that her agreement with Disney’s Marvel Entertainment guaranteed an exclusive theatrical release, and her salary was based in large part on the box-office performance of the film. Meanwhile, the film was released to stream simultaneously with the box office release. Ouch.

Sounds like she had people negotiating for her who failed to recognize the full weight of the pandemic's lasting repercussions. Who knows? They may have even negotiated this deal before the severity of the pandemic was plain? Whatever the case may be, it's a teachable moment. You almost have to have "continuous wargaming" to sort out ongoing effects the pandemic may have on your business.

[deleted]

Re: Scarlett Johansson Sues Disney over ‘Black Widow’ Streaming Release

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mind not using the term "blacklist"? It's racist and othering, ties negativity to Blacks and other PoCs. "Blocklist" and "denylist" are better terms that are neutral and more descriptive.

Please don't refer to people as "blacks" and "pocs". That's racist as it boils people down to their most superficial trait. I'm being sincere.

[deleted]

Re: Scarlett Johansson Sues Disney over ‘Black Widow’ Streaming Release

#33
post #17

> Ms. Johansson said in the suit that her agreement with Disney’s Marvel Entertainment guaranteed an exclusive theatrical release, and her salary was based in large part on the box-office performance of the film. Meanwhile, the film was released to stream simultaneously with the box office release. Ouch.

Sounds like she had people negotiating for her who failed to recognize the full weight of the pandemic's lasting repercussions. Who knows? They may have even negotiated this deal before the severity of the pandemic was plain? Whatever the case may be, it's a teachable moment. You almost have to have "continuous wargaming" to sort out ongoing effects the pandemic may have on your business.

dude, they didn't negotiate on starring in the movie, shoot the movie, post production it, and then released it all within the pandemic window.

Re: Scarlett Johansson Sues Disney over ‘Black Widow’ Streaming Release

#34
post #17

> Ms. Johansson said in the suit that her agreement with Disney’s Marvel Entertainment guaranteed an exclusive theatrical release, and her salary was based in large part on the box-office performance of the film. Meanwhile, the film was released to stream simultaneously with the box office release. Ouch.

Sounds like she had people negotiating for her who failed to recognize the full weight of the pandemic's lasting repercussions. Who knows? They may have even negotiated this deal before the severity of the pandemic was plain? Whatever the case may be, it's a teachable moment. You almost have to have "continuous wargaming" to sort out ongoing effects the pandemic may have on your business.

Disney lied about it. They said they would renegotiate with her if plans changed about theatrical release, and then when plans changed, they didn’t renegotiate. (The contract was signed WELL before the pandemic.)

Re: Scarlett Johansson Sues Disney over ‘Black Widow’ Streaming Release

#35
post #6
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Knowing nothing at all about the industry from an insider perspective, my outsider surmise is maybe a lesser star in this situation would be. But Scarlett Johansson is the highest grossing female 'bankable'[0] star and as such even if Disney might not want to work with her, I doubt she will ever be wanting for work. >Expect her ROI to jump after the box-office takes of "Black Widow" are tallied. ope. I think the disp…

The problem is if Disney blacklists her from its main franchises, Star Wars and Marvel and Pixar/Disney animation films, that is more than half of the box office these days. The box office is I think 50% super hero films now. That said I think they won't...

Sounds very antitrust to me.

Re: Scarlett Johansson Sues Disney over ‘Black Widow’ Streaming Release

#37
post #17

> Ms. Johansson said in the suit that her agreement with Disney’s Marvel Entertainment guaranteed an exclusive theatrical release, and her salary was based in large part on the box-office performance of the film. Meanwhile, the film was released to stream simultaneously with the box office release. Ouch.

Sounds like she had people negotiating for her who failed to recognize the full weight of the pandemic's lasting repercussions. Who knows? They may have even negotiated this deal before the severity of the pandemic was plain? Whatever the case may be, it's a teachable moment. You almost have to have "continuous wargaming" to sort out ongoing effects the pandemic may have on your business.

Hmm, the point is that Disney breached the contract.

The pandemic would still affect her earnings, but that's beyond the point - the release shouldn't have happened on stream.

So it's Disney who should have gone to her and say, maybe let's give you a cut of the streaming and we will release this simultaneously.

Re: Scarlett Johansson Sues Disney over ‘Black Widow’ Streaming Release

#38
post #17

> Ms. Johansson said in the suit that her agreement with Disney’s Marvel Entertainment guaranteed an exclusive theatrical release, and her salary was based in large part on the box-office performance of the film. Meanwhile, the film was released to stream simultaneously with the box office release. Ouch.

Sounds like she had people negotiating for her who failed to recognize the full weight of the pandemic's lasting repercussions. Who knows? They may have even negotiated this deal before the severity of the pandemic was plain? Whatever the case may be, it's a teachable moment. You almost have to have "continuous wargaming" to sort out ongoing effects the pandemic may have on your business.

I think they were negotiating in March 2019, when there wasn't a pandemic to consider?

Re: Scarlett Johansson Sues Disney over ‘Black Widow’ Streaming Release

#39
post #17

> Ms. Johansson said in the suit that her agreement with Disney’s Marvel Entertainment guaranteed an exclusive theatrical release, and her salary was based in large part on the box-office performance of the film. Meanwhile, the film was released to stream simultaneously with the box office release. Ouch.

Sounds like she had people negotiating for her who failed to recognize the full weight of the pandemic's lasting repercussions. Who knows? They may have even negotiated this deal before the severity of the pandemic was plain? Whatever the case may be, it's a teachable moment. You almost have to have "continuous wargaming" to sort out ongoing effects the pandemic may have on your business.

The shooting of the movie ended months before the pandemic hit, and the negotiations regarding her salary had obviously been done before the shooting had even started.

Re: Scarlett Johansson Sues Disney over ‘Black Widow’ Streaming Release

#40
post #2

You think she’s blacklisted now?

Unlikely, she is very talented and extremely popular.

She may not do a Marvel Studios project again, but her character's arc is complete now so there's not much of a reason to have her anyway.

Post reply on HN