Live data from Hacker News

Windows Defender blocks qBittorrent

github.com

201–210 of 345 posts

Re: Windows Defender blocks qBittorrent

#201
post #28

I recently unpacked an old archive from the time I was making some shareware few decades ago. Windows Defender instantly ate all keygen.exe files from it. Those keygens were my own keygens for my own software (I wrote them myself and used them to generate keys for my customers back in the day).

Out of curiosity, which shareware programs were you developing back in the day?

Re: Windows Defender blocks qBittorrent

#202
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I was told I was making stuff up and/or this is in 'best interest' I read the comment thread. It's unclear which comment said that you were "making stuff up". There's also zero matches for "best interest" (your direct quote). >that this only happens because these are 'uncommon applications'. Relatively speaking, winmerge and kdiff3 are quite uncommon, compared to the normal stuff that people have installed on their…

I admit and apologize for salty tone above. It is not very constructive, and I agree, and would like to elaborate. This isn't the first time such thing has happened and it won't be last. Windows has becoming more and more painful as Operating System as in operating the machine and has been trying to operate the user instead. The incidents I mentioned about Winmerge and Kdiff3 did happen with me and I stand by that. A…

TBH, Windows shouldn't even be in the business of having any opinion on uncommon software.

If they want to collect data sets for virus protection, go ahead.

If they want to hash installed files from common software to detect divergences for virus protection, go ahead.

But having any kind of notification that an install is uncommon? We call it a general purpose computer because we want to use it for general purposes: which is to say, uncommon purposes.

This feels like ape'ing Apple without thinking it through.

Re: Windows Defender blocks qBittorrent

#203

When I mentioned in another thread this happening to other open source projects (winmerge, kdiff3) [0], I was told I was making stuff up and/or this is in 'best interest' of users and that this only happens because these are 'uncommon applications'. Its going to be amusing to read replies to this thread. Pardon the snark, but this is BS and its really sad to see this shitshow being defended. [0] https://news.ycombina…

> I was told I was making stuff up and/or this is in 'best interest' of users

This is the sensation I get too. "Why don't you just use regedit/gpedit/etc." (this approach is hilariously insufficient)

Some days I feel like giving up on tech because of how the corporate PR machines have ruined large swathes of the community. It is getting harder and harder to find actual answers to questions like "how do I remove the windows defender binaries from my PC?"

If the TI approach stops working, I am moving to linux and I am taking our product's platform along for the ride too.

Re: Windows Defender blocks qBittorrent

#204
post #121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I anticipated this question :) No, it was just a plain Windows form, built from scratch using a then-popular Windows IDE. I think it was mostly triggered by the file name, maybe in combination with some crypto code inside.

> using a then-popular Windows IDE If you're referring to Delphi, this has been a common issue for a long time. Delphi seems to have been very popular with malware writers, and so AV companies keep flagging stuff from the standard libraries as malware. Got so bad at one time that some tried to get a deal with the major AV players to provide a suite of very basic Delphi applications they could use for false-positive t…

This is so sad.

Re: Windows Defender blocks qBittorrent

#205
post #189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> * "Linux doesn't support Photoshop / MS Excel / Altium / SolidWorks" "You don't need those things anyway, Krita / LibreOffice Calc / etc are good enough. Alternatively, don't they run in Wine?" > * "Microsoft's fanatical devotion to binary backwards-compatibility means I don't have to worry old software will break because I've got the wrong version of python installed, or my version of libreadline is too new." "Peo…

"Single button mouse"... You did exactly this. Edit: changed to the relevant statement

People really latched on to that "single button mouse" thing, completely ignoring the other 2 reasons I listed that I don't like MacOS. Not to mention that I wasn't telling people they should use Windows or criticising their reasoning for using MacOS.

Re: Windows Defender blocks qBittorrent

#207
post #157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interesting ideas here: how antivirus becomes a form of censorship. Maybe that’s an extreme view but it feels like now that Microsoft supplies it’s own defender app. And like all forms of martial law beginning as a way to protect citizens! I also noticed that with win10 when apps crash it sends the data to Microsoft—as though they can fix 3rd party apps for us. Yeesh. I think I’ll skip out on Windows 11 TYVM.

This is incredibly hyperbolic. If you don't like Defender's default behavior (which is sane for the 99.999% of users who are not devs), turn it off or use a different OS.

Is it? I've personally seen it label keygen type files (with no malware whatsoever) as dangerous more times than I can count. It's false and misleading and I don't see why they couldn't pull the same shit with anything else.

Re: Windows Defender blocks qBittorrent

#208

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes that's why you have to unzip them on a Mac or Linux PC first. It does the same for Windows Loader by Daz and similar activation cracks for Windows 7/10.

...or you just disable Windows Defender.

You can also just whitelist it. It's how I maintain my LTSC variant

Re: Windows Defender blocks qBittorrent

#209
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You mean the act of torrenting on its own would cause you to fall victim to malware, or that the process of finding a torrent via certain sites would do so?

Both. Plenty of malware-infested executables in torrents.

Instead, just don't run executables from untrusted sources.

Torrents, email, mobile apps (like that fake banking iOS app that looks like the legit one) or otherwise. The transport method doesn't matter much.

Re: Windows Defender blocks qBittorrent

#210
post #17

Switching my home computer to Linux has had its problems since I'm an avid gamer, but the more news I read about Windows the less I regret that decision.

I set up a LAN box for my parents on a computer that my dad received for free. It came with Windows 10 on it, but wasn't very powerful - company's old hardware. After several...frustrating... hours of trying to talk them through things over the phone to get RDP working, just so I could install Docker to run some containers that didn't even work properly with networking, and having to call/text any time the machine th…

Have you checked https://www.protondb.com/ to see which games run well on Linux with Steam?

Lutris ( https://lutris.net/ ) also provides scripts for games that aren't on steam or bought on other stores.

You can also install Pop!OS which is another Linux distro for gaming (or so I've heard).

Post reply on HN