Live data from Hacker News

Amazon Is Creating Company Towns Across the United States

jacobinmag.com

21–30 of 271 posts

Re: Amazon Is Creating Company Towns Across the United States

#21
A key aspect of company towns is that there's only one serious employer. This then gives that employer a very dangerous amount of power, which is why we don't like this structure.

Possibly this is true in don't places with Amazon, but the article doesn't make the argument. The closest they get is saying that Amazon is a large employer in Seattle, but that's not enough -- the city is large enough that there are tons of non-Amazon options.

Re: Amazon Is Creating Company Towns Across the United States

#22
post #17

The article seems to contain nothing that would qualify for the words "Company Town". It appears to boil down "look amazon is big, surely it means that it must be evil!".

> The article seems to contain nothing that would qualify for the words "Company Town". It appears to boil down "look amazon is big, surely it means that it must be evil!". I guess this is the difference between a literal v. figurative interpretation of the title. The article itself is speaking to Amazon's efforts to sustain its hiring pipeline in the face of colossal churn, describing activities such as sponsoring s…

So what? The EU and other similar institutions require their branding to be present in classes too. I'd rather have obviously absurd corporate branding than slow but sure political indoctrination (e.g. the EU makes it look like the local government is incapable of doing anything on its own, while the fact is that everything worked pretty well before the EU and even today 90%+ of funding is local - but the EU flag must be displayed prominently!).

Re: Amazon Is Creating Company Towns Across the United States

#23
Is there an argument for not having Amazon as an employer in these towns?

Is there an argument for not having Amazon support the local school system?

I understand that working conditions are rarely ideal. Many would prefer to enjoy leisure and collect a paycheck as the ideal source of income. Jobs pay because workers need an incentive to provide labor.

What exactly would JacobinMag.com's alternative to Amazon employment look like?

Why aren't they providing this alternative?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy#Perfect_soluti...

Re: Amazon Is Creating Company Towns Across the United States

#24

The article seems to contain nothing that would qualify for the words "Company Town". It appears to boil down "look amazon is big, surely it means that it must be evil!".

It’s on Jacobin, so this is to be expected. Not exactly a neutral publication.

Re: Amazon Is Creating Company Towns Across the United States

#26
post #22
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The article seems to contain nothing that would qualify for the words "Company Town". It appears to boil down "look amazon is big, surely it means that it must be evil!". I guess this is the difference between a literal v. figurative interpretation of the title. The article itself is speaking to Amazon's efforts to sustain its hiring pipeline in the face of colossal churn, describing activities such as sponsoring s…

So what? The EU and other similar institutions require their branding to be present in classes too. I'd rather have obviously absurd corporate branding than slow but sure political indoctrination (e.g. the EU makes it look like the local government is incapable of doing anything on its own, while the fact is that everything worked pretty well before the EU and even today 90%+ of funding is local - but the EU flag mus…

> require their branding to be present in classes too

No they don't.

Re: Amazon Is Creating Company Towns Across the United States

#27
>$15 an hour, Amazon’s starting wage, is below the average for the warehousing industry

Where are they getting this information? The average wage in the US is lower, like $13-14.

https://www.indeed.com/career/warehouse-worker/salaries

https://www.payscale.com/research/US/Job=Warehouse_Worker/Ho...

Re: Amazon Is Creating Company Towns Across the United States

#28
An extremely efficient and competent corporation doing everything it can to deliver goods cheaper and faster to hundreds of millions of people while creating value for tens of millions of shareholders? And now it has more and more impact running social services too?

How dare they do this travesty without democratic oversight. Clearly the best way forward is to regulate them so that they are on a level playing field with other democratically overseen government services.

Re: Amazon Is Creating Company Towns Across the United States

#29
post #22
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The article seems to contain nothing that would qualify for the words "Company Town". It appears to boil down "look amazon is big, surely it means that it must be evil!". I guess this is the difference between a literal v. figurative interpretation of the title. The article itself is speaking to Amazon's efforts to sustain its hiring pipeline in the face of colossal churn, describing activities such as sponsoring s…

So what? The EU and other similar institutions require their branding to be present in classes too. I'd rather have obviously absurd corporate branding than slow but sure political indoctrination (e.g. the EU makes it look like the local government is incapable of doing anything on its own, while the fact is that everything worked pretty well before the EU and even today 90%+ of funding is local - but the EU flag mus…

>>while the fact is that everything worked pretty well before the EU

I don't know where you're from, but as a Pole I do not share this sentiment at all. Seeing the EU flag displayed everywhere makes me proud to be an EU citizen and it's a great thing to see.

Re: Amazon Is Creating Company Towns Across the United States

#30

The article seems to contain nothing that would qualify for the words "Company Town". It appears to boil down "look amazon is big, surely it means that it must be evil!".

Even the phrase "company town" itself does not signify anything evil. In fact I'm wondering if such a place might be better than the usual government administered cities and towns.

Honestly, I was hoping Amazon was actually making housing for its workers. I think high density housing within walking distance of your job is the realistic solution for lowering co2 emissions.
Post reply on HN