Live data from Hacker News

EU plans to make Bitcoin transfers more traceable

bbc.com

231–240 of 402 posts

Re: EU plans to make Bitcoin transfers more traceable

#231
post #141

I’m amazed by how short sighted most of the comments here are. When it comes to large financial operations, society has clearly chosen transparency over privacy. Cause guess what, tax evasion, money laundering, political fixing, terrorism financing are things that exist and really are hurtful to our economies. Stop fantasizing that the government cares about the shit you buy. This is not about you. And Bitcoin’s anon…

Funding terrorism and tax evasion are incredibly rare. I mean it, not-credibly rare. The main difficulty in discerning that is legality. Is this person/company evading taxes according to the law . Is this person allowed to purchase $5,000 of Syrian saffron on wish.com? No, I'm afraid governments already track all data necessary to pursue and convict tax evasion and terrorists. We don't need to sacrifice this new, exc…

> tax evasion are incredibly rare.

It is extremely common where I live, India. To an extent that, going by official statistics, paying tax is rare.

I agree with your second assertion though. The government is tracking more and more transactions by making it mandatory to use tax ID for transactions above a certain threshold.

Re: EU plans to make Bitcoin transfers more traceable

#232
post #141

I’m amazed by how short sighted most of the comments here are. When it comes to large financial operations, society has clearly chosen transparency over privacy. Cause guess what, tax evasion, money laundering, political fixing, terrorism financing are things that exist and really are hurtful to our economies. Stop fantasizing that the government cares about the shit you buy. This is not about you. And Bitcoin’s anon…

Well, transparency works both ways doesn't it? Governments are largely not transparent. If they were, you wouldn't have something like the CIA, Guantanamo bay and the entire surveillance enterprise. I am just quoting the US government as an example but most governments are more or less the same. Expecting others to be transparent, while governments go on about their private secret activities is very unfair. Case in p…

A 6700-page report (1) and a Hollywood movie were made about Gitmo. Just like climate change, the issue is not one of knowledge or information.

(1) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Senate_Intelligence_Committe...

Re: EU plans to make Bitcoin transfers more traceable

#233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

credit and debit cards are rate regulated in the EU to a 0.2% maximum fee and moving money between users these days is usually free completely with almost any payment service or bank account. Cryptocurrency fees are significantly more expensive, and process a fraction of the transactions. The ability to have a monetary policy is a bonus and it's the reason centralized money is price stable. If you were paid your sala…

>Cryptocurrency fees are significantly more expensive That statement makes no sense. Crypto transfer fees are not a percentage of the transferred amount.

For bitcoin at the moment you have to move around $1300 before the fee is less than 0.2%

And around $2400 for etherium. Which means that in the common use as a payment it will be more expensive. On top of that you get into questionable situations if the shop owner wants to charge differently because of the fee as that is already disallowed for plastic cards.

Re: EU plans to make Bitcoin transfers more traceable

#235
post #167

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you mean not long ago when the government budget was 1% of GDP? Nowadays it's 40-60%, in developed countries. Large levels of public spending are a choice that we have made as a society, and the spending needs to be funded somehow.

> Large levels of public spending are a choice that we have made as a society It most certainly isn't a choice we've made democratically. Rather, it's a case of boiling the frog: a thousand tiny cuts inflicted by elected politicians over the very long term which has slowly led to the monster size leech our government has become.

No, most people are just stupid enough to elect the one promising the most.

Re: EU plans to make Bitcoin transfers more traceable

#236
post #228
post #141

I’m amazed by how short sighted most of the comments here are. When it comes to large financial operations, society has clearly chosen transparency over privacy. Cause guess what, tax evasion, money laundering, political fixing, terrorism financing are things that exist and really are hurtful to our economies. Stop fantasizing that the government cares about the shit you buy. This is not about you. And Bitcoin’s anon…

Bitcoin's goal was to help people "get out" of the traditional financial system "not inside it". Everyone knows where the real money laundering and terrorist financing happens. It is done by the likes of HSBC, Standard Chartered and other big banks. This is public knowledge, as we have seen with the Panama papers and most recently the FinCen files. Our financial institutions are too rotten for you to even assume that…

"Getting out" is very fuzzy goal. For my understanding people usually cite two central goals:

1. Stop central bank imposed inflation.

2. Serve the people who are excluded from banking.

If either of those goals can't be reached, it is due to misdesign/inherent flaws of the approach and not governments.

Re: EU plans to make Bitcoin transfers more traceable

#237

I'm ok with this. Ideally private persons should have an allowance of around 5.000€ (or so) per month in privacy coin usage, where an invoice is the only traceable thing, and everything above that amount should be fully transparent to the authorities (IRS), and pseudoanonymously visible to the public, for journalists to be detectable. Buy a car? -> IRS can see it. Buy a home? -> IRS can see it. Buy a Smartphone? -> N…

The issue with any 'cap' is that the batches just get sharded to be under that cap and you get the 'working from home' style mix of scam and money laundering.

As the sibling links, the answer is anonymity for spenders, but not for recipients of money. This also, ideally, blocks moral panics and instead forces law enforcement to go after cash flow into 'bad activities' and actors.

Re: EU plans to make Bitcoin transfers more traceable

#239

I'm ok with this. Ideally private persons should have an allowance of around 5.000€ (or so) per month in privacy coin usage, where an invoice is the only traceable thing, and everything above that amount should be fully transparent to the authorities (IRS), and pseudoanonymously visible to the public, for journalists to be detectable. Buy a car? -> IRS can see it. Buy a home? -> IRS can see it. Buy a Smartphone? -> N…

IMO, I should be able to spend a zillion dollars on whatever I want, as long as I'm not buying people it's none of anyone's business.

The way to make sure everyone pays taxes is to tax property, or sales, or do a value added tax. Want a progressive tax? Higher taxes on second properties, or luxury items. Now you don't have any reason to need to know what everyone in the world has or does with their money.

Re: EU plans to make Bitcoin transfers more traceable

#240
post #228
post #141

I’m amazed by how short sighted most of the comments here are. When it comes to large financial operations, society has clearly chosen transparency over privacy. Cause guess what, tax evasion, money laundering, political fixing, terrorism financing are things that exist and really are hurtful to our economies. Stop fantasizing that the government cares about the shit you buy. This is not about you. And Bitcoin’s anon…

Bitcoin's goal was to help people "get out" of the traditional financial system "not inside it". Everyone knows where the real money laundering and terrorist financing happens. It is done by the likes of HSBC, Standard Chartered and other big banks. This is public knowledge, as we have seen with the Panama papers and most recently the FinCen files. Our financial institutions are too rotten for you to even assume that…

> It is done by the likes of HSBC, Standard Chartered and other big banks.

And, as it happens, because of the records, it has been discovered and everyone involved is traceable. The system works.

Post reply on HN