Live data from Hacker News

Blue Origin first human flight

blueorigin.com

61–70 of 504 posts

Re: Blue Origin first human flight

#61

This felt so underwhelming. I don't know if it's because I've seen SpaceX doing much more complicated missions or it's just not that big of a deal. They got about two minutes of zero G and came down immediately. You can experience that for much longer with a regular plane, for much less money. It really shouldn't count as space travel unless they go into orbit around Earth.

Im very happy for Wally Funk

Re: Blue Origin first human flight

#62

This felt so underwhelming. I don't know if it's because I've seen SpaceX doing much more complicated missions or it's just not that big of a deal. They got about two minutes of zero G and came down immediately. You can experience that for much longer with a regular plane, for much less money. It really shouldn't count as space travel unless they go into orbit around Earth.

i feel pretty guilty for being so underwhelmed because I sure as hell couldn't build an engine and airframe to do that but I am. I think the duration and lack of events is what did it. I'm use to the multiple phases of a falcon9 launch and the landing.

However, i'm glad BlueOrigin did this and had a successful launch/landing. It certainly helps inspire others and is good for the industry as a whole.

Re: Blue Origin first human flight

#63
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't see a race. I see one company that does space travel and two dilettantes, who may or may not one day actually do something useful.

Blue Origin is the closest to actually developing useful orbital and beyond-orbital capabilities. They have their own new engine design that's not quite as impressive as Raptor but not bad and their own super-heavy lift booster in development. The thing you just saw fly is similar to "Starhopper." Virgin Galactic is an expensive carnival ride and has nothing close to orbital capability. For those that don't know: get…

Virgin galactic does go to orbit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgin_Orbit

They launched satellites earlier this year.

The space tourism thing is just a part of what the company does.

Re: Blue Origin first human flight

#64
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't see a race. I see one company that does space travel and two dilettantes, who may or may not one day actually do something useful.

Blue Origin is the closest to actually developing useful orbital and beyond-orbital capabilities. They have their own new engine design that's not quite as impressive as Raptor but not bad and their own super-heavy lift booster in development. The thing you just saw fly is similar to "Starhopper." Virgin Galactic is an expensive carnival ride and has nothing close to orbital capability. For those that don't know: get…

> The thing you just saw fly is similar to "Starhopper."

I think you mean "Grasshopper" (the Falcon 9 VTOL test mule from a few years back). New Shepard is less than half the size of Starhopper, and the BE-3 engine has ~25% of the thrust of the Raptor engine.

Re: Blue Origin first human flight

#65

Seems that between Musk, Bezos and Branson, we have in essence restarted a space race but this time it's billionaires in the private sector versus governments. Some will surely say that they have better things to spend their money on (Bezos for sure) but I gave to say it's still mindblowing. I would imagine if you're one of those guys, you've basically have enough money to solve any problem, so these guys it seems ar…

It takes a special kind of awful person to think that this is the hard problem they should solve with their billions.

Re: Blue Origin first human flight

#66
post #41

This felt so underwhelming. I don't know if it's because I've seen SpaceX doing much more complicated missions or it's just not that big of a deal. They got about two minutes of zero G and came down immediately. You can experience that for much longer with a regular plane, for much less money. It really shouldn't count as space travel unless they go into orbit around Earth.

> It really shouldn't count as space travel unless they go into orbit around Earth. Translation: 'Other private companies building their own rockets and going into space is 'not good enough' unless it is by SpaceX' and doesn't count. To SpaceX fanatics and downvoters: I'm sure you are deep fanatics of SpaceX but surely you have the funds and deep pockets to join Musk and friends on a space mission together right now?…

The Russian v. USA space race’s important milestones included putting satellites, animals and people into orbit. It wasn’t just merely launching them to the edge of spacs.

Re: Blue Origin first human flight

#67
post #63
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Blue Origin is the closest to actually developing useful orbital and beyond-orbital capabilities. They have their own new engine design that's not quite as impressive as Raptor but not bad and their own super-heavy lift booster in development. The thing you just saw fly is similar to "Starhopper." Virgin Galactic is an expensive carnival ride and has nothing close to orbital capability. For those that don't know: get…

Virgin galactic does go to orbit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgin_Orbit They launched satellites earlier this year. The space tourism thing is just a part of what the company does.

Virgin Galactic doesn't go to orbit, Virgin Orbit does.

Re: Blue Origin first human flight

#68

Seems that between Musk, Bezos and Branson, we have in essence restarted a space race but this time it's billionaires in the private sector versus governments. Some will surely say that they have better things to spend their money on (Bezos for sure) but I gave to say it's still mindblowing. I would imagine if you're one of those guys, you've basically have enough money to solve any problem, so these guys it seems ar…

I can't help but thinking we've entered another Gilded Age.

Re: Blue Origin first human flight

#69
post #63
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Blue Origin is the closest to actually developing useful orbital and beyond-orbital capabilities. They have their own new engine design that's not quite as impressive as Raptor but not bad and their own super-heavy lift booster in development. The thing you just saw fly is similar to "Starhopper." Virgin Galactic is an expensive carnival ride and has nothing close to orbital capability. For those that don't know: get…

Virgin galactic does go to orbit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgin_Orbit They launched satellites earlier this year. The space tourism thing is just a part of what the company does.

Wow... I didn't even know about that. I stand corrected.

SpaceX is still way ahead though.

Post reply on HN