Live data from Hacker News

When Vaccine Apathy, Not Hesitancy, Drives Vaccine Disinterest

jamanetwork.com

11–20 of 66 posts

Re: When Vaccine Apathy, Not Hesitancy, Drives Vaccine Disinterest

#11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People who don't want the vaccine and don't want to be harassed for it.

> People who don't want the vaccine and don't want to be harassed for it That’s easy to do—stay on private property. This country’s laws were written to protect those rights. With WFH, it’s more plausible than ever.

Accepting proof of antibodies would be an even better way for everyone to get what they want right?

Re: When Vaccine Apathy, Not Hesitancy, Drives Vaccine Disinterest

#12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> People who don't want the vaccine and don't want to be harassed for it That’s easy to do—stay on private property. This country’s laws were written to protect those rights. With WFH, it’s more plausible than ever.

Accepting proof of antibodies would be an even better way for everyone to get what they want right?

Unfortunately, no. Natural immunity is less durable against variants [1]. (Proof of exposure should be fine, though, for low-risk stuff in areas not undergoing an outbreak.)

Given that and assuming we’ll have a permanently unvaccinated population, the virus would be expected to keep reinfecting that group, thereby increasing the selection pressure for strains that reinfect.

[1] https://directorsblog.nih.gov/2021/06/22/how-immunity-genera...

Re: When Vaccine Apathy, Not Hesitancy, Drives Vaccine Disinterest

#13

99.5% of those dying from Covid in America are unvaccinated. 99.5%. At a certain point, I don’t know what to say, but the train has to leave the station. If you choose to run around unvaccinated and get Covid, the rest of us shouldn’t have to (a) shut down our lives or (b) pay tax dollars to save you if you end up in the hospital or dealing with the costs of long Covid. (See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stupid_Moto…

The problem is that you can't differentiate between "stupid" and "justifiably ignorant" or just "scarred by history".

Black people were literally experimented on under the guise of vaccination programs. They have no reason to believe that isn't going to happen again.

And then you just have millions of people who don't know basic biology or medicine, and vaccines are no more fathomable than magic.

Add lots of misinfo from Facebook to that mess, and you have people who can't always be blamed for their fear.

Re: When Vaccine Apathy, Not Hesitancy, Drives Vaccine Disinterest

#14

99.5% of those dying from Covid in America are unvaccinated. 99.5%. At a certain point, I don’t know what to say, but the train has to leave the station. If you choose to run around unvaccinated and get Covid, the rest of us shouldn’t have to (a) shut down our lives or (b) pay tax dollars to save you if you end up in the hospital or dealing with the costs of long Covid. (See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stupid_Moto…

If you read the essay they made a good example of why black people are hesitant- their history of mistreatment by a racist medical industry. So to say we should leave these people “SOL” strikes me as deeply non-sympathetic to efforts at reparative racial health justice. Another thought I had is that figuring out ways to influence (trick?) these people into making the “right” choice now wrt vaxxing may not make them less hesitant about “following advice” in the future.

Re: When Vaccine Apathy, Not Hesitancy, Drives Vaccine Disinterest

#15
post #4

Why is there no widespread antibody testing to see if we've reached herd immunity? The push to vaccinate is only necessary if we're not there yet. I recall a study from a couple months ago claiming several times more people caught the virus than was generally thought.

We don't need testing to figure out of we are at herd immunity. We know we are not, because the virus is spreading still and increasing speed now. It is only really an issue amongst unvaccinated. This population is basically anti-vax, apathetic, or children for whom the government has banned from getting the vaccine, regardless of circumstance.

In France, most people infected are young (< 55 years old), part of it because we could only access the vaccine at a later date than older people. Everyone that I know got their two shots, but most of them got the second less than a week ago.

Re: When Vaccine Apathy, Not Hesitancy, Drives Vaccine Disinterest

#16
post #4

Why is there no widespread antibody testing to see if we've reached herd immunity? The push to vaccinate is only necessary if we're not there yet. I recall a study from a couple months ago claiming several times more people caught the virus than was generally thought.

We don't need testing to figure out of we are at herd immunity. We know we are not, because the virus is spreading still and increasing speed now. It is only really an issue amongst unvaccinated. This population is basically anti-vax, apathetic, or children for whom the government has banned from getting the vaccine, regardless of circumstance.

Or, if you read the featured article, black people and native Americans who rightfully do not trust the racist medical system.

Re: When Vaccine Apathy, Not Hesitancy, Drives Vaccine Disinterest

#17
post #13

99.5% of those dying from Covid in America are unvaccinated. 99.5%. At a certain point, I don’t know what to say, but the train has to leave the station. If you choose to run around unvaccinated and get Covid, the rest of us shouldn’t have to (a) shut down our lives or (b) pay tax dollars to save you if you end up in the hospital or dealing with the costs of long Covid. (See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stupid_Moto…

The problem is that you can't differentiate between "stupid" and "justifiably ignorant" or just "scarred by history". Black people were literally experimented on under the guise of vaccination programs. They have no reason to believe that isn't going to happen again. And then you just have millions of people who don't know basic biology or medicine, and vaccines are no more fathomable than magic. Add lots of misinfo…

> the rest of us shouldn’t have to (a) shut down our lives or (b) pay tax dollars to save you if you end up in the hospital or deal with the costs of long Covid

still remains true and you didn’t present a counterpoint to that

Re: When Vaccine Apathy, Not Hesitancy, Drives Vaccine Disinterest

#18

Why is there no widespread antibody testing to see if we've reached herd immunity? The push to vaccinate is only necessary if we're not there yet. I recall a study from a couple months ago claiming several times more people caught the virus than was generally thought.

The problem with herd immunity is that the rate differs based on the variant. For something much more transmissible (like the Delta variant), herd immunity numbers are much different than for the original one. There's an argument that the US reached herd immunity on the original one pretty early on in vaccinations. And alpha with current vaccination rates. It's clear we haven't with Delta because numbers are going wa…

Immunity to one would be immunity to the other

They use the same vector for infection which so the immunities offer protection against. The protection mechanism is a game of catch up though.

Re: When Vaccine Apathy, Not Hesitancy, Drives Vaccine Disinterest

#19

There’s also just plain distrust of government and media pushing something. Our trust in government and media is so low that when they say do something, most rational people are immediately suspicious.

Exactly this. There is an unbelievable irony in the fact that the current administration is on a intense PR push to get unvaccinated Americans to trust the vaccines and get vaccinated when they specifically communicated during their (Biden and Harris) campaigns last year their distrust regarding the vaccine due to its association with Trump, speed of development, and experimental nature.

This is what happens when people check in their common sense for political allegiances. I have no doubt that if Trump had won, we would still be having this issue of the distrustful unvaccinated, but their politics would be more on the democrats side.

Post reply on HN