Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Would you like to see this site become CS/Startup related only?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 81 posts

Poll: Would you like to see this site become CS/Startup related only?

#1
The exact guidelines as to what belongs on this site, as written in the current edition, are as follows:

"On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.

Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic. "

This is pretty vague, and there seems to be a lot of crossover, as it's entirely possible for an article about politics to be intellectually stimulating. For instance what is going on in Zimbabwe is sometimes covered on TV news, but usually never with the sort of depth found in the link that inspired the thread that inspired this poll.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=278342

So my question is, would you like to see the site's guidelines narrowed such that only CS/startup related links are considered on-topic? This is for no purpose other than to satisfy my own curiosity about what the general consensus here is.

Re: Poll: Would you like to see this site become CS/Startup related only?

#3
This is a tough vote for me, because I enjoy spending my time with CS/hacker related content and yet I fancy politics.

But what I do have a problem with is the links to subscription-only content. Very often, it appears that the Wall Street Journal articles are submitted and approved to HN, but when I go to try and view this article(usually with a great title- often that might be something I would like to read), it turns out that I need to be a subscriber to the WSJ - hogwash! If this is all about what good hackers would find interesting, IMO, it should be in the realm of the free too. In other words, articles that require a subscription should not be submitted... unless of course all of HN's readers have a subscription and I'm just missing out...

Re: Poll: Would you like to see this site become CS/Startup related only?

#6
I would add a forth choice personally:

mostly cs/hacker stuff, with some intellectually stimulating stuff

That's actually the balance I feel we have right now.

I voted for "no, anything intellectually stimulating" because that seems to be what we have no and it seems to be working (for me).

Re: Poll: Would you like to see this site become CS/Startup related only?

#7
I wish I could vote for 1 and 2, like "yes, cs/hacker stuff that's intellectually stimulating."

news.ycombinator.com is less interesting to me now than when it was known as Startup News. In the year that it's been called "Hacker News" the posts have been far more general than I'd like. If I wanted that I'd spend time at Reddit.

Re: Poll: Would you like to see this site become CS/Startup related only?

#9
post #4

if you want cs/hacker + politics, go to reddit. I personally think the way the site is no is perfect, sure some offtopic stuff goes to the front page, but almost all of the content is cs/hacker/startup only

Thank you for your suggestion.. but I like the simplistic and minimal nature of HN. Further, I think what really gets to me more is the submits requiring a subscription.

Re: Poll: Would you like to see this site become CS/Startup related only?

#10
Around what it is now, I think.

Though you've got to remember a lot of people here aren't in the US, so while all the US politics would be interesting to the American hackers, what about hackers from other parts of the world, which very likely make up more of a percentage combined than Americans?

Thats why I would prefer for submissions to be: "Something an english speaking hacker anywhere in the world would be interested in."

:)

Post reply on HN