Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What do you see as red flags in a job application process?

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–10 of 25 posts

Re: Ask HN: What do you see as red flags in a job application process?

#3

Post by chaosharmonic »

I'm also going to throw my own gripe here: applicant tracking platforms that require you to set up logins in order to apply for a job.

There's a lot about typical application processes that's just... kind of obnoxious. Making people manually correct the bad parsing your tracker does on uploading your resume? That's clunky and annoying, and a failure to respect your applicants' time. Making people beg for a job by writing up a 500 word essay about what excites you about them specifically, along with their opinions about puppies just so that you know it was personally crafted? (And yes, I've seen that specifically.) That's kind of demeaning, and a failure to respect your applicants' time.

But requiring that they create a discrete user account, for something they're effectively going to interact with once, that in all likelihood is using a recycled login and going to be forgotten in a week? That's on a completely separate level -- it's a failure to respect your applicants' security, by pointlessly adding to the risk that their user credentials are going to show up on Have I Been Pwned someday, and it's just irresponsible.

Re: Ask HN: What do you see as red flags in a job application process?

#4

Post by warrenm »

- demanding to know previous salaries

- trivia questions in the interview (https://antipaucity.com/2011/10/03/doing-technical-phone-scr...)

- don't know why they're hiring you (eg "we think we' have more projects after this one...")

- can't explain benefits in a couple simple sentences

- they require you to be in X location ...but won't pay to relocate you

- won't accommodate salary/title/etc to your actual experience/expectations

There're 6

I bet I could add another 20 if I worked at it

Re: Ask HN: What do you see as red flags in a job application process?

#8

Post by westcort »

"Vacation is accrued over the first year" and it turns out that means you can't take any vacation for a year. Benefits cost more than they would through the exchanges...and they get a kickback when employees do not use the insurance, so it's a moneymaker for them. Also, the insurance requires disclosing all health conditions on an unprotected form that goes to HR creating an incentive for hiring younger and healthier people. There is a core group of long-serving employees and a revolving door for others. "Family" atmosphere in general--that is not a model for a workplace, it is a model for a family.

Re: Ask HN: What do you see as red flags in a job application process?

#9

Post by kody »

Red:

- You can do anything (frontend backend ci/cd backend product management IT)

- We’re a family here

- Yeet ninja 10x rockstars, “you friends see you as a badass hacker” (yes I saw the latter in a job description)

- 120k - 165k for a junior position

I haven’t gotten enough jobs to have a clear green flag filter, but my most delightful interviewing experiences have been take home projects to demonstrate ability to reason about a domain that pertains to the job for which I’m applying. E.g. “build a web server that can return X and memoizes results, bonus points for creating a one-click-run Docker image for the project”.

Post reply on HN