Live data from Hacker News

It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors are important to you

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 192 posts

Re: It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors are important to you

#41

“We care about your privacy.” is also a real joker. Those boxes often provide no “opt-out all” button and force you to “object” to “legitimate interests” one-by-one even if you do “opt-out”.

It used to be the most common lie was "I have read the EULA". Nowadays the most common lie is "we care about your privacy" or possibly "we get it, you hate ads".

Re: It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors are important to you

#43
I have been very grateful for GDPR, because on lots of sites the very first question is "do I care enough about this content to try and click a bunch of buttons?" Nine times out of ten the answer is no and I just close the tab without reading the article, and I genuinely think I'm happier for it. I certainly have more time.

Re: It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors are important to you

#44

What I don't understand is, why are these local US news sites required to comply with GDPR? I wouldn't think they'd have any obligation to follow it (or any possible recourse for not doing so) unless they have business operations in the EU. Are these local news sites in fact all owned by multinationals that do have operations in the EU? Edit: I'm getting downvoted -- just in case it helps to clarify, I'm not trying t…

The EU can still, in theory, sue them because they're serving Europeans. Especially in the beginning many companies became afraid of the possibility so they simply blocked access to see where it goes. Then it probably became clear the European customers are not worth the effort to change back. But actually it's still illegal what they're doing because the GDPR also states that customers have to be treated neutral regardless of their location, as long as it's not about licensing of course.

Re: It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors are important to you

#45

What I don't understand is, why are these local US news sites required to comply with GDPR? I wouldn't think they'd have any obligation to follow it (or any possible recourse for not doing so) unless they have business operations in the EU. Are these local news sites in fact all owned by multinationals that do have operations in the EU? Edit: I'm getting downvoted -- just in case it helps to clarify, I'm not trying t…

I understand it as: if you're taking my data as European citizen, that is protected; even if you're in the US I'm still European.

Re: It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors are important to you

#47

I always read this as: "Our European visitors are important to us BUT vacuuming all your data and selling to multiple bidders is importanter " You wanna be obnoxious? Sure, go ahead, but I'll dislike your site more (and I have adblock so I have no qualms in accepting). Wanna pretend you're compliant by having an obvious non-compliant "solution" and think that will shield your responsibility? Now I'll just hate you an…

Except the GDPR doesn't work as sold.

How so?

Re: It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors are important to you

#48

Jeez, what a mess. To extend the McDonald’s analogy, when McDonald’s is serving its American customers, it doesn’t heed European laws about beef and potatoes. Because those laws are irrelevant to them, they have no bearing on McDonald’s making money (again in the context of serving their American customers). McDonald’s is never going to check what Brussels says about dairy before they make a milkshake in Spokane. Sor…

[deleted]

Re: It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors are important to you

#49
> Every now and then, a link to an interesting news article is suggested to me.

If the link looks like something worth the effort, plug it in to archive.is and read the output there. Or try it via outline.com instead. These tend to work for most text-based articles/sites, and archive.is often breezes right through paywalls, too.

Re: It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors are important to you

#50

Before GDPR passed I heard nothing but "I don't want to patronize a site that doesn't want to respect my privacy" and "we don't need sites that won't follow basic rules like this". Well you got your wish. Your internet is no longer polluted with these reprehensible site owners. Yet people continue to bitch and moan.

The moan is about the language used, not the availability of the site.
Post reply on HN