Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Hera (YC S21) – macOS app to prepare, join and take notes in meetings

news.ycombinator.com

61–70 of 120 posts

Re: Launch HN: Hera (YC S21) – macOS app to prepare, join and take notes in meetings

#61
post #7

sorry to undermine your efforts but someone has to say this: as a Mac user, i won't be paying $100/year for electron app will stick to itsycal, a freeware, "real" macOS app, i've paid $10 for not affiliated, but feel free to check out: https://www.mowglii.com/itsycal/

I honestly wouldn't be able to tell whether it's electron or anything else... maybe people who can tell them apart aren't the target group for this?

Re: Launch HN: Hera (YC S21) – macOS app to prepare, join and take notes in meetings

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Understood, right now your meeting notes are not encrypted, but stored in a secure database on our server. We are currently considering two options to make sure your notes are safe: either end-to-end encryption on our servers or offline-based storage for your notes. Thanks for the remark

I was super excited until I saw this; I guess I'll have to wait. Offline storage is essential for a number of reasons, not the least of which is the ability to reach my notes if Hera is having an outage.

Totally understandable!

Re: Launch HN: Hera (YC S21) – macOS app to prepare, join and take notes in meetings

#63
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, it's not: You can see Hera as a note-taking app entirely dedicated to meetings. It's easy to take notes in meetings, capture highlights or next actions that you can then either export to other tools or easily access in your future meetings.

thanks for explanation! and sorry for me being hostile should say, the automation feature is pretty neat though :)

No problem, thanks for taking the time to comment :)

Re: Launch HN: Hera (YC S21) – macOS app to prepare, join and take notes in meetings

#64
post #24

Really like this, congrats on the launch! To the people moaning about Electron apps... you're not the market. To the people moaning about $100 price... you're not the market. To the people moaning about Mac-only... you're not the market. To the people who missed the value-prop COMPLETELY and think some free taskbar widget is the whole idea... you're not the market. IMO if you're managing 10+ people and have 10+ meeti…

> To the people moaning about Electron apps... you're not the market. To the people moaning about $100 price... you're not the market. To the people moaning about Mac-only... you're not the market. To the people who missed the value-prop COMPLETELY and think some free taskbar widget is the whole idea... you're not the market. Then who's the market? Because it's obviously not us and I think the (accepts Electrons) ∩ (…

pays for expensive apps: 100s of millions of people uses mac os: 100s of millions knows what electron is: 431,882 weekly downloads.

I'm making a bit of a joke here, but the market is plenty huge for this app. Also, not all of Hackernews is developers who have opinions on electron. e.g. Me.

Re: Launch HN: Hera (YC S21) – macOS app to prepare, join and take notes in meetings

#65
post #39

Hu bruno, I really like the project. There was an a comment by someone about $100 for a mac app. We pay for a many mac apps that solves a problem for us and at present meetings are an issue. I have been juggling among apps to solve this exact issue. The alternatives suggested like itsycal and meeter don't've the note taking and template support especially to look at the history of notes in previous meetings. This is…

Totally get that the safety of your meeting notes is top priority. We have not yet settled on whether we want to choose the "notes stored locally" path or the "fully encrypted on our server" path, mainly because of the impact on features we want to build in the upcoming years.

We will communicate publicly as soon as we take a strong stance.

Re: Launch HN: Hera (YC S21) – macOS app to prepare, join and take notes in meetings

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hey Bruno - sounds like a cool concept - wishing you both all the best! Just looking at the screenshot (and being afflicted with the pedantry of being the son of an English teacher), would ‘Ready to take back control of your meetings?’ be more usual/a little less clumsy wording-wise? Not that I think what you’ve written is ‘wrong’ - in some ways it’s fresher/more unusual (‘Ready to bring sexy back to meetings?’ :), b…

touché , our french origin is exposed :) We've had this feedback before, I am going to change that, thanks for the suggestion!

‘En garde!’/‘Zut alors! Pas de problème, mon ami! (…that’s probably all wrong heheh..) Your English is certainement a billion times better than my French! :) Bonne chance!

Re: Launch HN: Hera (YC S21) – macOS app to prepare, join and take notes in meetings

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good insight, I agree with you. We have found great fit with co-founders of early stage start-ups and product managers in high growth start-ups. Mac is overly present in this target audience, hence our initial start on MacOS! That being said, it's on us to show users that a well-crafted Electron app can behave as nicely as a native one. Down the road, we might switch to a native app if we believe it would significant…

If you are considering a native version, then you are not prioritizing multiplatform which is Electron's strong point. Why choosing it insted of something like Catalyst? Mind you, I am not against Electron apps on my mac (Evernote user here heh)

Good question, mainly two points: 1. We had deep expertise in Electron and web dev. We are 4 months old so we wanted to validate the problem AND our solution as quickly as possible.

2. Meetings, by essence, have many stakeholders. Some (if not most) of the attendees are not on Hera and this is where having our core product mostly web compatible will proved to be useful - we can easily spin up for instance a public page to share the outcomes of your meeting to people not using hera

Re: Launch HN: Hera (YC S21) – macOS app to prepare, join and take notes in meetings

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

touché , our french origin is exposed :) We've had this feedback before, I am going to change that, thanks for the suggestion!

‘En garde!’/‘Zut alors! Pas de problème, mon ami! (…that’s probably all wrong heheh..) Your English is certainement a billion times better than my French! :) Bonne chance!

Merci!!

Re: Launch HN: Hera (YC S21) – macOS app to prepare, join and take notes in meetings

#69
post #43

why would anybody keep using this, when macOS Monterrey is on the way and it has "Quick Notes" built in ? https://www.apple.com/macos/monterey-preview/

Hmm. It seems you posted this after apologizing for being hostile in another thread, where Hera’s capabilities (which are… very different from “Quick Notes”) were explained to you. You’ve made several comments at this point incorrectly summarizing and then dismissing the project. What’s your aim here?

Re: Launch HN: Hera (YC S21) – macOS app to prepare, join and take notes in meetings

#70
I love the idea of a desktop app, but don’t understand the monthly fee. What’s the advantage to me as a user to pay $10/month for the rest of my career.

Is it possible that you could figure out a one time price that lets me buy the software? I like the idea of improving my meetings, but try to minimize recurring fees.

Also the price/value seems wonky as I pay $10/month for office365 with a TB of cloud storage

Post reply on HN