Live data from Hacker News

What are the odds we are living in a computer simulation? (2016)

newyorker.com

41–50 of 127 posts

Re: What are the odds we are living in a computer simulation? (2016)

#41
post #25

I’ve had a reoccurring dream since childhood about our universe being a B+ assignment in an extraterrestrial middle school classroom and that in effect I’m a npc in that effort. Whenever this subject comes up I’m always a bit interested but it seems like an impossible thing to know.

“Extraterrestrial” somehow implies that they would live in the same universe as us, doesn’t it?

Re: What are the odds we are living in a computer simulation? (2016)

#42
post #33

If it is a simulation, what are the odds that it's a game? The great majority of simulations that we know about are games. If it is a game, what are the odds that you are a non player character? In games, the vast majority of characters aren't the player. So if we are living in a computer simulation, odds are that we're non player characters.

Maybe you are not an NPC but an actual playable character to someone and the whole concept of you thinking that you are in control is part of the system.

But yeah, odds are much higher you are just an NPC for decorative purposes ...

Re: What are the odds we are living in a computer simulation? (2016)

#43
post #33

If it is a simulation, what are the odds that it's a game? The great majority of simulations that we know about are games. If it is a game, what are the odds that you are a non player character? In games, the vast majority of characters aren't the player. So if we are living in a computer simulation, odds are that we're non player characters.

I think probably as likely as the earth is at the center of the universe. The simulation theory as fun as it is to imagine I think is more like the earth being flat or center of the universe type thinking … it more comes from our imagination then from our observation

Re: What are the odds we are living in a computer simulation? (2016)

#45
post #19

There's just too much pain (both physical and emotional) and too many diseases in the world. I refuse to believe that a higher entity (name it God or aliens) would create or simulate all those cruel things.

Have you ever watched anyone play RollerCoaster Tycoon?

Or any of the 50%+ of our games sales that involve combat and/or death?

Re: What are the odds we are living in a computer simulation? (2016)

#46
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless it’s possible to attack the simulation from inside it and escape the sandbox. OTOH, every time an escape is detected and contained, the simulation can be reset to its last valid state and its inhabitants will never suspect the universe was reset.

“There is a theory which states that if ever anyone discovers exactly what the Universe is for and why it is here, it will instantly disappear and be replaced by something even more bizarre and inexplicable.” -Douglas Adams

Aww you missed the best bit - ‘there’s another theory that says this has already happened’!

Re: What are the odds we are living in a computer simulation? (2016)

#47
post #33

If it is a simulation, what are the odds that it's a game? The great majority of simulations that we know about are games. If it is a game, what are the odds that you are a non player character? In games, the vast majority of characters aren't the player. So if we are living in a computer simulation, odds are that we're non player characters.

cries in solipsism

Re: What are the odds we are living in a computer simulation? (2016)

#48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1 And now we have a dyad. Great job. Do you have any idea what just started?

computers as we know them are pretty limited in simulating anything in real time. I mean we are limited to double precision most of the time. If we are in a simulation, it isn’t a piece of silicon and metal running on electricity with all the finite math. Maybe if you redefine computer to be reality and have a model for dealing with singularities and infinities.

You can simulate plenty in real-time or faster - most games do. The underlying universe can easily be more complex than the simulated one.

Re: What are the odds we are living in a computer simulation? (2016)

#50
post #22

No dev up against a deadline is going to implement a Higgs Field. Those masses would be hard-coded.

You can always go back and add it later. You put in a cheap heuristic to begin with and only implement the faithful model when particle colliders start coming online. If it took too long to develop just pause the simulation for a bit.
Post reply on HN