Live data from Hacker News

Back to the Future with RSS

ncase.me

41–50 of 105 posts

Re: Back to the Future with RSS

#41
post #40

And each time I see an article like this, I realize how much I miss google reader. So much so that last year I decided that I'd rebuild it myself but it's definitely not something one person can pull off on his own.

I’ve been a happy Newsblur customer since the Reader shutdown. Every now and again, I look into setting up TinyTinyRSS and similar hosted software but always go back to Newsblur.

Re: Back to the Future with RSS

#42
There is on issue, RSS is advert and cookie free. Meaning it creates a clean web, but as such prevents monetization, so I guess it was not suitable technology. But on the other hand there are many blogs that do not care about Google Ads or similar, so it would be interesting to revamp RSS again.

Re: Back to the Future with RSS

#43

I recently added an RSS feed to my personal blog, hosted on github pages, and I was astonished at just how easy it is. I wish all of my friends just had blogs and RSS feeds instead of Facebook or Instagram accounts.

You may like micro.blog. It’s a blog/rss based social network. You can create a blog with them or import an existing RSS feed (what I do). It’s all chronological. And since it’s “just rss”, you can use different apps to use it like Instagram or Twitter.

... you ever see a project and realize it's exactly the one you've had knocking around your brain for ages and just never had time to get to?

Re: Back to the Future with RSS

#44
Shameless plug of my own RSS reader side project: https://github.com/msurdi/feedo.

It's not great nor complete, but is very simple and does the basic thing, it has no ads and there is no risk somebody will turn it off or push it in commercial ways.

I built it about a month ago over the weekend and haven't looked back to other popular services.

If you're a developer, making an RSS reader you like seems like a very nice side project to try out new tools, frameworks, etc... more useful than a TODO list and also very simple to build.

Re: Back to the Future with RSS

#45
post #10

What would it take to get Firefox to support RSS again? With support I mean: 1. To detect RSS feeds and show an icon in the UI 2. Render RSS files, so they look better than raw text 3. Link that UI icon to a subscribe function: Show a configurable list of RSS Readers and send the feed to the subscribe URL of the selected one. This can already be added with extensions, but it would boost RSS adoption if it were a defa…

Mozilla doesn't have an incentive to add RSS since they would prefer larger Pocket adoption.

Re: Back to the Future with RSS

#46
post #44

Shameless plug of my own RSS reader side project: https://github.com/msurdi/feedo . It's not great nor complete, but is very simple and does the basic thing, it has no ads and there is no risk somebody will turn it off or push it in commercial ways. I built it about a month ago over the weekend and haven't looked back to other popular services. If you're a developer, making an RSS reader you like seems like a very ni…

This is very cool, thanks for sharing -- starred!

Re: Back to the Future with RSS

#47

There is on issue, RSS is advert and cookie free. Meaning it creates a clean web, but as such prevents monetization, so I guess it was not suitable technology. But on the other hand there are many blogs that do not care about Google Ads or similar, so it would be interesting to revamp RSS again.

I follow a few monetized feeds. They’re usually one of:

- One post per week, showcasing the sponsor - Embedding a static image into every feed entry for their current sponsor - Adding a text-based „this post is sponsored by“ sentence/paragraph to every post

For me personally they’re fair tradeoffs

Re: Back to the Future with RSS

#48
post #11

The tech is great, the feeds are just garbage / 2nd tier citizens. Garbage in, garbage out rule still lives. e.g. I've got an economist sub - a reputable source of news. Checked out the feed...picked one...week in review. Title on every post is week in review. Content of post is a link. No context, no summary, no single sentence...nothing.i.e. Would need to click through to find out topic on each one. Might as well n…

I really love the model Ars Technica went with! As a free user you’ll get the first couple (3 maybe?) paragraphs of each article and for paid subscribers they’re offering full text feeds

Re: Back to the Future with RSS

#49
It never ceases to frustrate me that these sorts of articles invariably focus on RSS, and say little to nothing about Atom.

This article mentions Atom once:

> (Note: there's something very similar to RSS called "Atom", but all modern apps work equally with both.)

Here’s what I say about it:

If you’re doing podcasts, use RSS, because almost nothing supports Atom there, because for all practical purposes Apple took over and froze the ecosystem at a certain point in time that was just before Atom became popular and fixed up the mess that was RSS.

If you’re doing any other type of feed, use Atom, because it’s technically substantially superior to RSS and supported just as well.

Where Atom and RSS are both supported, you should always prefer Atom, because RSS has the potential to mess things up because it leaves the client to guess whether certain fields are text or HTML. RSS is simply a hopelessly incorrect format, whereas Atom models content types properly. RSS is even harder to write correctly than Atom, due to things like using a weird date format.

(Look through older comments of mine for more explanation and reasons: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu....)

Can we please stop talking about RSS and talk about feeds? A bit like we finally mostly stopped talking about SSL in favour of TLS.

Re: Back to the Future with RSS

#50
So what's a good general news feed? The Associated Press shut theirs down. The New York Times doesn't update much throughout the day.

I'd like a good news feed that only has really important stories. No filler, no press release stuff.

Post reply on HN