Live data from Hacker News

New type of ancient human discovered in Israel

bbc.com

1–10 of 111 posts

Re: New type of ancient human discovered in Israel

#3
> It all started in Israel. We suggest that a local group was the source population," she told BBC News. "During interglacial periods, waves of humans, the Nesher Ramla people, migrated from the Middle East to Europe

Hm, how convenient for people who claim they have divine rights to the land. Odd racial superiority vibes here.

Re: New type of ancient human discovered in Israel

#4
post #3

> It all started in Israel. We suggest that a local group was the source population," she told BBC News. "During interglacial periods, waves of humans, the Nesher Ramla people, migrated from the Middle East to Europe Hm, how convenient for people who claim they have divine rights to the land. Odd racial superiority vibes here.

Yeah, that was ridiculously racist! Let's get her cancelled!

Re: New type of ancient human discovered in Israel

#5
We'll see if the inflation in ancient human species stands up to scrutiny.

Here's a great TED Talk about dinosaur species being mistakenly identified because 'scientists have egos': https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQa11RMCeSI&t=102s (well worth a watch, it's a great story)

Re: New type of ancient human discovered in Israel

#6

We'll see if the inflation in ancient human species stands up to scrutiny. Here's a great TED Talk about dinosaur species being mistakenly identified because 'scientists have egos': https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQa11RMCeSI&t=102s (well worth a watch, it's a great story)

I thought a big part of that was that birds have big variation between juveniles and adults, something that mammalians have less of... (let alone primates)

Looking at a time when multiple hominid groups lived in relative isolation over large spans of time, admittedly without expert knowledge, it seems to make sense to me that there would be quite a bit of variation of "species" (though I also suspect the various species are more alike than most breeds of dogs...)

Re: New type of ancient human discovered in Israel

#7
post #3

> It all started in Israel. We suggest that a local group was the source population," she told BBC News. "During interglacial periods, waves of humans, the Nesher Ramla people, migrated from the Middle East to Europe Hm, how convenient for people who claim they have divine rights to the land. Odd racial superiority vibes here.

[deleted]

Re: New type of ancient human discovered in Israel

#8
post #3

> It all started in Israel. We suggest that a local group was the source population," she told BBC News. "During interglacial periods, waves of humans, the Nesher Ramla people, migrated from the Middle East to Europe Hm, how convenient for people who claim they have divine rights to the land. Odd racial superiority vibes here.

I’m sorry are you saying her claim that Neanderthals’ ancestors originated in Israel has something to do with a religion that started hundreds of thousands of years later? Because I just don’t see the connection.

Re: New type of ancient human discovered in Israel

#10
post #6

We'll see if the inflation in ancient human species stands up to scrutiny. Here's a great TED Talk about dinosaur species being mistakenly identified because 'scientists have egos': https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQa11RMCeSI&t=102s (well worth a watch, it's a great story)

I thought a big part of that was that birds have big variation between juveniles and adults, something that mammalians have less of... (let alone primates) Looking at a time when multiple hominid groups lived in relative isolation over large spans of time, admittedly without expert knowledge, it seems to make sense to me that there would be quite a bit of variation of "species" (though I also suspect the various spec…

> I thought a big part of that was that birds have big variation between juveniles and adults, something that mammalians have less of...

You should see what insects do. It just isn't possible, using fossil records alone, to identify whether two insects belong to the same or different species.

Post reply on HN