Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft is bringing Android apps to Windows 11

theverge.com

171–180 of 289 posts

Re: Microsoft is bringing Android apps to Windows 11

#171

Microsoft really wants to convince you that your phone and your PC are the same thing. But they've failed in the execution of this idea several times now. The fact that this partnership is with the Amazon app store, not the Google Play store, is a strong hint of how serious they are about this, and how this latest iteration will work out.

The old saw was that Microsoft takes 3 tries to get it right. Don't know if it applies anymore.

Re: Microsoft is bringing Android apps to Windows 11

#172
post #162

So Microsoft has its own App Store, then within that App Store there exists the Amazon App Store. Apps on this third layer will then be executable or sideloadable in Windows 11? Sounds like a disaster to me.

More like, "There is one Microsoft App Store, but apps on Amazon's Android App Store will also appear in Microsoft's App Store so you won't as a developer have to publish your Android app two places for them to show up in two places."

I would bet, for better or for worse, these Amazon Android apps will share metadata as well, so you'll see the same "Star" rating in both the Microsoft App Store and the Amazon Android App Store, but that's speculation on my part.

Re: Microsoft is bringing Android apps to Windows 11

#173
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the majority of mobile apps are very coupled to the mobile ecosystem. Or they exist to coverup the poor mobile web experience. I can use social media and messaging from any desktop web browser already. Anything geared around mobility or photography won't be very useful on a desktop. And at least a few apps just have "mobile only" as their edgy marketing strategy. I get why this is potentially useful but I can…

A big part of the reason Windows Phone failed was a lack of a good app ecosystem. Maybe they’re working their way toward a new Windows Phone that is compatible with Android apps?

Good luck passing "Safety"Net with a Windows Phone.

Re: Microsoft is bringing Android apps to Windows 11

#176

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is an absolute win-win for Microsoft and Amazon. Microsoft gets Android Apps, Amazon expands its app store and Google is shunted out of the Microsoft eco-system. I see this as an absolute brilliant thing to happen to the app ecosystem. I really hope innovation accelerates on the Amazon App store.

> Google is shunted out of the Microsoft eco-system We'll see about this one. Last I checked, half of Microsoft's own apps couldn't run on Android if Play Services was disabled.

Microsoft brought the office suite to Amazon's app store pretty recently, when Amazon launched their latest 10 inch tablet with a keyboard attachment.

Re: Microsoft is bringing Android apps to Windows 11

#177
I just went through my phone and there isn't a single Android app I'd actually want to use on my PC. Most of my apps are just hobbled versions of websites anyway, so I just use the fully functional browser with a full sized keyboard and nice big monitor and use the websites when I'm on the PC, and for that all I need is a single browser and the OS doesn't really matter.

Re: Microsoft is bringing Android apps to Windows 11

#178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Google is shunted out of the Microsoft eco-system We'll see about this one. Last I checked, half of Microsoft's own apps couldn't run on Android if Play Services was disabled.

Microsoft brought the office suite to Amazon's app store pretty recently, when Amazon launched their latest 10 inch tablet with a keyboard attachment.

That's good to know. One of the things that pushed me completely off Android was discovering how few even Microsoft apps I could use without Play Services' malware being installed as well.

And it's very likely Google will find ways to retaliate against Microsoft for working with the Amazon Appstore here. They are pretty aggressive against forks. Honestly, I would suspect the next Duo won't be able to run Play Services, because Microsoft dared to work with a competing Android app store.

Re: Microsoft is bringing Android apps to Windows 11

#179

To be honest I have no idea why someone would use Android apps on Windows? Popular apps can be used via the web-browser or even have a separat desktop app (e.g., whatsapp, facebook, youtube, ...). That is similar with games. Edit: apps which require sensors, such as gps, gyro, etc. wouldn't work anyway...

Because mobile apps ported on the web often suck (ahem... Instagram, TikTok), and the mobile version might suck less.

Re: Microsoft is bringing Android apps to Windows 11

#180
post #159

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is an absolute win-win for Microsoft and Amazon. Microsoft gets Android Apps, Amazon expands its app store and Google is shunted out of the Microsoft eco-system. I see this as an absolute brilliant thing to happen to the app ecosystem. I really hope innovation accelerates on the Amazon App store.

> Google is shunted out of the Microsoft eco-system iOS is 54.33% of all tablets, Android is 45.57%. Microsoft, Amazon, and everyone else combined account for 0.1% It doesn't seem like an ecosystem Google has the time to worry about.

54% of all tablets in USA maybe? It's more like 5.4% of all tablets in reality
Post reply on HN