Live data from Hacker News

Firefox 8 is 20% faster than Firefox 5, matches Chrome 14

extremetech.com

61–70 of 124 posts

Re: Firefox 8 is 20% faster than Firefox 5, matches Chrome 14

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Zero crashes, zero manual restarts, zero lag.

And addon support?

I run Aurora and use the Add-on Compatibility Reporter[1] to disable version checks and run any add-on I want. For most of my add-ons this works fine, but if there is a significant API change an add-on might not work correctly. But if you were scared of that you wouldn't be using Nightly or Aurora.

[1]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/add-on-compat...

Re: Firefox 8 is 20% faster than Firefox 5, matches Chrome 14

#62
post #28

So then Firefox will still be behind Chrome? Firefox 7 will be the one launched in the same time with Chrome 14. Chrome 14 should be stable in about 8-10 weeks. Firefox 8 won't be stable until 14-16 weeks from now. That's around the time Chrome 15 will be out.

I continue to be confused be what I interpret as "version number envy". Are people really that impressed by version 14 vs version 7? If FF7 is awesome, Chrome 14 must be x2 awesome! Is Firefox development "behind" because of version numbers? I'm most surprised that Mozilla seems to take this so seriously. Are the numbers anything other than a marketing / PR game? Any reason either side couldn't arbitrarily jump to ve…

This is not about marketing. I'm travelling and typing this on a phone right now, so I'll just link to a reply from the last time this misunderstanding appeared: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2679813

Re: Firefox 8 is 20% faster than Firefox 5, matches Chrome 14

#63
I might go back to Firefox when it no longer consumes gigabytes of RAM after a few hours of operation. Until then, I'm with Chrome. I don't care about speed as much -- so long as it's reliable, and doesn't grind the rest of my machine to a halt, it's all good.

Re: Firefox 8 is 20% faster than Firefox 5, matches Chrome 14

#65

I might go back to Firefox when it no longer consumes gigabytes of RAM after a few hours of operation. Until then, I'm with Chrome. I don't care about speed as much -- so long as it's reliable, and doesn't grind the rest of my machine to a halt, it's all good.

Chrome is very wasteful; only after many hours of operation in which you opened and closed dozens and dozens of tabs, it starts to be better than Firefox; as Firefox fragments memory and doesn't release it properly when closing a tab.

But for my usage patterns; with many tabs opened after a few hours of operation, Firefox consumes less RAM for me.

Also, don't confuse memory waist (coming from bloat and fragmentation) with memory used for improving the browsing experience, like caching. These browsers are doing a lot of caching and I personally don't like having 4 GB of memory and being left unused.

Re: Firefox 8 is 20% faster than Firefox 5, matches Chrome 14

#66

I might go back to Firefox when it no longer consumes gigabytes of RAM after a few hours of operation. Until then, I'm with Chrome. I don't care about speed as much -- so long as it's reliable, and doesn't grind the rest of my machine to a halt, it's all good.

Chrome is very wasteful; only after many hours of operation in which you opened and closed dozens and dozens of tabs, it starts to be better than Firefox; as Firefox fragments memory and doesn't release it properly when closing a tab. But for my usage patterns; with many tabs opened after a few hours of operation, Firefox consumes less RAM for me. Also, don't confuse memory waist (coming from bloat and fragmentation)…

memory footprint or not, chrome is faster than firefox. both in terms of page loading, and raw operation. i might reconsider firefox when it doesn't take 4 times longer to boot up.

Re: Firefox 8 is 20% faster than Firefox 5, matches Chrome 14

#68
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

6 is in beta now. Nightlies were 7.0a a few days ago, but if you update.... yep, 8.0a1 PS. Nightly has been incredibly stable on my Mac. I actually use it in production, for no other reason than I was testing it and have no reason to get an old release since it's never crashed and is incredibly fast.

Can echo that Nightly (8) is very stable on Windows, too.

Same goes for Linux. This build is quite stable and starts in a snap.

Re: Firefox 8 is 20% faster than Firefox 5, matches Chrome 14

#69
20% sounds good, but unless versions 5, 6 and 7 also had 20% improvements, it would still be slower than the current version of Chrome on canvas stuff.

For the relatively simple canvas rendering I'm doing, I can watch Firefox chugging along at 10fps struggling to render a few dozen filled rectangles, while Chrome is happily pegged at 60fps (via RequestAnimationFrame).

It's just night and day.

Re: Firefox 8 is 20% faster than Firefox 5, matches Chrome 14

#70

Firefox 8? What happened to 6 and 7? I see 7's mentioned in the article, but there's not hide nor hair of Firefox 6.

FF6 is in beta, should be out by the end of summer (or early autumn), FF7 is in alpha and should be released before end-of-year. I guess FF8 (which just arrived on the nightly channel) will be up for release in late 2011-early 2012.

See this calendar for specific dates when new Firefox updates will be pushed to the Nightly, Aurora, Beta, and Release channels: https://wiki.mozilla.org/RapidRelease/Calendar

(This should be very familiar to anyone who has seen Chrome's update schedule, which has three versions in flight at once, staggered by the same six-week intervals.)

Post reply on HN