Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: I made a community sourced fitness routine database

routinedb.com

91–100 of 194 posts

Re: Show HN: I made a community sourced fitness routine database

#91

I've lifted weights pretty regularly for some years, some years ago. However, the first program I click is gibberish [1] to me (I did olympic weightlifting too, so that's not the problem). Is there some quality control in place? [1] https://www.routinedb.com/routine/ckpvxacen02200wl8f8z27z77

Hey, thanks for the feedback. Yeah, community driven ranking and filtering is in the works! Do you have any suggestions?

Re: Show HN: I made a community sourced fitness routine database

#93
post #67

I was wondering if https://musclewiki.com/ was going to pop up. My wife had just sent it to me earlier this week. It lets you pick gender, muscle group, exercise type (stretch, bodyweight, barbell, dumbbells, kettlebells) and has detailed instructions and videos. (It does not have sets/reps like the shared site.) Perhaps they would be good to use in tandem. Personally, I think for sets/reps, it follows most exercise…

I was just reading that the optimum reps count was somewhere between 8 and 12. I was doing something that suggested 16 reps and that felt a little more like cardio or something, and I dug into it and it is a whole debate, but what I got out of it was that for what I was doing eight or so is about right.

It depends on what your goals are, lower reps with heavier weights will give you more strength. Higher reps with lighter weights will give you bigger muscles.

Re: Show HN: I made a community sourced fitness routine database

#94
post #67

I was wondering if https://musclewiki.com/ was going to pop up. My wife had just sent it to me earlier this week. It lets you pick gender, muscle group, exercise type (stretch, bodyweight, barbell, dumbbells, kettlebells) and has detailed instructions and videos. (It does not have sets/reps like the shared site.) Perhaps they would be good to use in tandem. Personally, I think for sets/reps, it follows most exercise…

I was just reading that the optimum reps count was somewhere between 8 and 12. I was doing something that suggested 16 reps and that felt a little more like cardio or something, and I dug into it and it is a whole debate, but what I got out of it was that for what I was doing eight or so is about right.

There is no optimum number. There are optimum numbers for specific goals. List your goals, your hormonal and diet context, some genetic factors, and then people could propose optimal reps for you.

Unfortunately, a lot of exercise studies use untrained people. How that extends to even moderately trained people is usually pretty problematic. I'd say "forget it, just listen to people that have been doing it for a couple of decades" is probably better advice.

The primary mover of all set-and-rep ranges is going to be goals and hormonal context, so make sure that when taking advice from someone, know what they think those two things are.

Re: Show HN: I made a community sourced fitness routine database

#95
post #49
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What I want is an app that screams at me like a drill sergeant: "Let's go, you got 10 more to go! Keep up!"

Not really screaming but in VRWorkout the computer voice combined with the visual cues are as direct as it gets :) So if you need some motivation to get your bodyweight training done maybe check it out ( https://vrworkout.at )

That looks promising, thanks!

Re: Show HN: I made a community sourced fitness routine database

#96
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This may be a little pie-in-the-sky, but I've found myself disliking the "upvote" or "like" mentality. Instead, maybe a "I use(d) this!" functionality, as well as talk sections for each routine?

I like this idea!

if i've learned one thing from this thread:

don't like the idea, use the idea!

Re: Show HN: I made a community sourced fitness routine database

#97
Features I want to see in things like this:

1. Images/videos showing the exercises

2. Program generators. I have {equipment} and n days per week. Which programs work for me? Or, I have {goal} and n days per week, what should I do? The programs would be populated with exercises from the DB, programs could be exported, etc.

3. As much ELI5 info as possible - the barrier to exercise for a lot of people (myself included despite my experience) can be not knowing wtf something is, or why to do it, and generally what the benefits are.

4. Treat warmups like any exercise - a critical part of the routine. Include lots of warm up exercises, whether it's something you make quantifiable progress with or not. Everything from skipping rope and light jogging to dead bugs. Include these as part of program generation.

Maybe something does this, but my favourite tracker (Strong) doesn't cover all of it and I'd switch in an instant if something did. I like the idea of switching programs every year or so, experimenting with warm ups, having convenient access to understanding programs and lifts better, etc. As it is, working out requires a crazy amount of research. Or a coach.

Re: Show HN: I made a community sourced fitness routine database

#100

Features I want to see in things like this: 1. Images/videos showing the exercises 2. Program generators. I have {equipment} and n days per week. Which programs work for me? Or, I have {goal} and n days per week, what should I do? The programs would be populated with exercises from the DB, programs could be exported, etc. 3. As much ELI5 info as possible - the barrier to exercise for a lot of people (myself included…

Great feedback, thanks!
Post reply on HN