Live data from Hacker News

What RSS reader do you use, and what does it lack?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 64 posts

Re: What RSS reader do you use, and what does it lack?

#31

Reeder. It lacks what all RSS feeds seem to lack - a "mark all up to here as read" feature. If I have 1000 unread items in a stream and I leaf through 200 of them I want to right click and article and mark all chronologically preceding articles as read. Nothing seems to do that.

Very very useful. +10

Re: What RSS reader do you use, and what does it lack?

#32

Reeder. It lacks what all RSS feeds seem to lack - a "mark all up to here as read" feature. If I have 1000 unread items in a stream and I leaf through 200 of them I want to right click and article and mark all chronologically preceding articles as read. Nothing seems to do that.

a) What Simple_Panda said. (100 points) b) Ability to limit items from a feed to N most recent (e.g. 100 items). Older items should be handled as read. (30 points) c) Ability to limit items from a feed to N most recent days (e.g. 2 days). Older items should be handled as read. (30 points)

I use Google Reader and I like most of its features. It lacks the aforementioned :)

Re: What RSS reader do you use, and what does it lack?

#33
Google Reader. Mostly because it's available on any machine I can login to my Google account, so I don't have to worry about synchronising my feeds on multiple machines.

What could be improved? Well, access to protected, private feeds that require authentication would be good. The problem is, of course, that the workarounds for Google Reader to access private feeds (http://lifehacker.com/5432277/access-password+protected-feed... and http://googlesystem.blogspot.com/2008/04/subscribe-to-authen...) kind of worry me.

Re: What RSS reader do you use, and what does it lack?

#34
post #15

Reeder (www.reederapp.com), having tried many and stopped reading any RSS feeds for a good while because I got too frustrated with them all. It's a front-end to Google Reader, which I really didn't enjoy using. Main thing I'd like is the smarts to filter out stories which are essentially the same, but perhaps not exactly the same. Oh, and if I bookmark/star something, then next time the same story comes up, highlight…

Yes please!! This is the feature I always find myself wanting. (Using Akregator / Kontact in KDE.) So many stories are duplicated at various stories that the ability to hide all but one where the target URL is the same would save lots of time.

Hey Taki, I've wanted that feature too and we built that into our social news site called The Shared Web (www.thesharedweb.com). The content is pulled from Twitter or posted by other people on the site and aggregated by URL. We'll be looking into pulling directly from sources so you can follow RSS feeds too soon. Would love to know if it works for you.

Re: What RSS reader do you use, and what does it lack?

#35
post #5

Stopped using an RSS reader a long time ago because I just couldn't keep up with all the content. Too many unreads, too much noise, got sick of it and figured I'd get the good stuff through Twitter or HN if it was really important. If you're building an RSS reader, I suggest you build one that filters out all the garbage and only shows me what I should really read. I honestly don't think we need "yet another RSS read…

There was a Waterloo-based company called AideRSS that did just this. Then, they became Postrank. Postrank was recently bought by Google, so perhaps they will add some kind of smart filtering to Google Reader.

Re: What RSS reader do you use, and what does it lack?

#36
post #35
post #5

Stopped using an RSS reader a long time ago because I just couldn't keep up with all the content. Too many unreads, too much noise, got sick of it and figured I'd get the good stuff through Twitter or HN if it was really important. If you're building an RSS reader, I suggest you build one that filters out all the garbage and only shows me what I should really read. I honestly don't think we need "yet another RSS read…

There was a Waterloo-based company called AideRSS that did just this. Then, they became Postrank. Postrank was recently bought by Google, so perhaps they will add some kind of smart filtering to Google Reader.

The PostRank is integrated into Google Reader as a (sort of) filtering plugin for Chrome/Safari. Here is the link: http://labs.postrank.com/gr

Re: What RSS reader do you use, and what does it lack?

#38
Google Reader. Obviously easily integrates with the rest of the Google services, the emailing and sharing of articles couldn't be easier. I'm not sure if anything could ever make me change.

I ported my Instapaper articles as a RSS feed, so if I want to read something later I'll do that through GReader. So if you could find a way to take out that step, although it isn't really a big deal.

Also on my phone I've accidentally hit "mark all as read" a few times, which is really frustrating when I've lost hundreds of items that I wanted to read. There's way to undo that, which is depressing.

Frankly I'm a little surprised that not everyone on here is using a RSS reader. It just seems like such an efficient way to get new content. So much of what I read now comes through it instead of typing in nytimes.com or something or using a bookmark, especially since I find myself on a lot of different computers.

I really hope RSS feeds never go away as they are so essential to me. But it's a thing that never really seemed to catch on with the non-geek public, even though it so obviously makes sense for everyone to use.

Re: What RSS reader do you use, and what does it lack?

#40
post #5

Stopped using an RSS reader a long time ago because I just couldn't keep up with all the content. Too many unreads, too much noise, got sick of it and figured I'd get the good stuff through Twitter or HN if it was really important. If you're building an RSS reader, I suggest you build one that filters out all the garbage and only shows me what I should really read. I honestly don't think we need "yet another RSS read…

Step 1. Sign up for Google Reader. Step 2. Subscribe to lots of stuff. Step 3. http://labs.postrank.com/gr
Post reply on HN