Live data from Hacker News

iOS 15 Humane

potential.app

321–330 of 496 posts

Re: iOS 15 Humane

#321
I wish like the flashlight i could toggle on and off "Silence All Unknown Callers," which for me I leave on always. There are times when I need to have a call come in and have to drill down into the settings to get to it.

Also, I'd love to be able to wake up using the built in alarm to a Internet URL (radio station, podcast, whatever).

Re: iOS 15 Humane

#322
post #300

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I don't want to miss a notification that my delivery food arrived, but I don't want to be bombarded with daily advertising messages from foodpanda trying to get me to change my behavior. This is exactly what the Android notification channels allow you to do, and it actually works really well. For UberEats I have the Delivery notification channel enabled, but the Marketing channel disabled. It's really the best of bo…

In UberEats (and many other apps) you can configure which push notifications you get. Is that functionally different than channels for the purposes of turning off marketing notifications? Both seem to rely on the App developer allowing you to turn off the notifications you don't want. The problem I have are the apps which don't allow that, which presumably also wouldn't allow to separate them into channels for the sa…

A difference is that there's a unified UI for disabling channels, and app developers don't have to do anything except annotate each notification with the channel it belongs to and list the channels somewhere in their manifest (IIRC). If you get a notification you don't like, you long long-press it and a menu appears showing you the different notification channels and prompting you to enable or disable them.

Re: iOS 15 Humane

#323
post #307

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It looks like they’re adding interruption levels with iOS 15: https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guideline... See “Helping People Manage Notifications” section.

That will be abused like crazy. Every marketing notification will be accompanied by an "order now to get 5% off your order" message so it can be classified as time sensitive.

Looks like they address that:

> Never designate a marketing notification as Time Sensitive. For guidance, see Helping People Manage Notifications.

Although I'm not clear on whether this are just HIG guidelines for notifications or if they are enforceable App Store rules.

Re: iOS 15 Humane

#324

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How does being able to get root access to an iPhone (the way you can on a Mac) limit creativity?

They are claiming the exact opposite of that: not having root access isn't a limit on creativity.

They're replying to a comment arguing for open devices. Saying "I'm fine with a closed device" is at best irrelevant. "I'm fine with a locked-down computer" is no argument against "I want my computer to be more open", as, in the end, if you're fine with your locked-down computer, just keep it locked down.

Re: iOS 15 Humane

#325

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sometimes one in that 0.01% end up creating a world changing operating system like Linux. I shudder to think what the world would have be if Andrew Tanenbaum/Linus/Wall/etc had to wait for a week long review after creating their software and got rejected every time because Apple support told them.. "Are you out of your freaking mind!? You possibly can't think we will let you do anything remotely like that on our hard…

Is that 0.01% really deterred by one particular OS and hardware platform being restricted? There's alternatives.

What is the equivalent phone today to the X86 Linus did his work on? Neither iOS or Android is anywhere near this, so what are the alternatives?

Re: iOS 15 Humane

#326
post #300

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I don't want to miss a notification that my delivery food arrived, but I don't want to be bombarded with daily advertising messages from foodpanda trying to get me to change my behavior. This is exactly what the Android notification channels allow you to do, and it actually works really well. For UberEats I have the Delivery notification channel enabled, but the Marketing channel disabled. It's really the best of bo…

In UberEats (and many other apps) you can configure which push notifications you get. Is that functionally different than channels for the purposes of turning off marketing notifications? Both seem to rely on the App developer allowing you to turn off the notifications you don't want. The problem I have are the apps which don't allow that, which presumably also wouldn't allow to separate them into channels for the sa…

>Is that functionally different than channels for the purposes of turning off marketing notifications?

I don't think so, it's just built into the OS which I personally prefer.

>The problem I have are the apps which don't allow that, which presumably also wouldn't allow to separate them into channels for the same reason they don't let you turn them off.

I think Apple is in a good position to enforce this though, given how strict their review process can be. They could easily reject apps that didn't use notification channels properly. I'm sure some would find a way to abuse but I think that would be a minority.

As I said I was surprised on Android by how many apps actually used them, despite not being enforced. I can only imagine they would be even better on iOS, which is why I'm so confused as to why Apple hasn't.

Re: iOS 15 Humane

#327
post #281

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple also abuses push notifications to sell their services so I don’t see this ending any time soon :(

I can't remember an Apple push notification that wasn't transactional or an update notification (which is also transcational I guess). Do you have an example?

"Helpful" tips when you get a new iPhone for one example. I also think I vaguely remember being very surprised that Photos advertised to me about being able to buy printed photo albums or something like that once? But I may be mis-remembering it with Google Photos.

Re: iOS 15 Humane

#328

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's well past midnight, I've been interacting with apps designed to maximize 'user engagement' since 8 PM. I don't have coherent thoughts, I'm opening irrelevant tabs habitually. This is not healthy. I have a problem. That problem is mindless browsing, and it feels engineered. Not saying you're wrong, just that your ideas don't work for me.

That’s because the internet is no longer a walk through the woods. It’s now a stumble through a confusing poorly-lit casino.

Well said. 100% agreement.

Last year, I found myself in an unusually unhappy place. Partly COVID lockdowns, partly changes at work, partly politics (US resident). My wife noticed and told me to get off Facebook/Twitter/etc - they were making me visibly agitated. As I weaned myself off those platforms, my happiness and stress levels improved.

I'm glad to be (mostly) off the platforms. It's been a massive improvement.

Facebook was the biggest culprit. I unfriended anybody I didn't know in meatspace. I unfollowed anybody I hadn't spoken to live in a year or more. My feed is now mostly photos my parents post, a few cycling groups, plus some marketplace activity. I no longer feel the need to check daily (or more) - once a week is plenty.

I do find I use Instagram more now. But, because it's "just photos", it doesn't stress me out like Facebook.

Twitter only gets visited when somebody links me to an interesting thread from elsewhere (here or other forums). I never go on my own.

Re: iOS 15 Humane

#329

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's well past midnight, I've been interacting with apps designed to maximize 'user engagement' since 8 PM. I don't have coherent thoughts, I'm opening irrelevant tabs habitually. This is not healthy. I have a problem. That problem is mindless browsing, and it feels engineered. Not saying you're wrong, just that your ideas don't work for me.

That’s because the internet is no longer a walk through the woods. It’s now a stumble through a confusing poorly-lit casino.

Reminds me of the song, "Welcome to the Internet":

"Could I interest you in everything

All of the time

A bit of everything

All of the time

Apathy's a tragedy

And boredom is a crime

Anything and everything

All of the time"

Re: iOS 15 Humane

#330
post #307

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It looks like they’re adding interruption levels with iOS 15: https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guideline... See “Helping People Manage Notifications” section.

That will be abused like crazy. Every marketing notification will be accompanied by an "order now to get 5% off your order" message so it can be classified as time sensitive.

Potential abuse is not a reason for not doing this feature. Bad actors will be bad in the current system or the new one.

A couple of years ago: Allow all or no notifications, hard to find settings to turn off

Current: Allow all, but easy to manage from home screen, apps that want to offer a choice of types of notification must figure out how, create config UI, make sure system is stable. Users must find, and each app is different and often report options are not working

iOS 15: A general framework that at the code level, each notification can declare. iOS unifies the UI for managing levels per app. Good actors will have lower costs, bad actors can be detected in device predictions.

I only see benefits, and you can still block apps abusing it

Post reply on HN