Live data from Hacker News

Courtney Love does the math (2000)

salon.com

31–40 of 72 posts

Re: Courtney Love does the math (2000)

#31

I can't believe Courtney Love wrote this. I had a low oppinion of her, but this seems really well written. Also, she's a fan of Neal Stephenson? That quote almost makes me wonder if this were written by some nerd and attributed to her...

It's from Salon, and claims to be a transcript of a speech, so I doubt they could have been easily deceived regarding its authorship.

Re: Courtney Love does the math (2000)

#32
post #6

Generally speaking, the creative industries are full of people and businesses that operate by screwing over creative people. They view creative people the way a miner views a resource in the ground: as something to be strip mined and then discarded. I've encountered raw contempt... in a sense they are jealous of the ability of creative people to be creative, and this fuels their desire to co-opt it and take some of t…

This is quite literally true; many organizations even refer to their employees as resources. But strangely, managers aren't PowerPoint resources.

Re: Courtney Love does the math (2000)

#33
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

First, I don't think anyone in Green Day has a PhD. Second, I wasn't surprised because she was a women, or a musician, or because she was part of the grunge scene. I know there are lots of smart women, and lots of smart women in music. I wasn't saying anything about a correlation between gender and intelligence or professions and intelligence. I was suprised because she's Courtney Love, and most of what I've read and…

My bad about Green Day -- it was the Offspring I was thinking about (can't blame me, they're almost interchangeable as bands). On the other hand, rockers with PhDs: Dexter Holland from Offspring (molecular biology, but dropped out with a masters) Greg Gaffin from Bad Religion (zoology, 2007) Brian May from Queen (astrophysics) James Lilja from Offspring (medical degree, not PhD) Sterling Morrison from the Velvet Unde…

Tom Sholz, guitarist from Boston -- MS in Engineering from MIT. Guitar Hero and Nerd. The only one in captivity?

Re: Courtney Love does the math (2000)

#35
I do not disagree with Courtney Love that the system is not great for artists but the solution is probably not in the distribution method, or the structure of the financing. It is most likely in solving the cost problem.

If it costs $500,000 to produce a record, like she says it does, that would create limited room for a great number of bands and artist to record. The market size ($s of world wide discretionary income) can only support a certain level of production.

Figuring out how to lowering that number would be far more productive than trying to create the next huge app which helps starving artists with terrible recording quality get their music heard or some other distribution method.

(She also fails to add in concert revenue which may be lucrative for artists)

Re: Courtney Love does the math (2000)

#36
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seconded. She's wickedly smart. and completely crazy.

That's a very frequent combination. I wonder if there's a reason why?

Reportedly the genes for intelligence and schizophrenia are linked: http://www.schizophrenia.com/sznews/archives/003341.html

Re: Courtney Love does the math (2000)

#37

I do not disagree with Courtney Love that the system is not great for artists but the solution is probably not in the distribution method, or the structure of the financing. It is most likely in solving the cost problem. If it costs $500,000 to produce a record, like she says it does, that would create limited room for a great number of bands and artist to record. The market size ($s of world wide discretionary incom…

I would not be surprised if the recording costs have dropped precipitously since 2000.

Re: Courtney Love does the math (2000)

#38
post #32
post #6

Generally speaking, the creative industries are full of people and businesses that operate by screwing over creative people. They view creative people the way a miner views a resource in the ground: as something to be strip mined and then discarded. I've encountered raw contempt... in a sense they are jealous of the ability of creative people to be creative, and this fuels their desire to co-opt it and take some of t…

This is quite literally true; many organizations even refer to their employees as resources . But strangely, managers aren't PowerPoint resources .

... or Excel resources

Re: Courtney Love does the math (2000)

#39

I can't believe Courtney Love wrote this. I had a low oppinion of her, but this seems really well written. Also, she's a fan of Neal Stephenson? That quote almost makes me wonder if this were written by some nerd and attributed to her...

I have a friend who knows Courtney. He says that people routinely underestimate her - she's very smart.

After I've read her article, I would say I have high regards with her.
Post reply on HN