Live data from Hacker News

The NFT market bubble has popped?

protos.com

261–270 of 332 posts

Re: The NFT market bubble has popped?

#261
post #20

NFTs are dumb however some of the NFT markets have one cool thing that I hope sticks around: the artist gets a cut of all future sales. If you sell your NFT art for $10 and then someone resells it for $1M, you will get some percentage of the $1M. We've all heard the stories of "collector buys 10 Jackson Pollock's for $10 in the 70s, sells the collection for $100M today". Wouldn't it be nice if the artist could benefi…

The royalties currently only happen if they sell on the same platform.

A peer to peer nft object transaction does not support royalties, currently

Re: The NFT market bubble has popped?

#262
I'd like to add that being a bubble doesn't mean the object of the bubble is bad. Take the dot com bubble - some of those dot coms are doing pretty well now, like amazon.com, google.com, facebook.com and news.ycombinator.com.

Re: The NFT market bubble has popped?

#263
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"the NFT hype never made any sense whatsoever to begin with" I felt the same, but now regard NFTs as the first meaningful application of blockchain. First, let's talk about land registries. In developed countries, the state administers a land registry. There is a strict, human-administered API against this registry. It allows users to inspect the full history of land; cause property splits/mergers; execute land excha…

> It would be pointless to duplicate artwork, because the sold duplicate would effectively destroy the original If someone cares about having a piece of art badly enough to steal it or create a fake do they care at all about what an NFT says about who owns it? I think we live in a world where holding the real thing in your real hands is all that matters.

"I think we live in a world where holding the real thing in your real hands is all that matters."

In regions with the rule of law, there are things more important than physical possession - ownership, contract.

Re: The NFT market bubble has popped?

#264

The overwhelmingly negative attitude towards technology on HN lately is upsetting and nauseating. If you don’t like NFTs, don’t buy them (I don’t). If you don’t like some startups product, don’t sign up. In the Boom thread there are people suggesting it’s fraudulent that they’ve taken longer than originally suggested to build supersonic aircraft. I’d very much like to know who elected the naysayers. There are tons an…

I challenge the idea that the negativity is about “technology.” The negativity appears to be about bogus businesses built on hype, fraud, exploitation, rigged demos, completely fictional timelines, and bogus business models that have come to dominate what we call the tech industry. Fraud is actually more common in “tech” than it has ever been. It has huge repercussions for everything from start ups to large companies…

By not sitting in judgment of other people’s decisions which are totally unrelated to me, I am far from “opting out”. I am not the arbiter of what is right, and neither is anyone on earth. c'est la vie

Re: The NFT market bubble has popped?

#265

The overwhelmingly negative attitude towards technology on HN lately is upsetting and nauseating. If you don’t like NFTs, don’t buy them (I don’t). If you don’t like some startups product, don’t sign up. In the Boom thread there are people suggesting it’s fraudulent that they’ve taken longer than originally suggested to build supersonic aircraft. I’d very much like to know who elected the naysayers. There are tons an…

As someone that did some contributions to the ERC721 NFT standard, I am completely enamored with the unexpected and robust direction the market took NFTs and their platforms I would pretty much never pay for one, but I love claiming NFTs! I have a nice little gallery now too. I also find it weird that people can’t separate that, it’s obviously their uncomfortable relationship with money that both got their attention…

How can one claim an NFT without buying it?

Re: The NFT market bubble has popped?

#266
post #147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The NFT is a token for the story behind it, just like the artwork. It is issued by the artist. It has even better provenance tracing than the artwork, which could be a fake.

What's to stop an artist from selling you a print as an original through an NFT?

You can see that the artist made NFTs on chain. That's actually how you can verify uniqueness as anyone can see this NFT is authentic and not a random copycat.

Re: The NFT market bubble has popped?

#267
post #265

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As someone that did some contributions to the ERC721 NFT standard, I am completely enamored with the unexpected and robust direction the market took NFTs and their platforms I would pretty much never pay for one, but I love claiming NFTs! I have a nice little gallery now too. I also find it weird that people can’t separate that, it’s obviously their uncomfortable relationship with money that both got their attention…

How can one claim an NFT without buying it?

There are plenty of claimable airdrops from prior participation in something

Just have to stick around and participate in the ecosystem

No different than achievements in an online game available to the first few people that did something

Think of the paid NFTs as microtransactions collectibles for people that dont [necessarily] want to participate and just have

I usually only find out I’m eligible for claiming an NFT from casually checking non-NFT related chatrooms from time to time. All luck but I’ve found things I really liked!

Re: The NFT market bubble has popped?

#268

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't understand how NFTs or blockchain in general helps in any way for this, or many other examples of this. All an NFT is is an encrypted hyperlink in the blockchain. The hyperlink points to a resource on someone's server. I think people forget that the NFT doesn't store the real thing. All an NFT is is basically an encrypted DNS server with some ownership data attached to it. Right now you could showcase your Fo…

> All an NFT is is an encrypted hyperlink in the blockchain. So if someone moves urls around on the server or if the company goes bust, that link is dead.

Most NFTs use IPFS for this reason.

Re: The NFT market bubble has popped?

#269

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I challenge the idea that the negativity is about “technology.” The negativity appears to be about bogus businesses built on hype, fraud, exploitation, rigged demos, completely fictional timelines, and bogus business models that have come to dominate what we call the tech industry. Fraud is actually more common in “tech” than it has ever been. It has huge repercussions for everything from start ups to large companies…

By not sitting in judgment of other people’s decisions which are totally unrelated to me, I am far from “opting out”. I am not the arbiter of what is right, and neither is anyone on earth. c'est la vie

Their decisions aren’t any more unrelated to you than any other gross polluter. “Don’t like polluted water? Don’t drink it” isn’t a viable policy.

Re: The NFT market bubble has popped?

#270
post #266

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's to stop an artist from selling you a print as an original through an NFT?

You can see that the artist made NFTs on chain. That's actually how you can verify uniqueness as anyone can see this NFT is authentic and not a random copycat.

What is an artist sells a a print verified by an NFT. The person who buys that print wants to sell it again. They make a copy of the print and sell the copy with the NFT. They keep the original print. The NFT doesn't seem like it did anything there other than be used as deception for the second buyer. Is there a way to actually link the NFT to the thing the NFT is supposedly tied to?
Post reply on HN