Live data from Hacker News

G+ invite open again

plus.google.com

61–70 of 114 posts

Re: G+ invite open again

#61
post #40
post #37

I'm curious, what's with the cruddy URLs? For eg: https://plus.google.com/113882113745075873153 Why the gargantuan number? Yeah, it's in trial, but still..

It's a strange irony that Google, the driving force behind the invention of SEO, often fail to bother with it themselves, even on extremely high-profile products. As noted, Google Profiles have meaningless, unguessable URLs: https://plus.google.com/112349855959838705650 Items in the Chrome app store are similarly opaque: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/aidgmjkfmbhldhnhko... (As are all Chrome extensions:) h…

I've not seen any evidence keyword URLs give any SEO benefit. If they once did, it doesn't appear to be the case now.

Re: G+ invite open again

#62
post #40
post #37

I'm curious, what's with the cruddy URLs? For eg: https://plus.google.com/113882113745075873153 Why the gargantuan number? Yeah, it's in trial, but still..

It's a strange irony that Google, the driving force behind the invention of SEO, often fail to bother with it themselves, even on extremely high-profile products. As noted, Google Profiles have meaningless, unguessable URLs: https://plus.google.com/112349855959838705650 Items in the Chrome app store are similarly opaque: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/aidgmjkfmbhldhnhko... (As are all Chrome extensions:) h…

About the chrome extension urls, the source they use to generate those hashes and some interesting trivia here: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1882981/google-chrome-alp...

Re: G+ invite open again

#63

Unfortunately, I made the mistake of entering my true birthdate when creating my Google account. I'm under 18, and Google currently is not allowing minors to use G+. I'm disappointed, but I'm not upset enough to create another account...Hopefully Google will welcome innocent and vulnerable 17.5-year-olds like me into the Plus fold reasonably soon.

If by soon you mean in six months...

Re: G+ invite open again

#64
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Andrew, give it a try - as I said, really easy to setup. I am thinking of installing it on one of my customers' LAN for their private use.

Yep, it's pretty great. We use it internally and it's pretty fantastic. Curious what XMPP platform you all went with, this was the most difficult part to implement for us and was a little tedious waiting for the CAs to accept the certificates and have it all propagate and everything. We're using Prosody which does have its quirks but maybe there's something better out there.

please someone invite me on G+ .. imransyedh@gmail.com

Re: G+ invite open again

#66
post #49

how do you send invites ?

Who the heck knows. I think adding an email address to your circles and then sharing something with them will trigger an email notification that doubles as an invite that works whenever new signups through invites are enabled, which isn't often. If anyone has better insight, please let me know.

Re: G+ invite open again

#67
Might just be me, but with Google opening and closing invitations like this all the time, it's not even "like Gmail all over again". It's much worse. With Google creating this much artificial scarcity to bring buzz, demand and publicity, they are really creating immense expectations and putting themselves up for slaughter.

People are going crazy right now trying to get invites, to find the invites closed, their received invites not working because it's closed again, etc etc. People are putting up lots of work to get in, and the more work Google make people put in, the better the product needs to be.

The buzz around G+ is also just insane. People are creating news websites, tutorial websites and twitter-accounts for G+. People are gaming others to like and follow them on twitter and facebook(!) to get G+ invites (makes sense, eh?). There are already several third-party URL-shorteners dedicated for G+. Why exactly? If G+ is going to be huge, who cares about twitter's 140 char limit? The buzz-machine is working like crazy and people are desperately trying to cling on to what's hot right now, even though it doesn't internally or externally make any sense. Expectations are way high and are still going up, up trough the roof.

G+ seems 100% marketing-driven at this point, just look at the demo-material. In the Circles video they even say "You take a chance on people, because they take a chance on you". For a feature which lets you put a user in a list. This is Apple-grade marketing BS, so it's hard to not think the overall deployment strategy with the associated buzz is intentional.

I'm however starting to doubt if G+ will be able to deliver on the expectations being created for it. They are just going way too high now.

Although probably not as bad, this is definitely moving into Wave-land. People had to go trough hell and back to get Wave-invites, but they went trough whatever crazy means they had to, and once they got there the response was "This is it"?

Unless G+ can really deliver, it might end up the same.

Re: G+ invite open again

#68
post #67

Might just be me, but with Google opening and closing invitations like this all the time, it's not even "like Gmail all over again". It's much worse. With Google creating this much artificial scarcity to bring buzz, demand and publicity, they are really creating immense expectations and putting themselves up for slaughter. People are going crazy right now trying to get invites, to find the invites closed, their recei…

The fact that I can invite someone and then they can't get in is ridiculous.

Do you think that person is going to try to get in again later? Probably not. And with only a handful of my invites getting in, my feed might as well be twitter with a lot of big public figures I followed. There's nothing personal there.

It's a stupid way to launch a social service. Social is nothing without my network. So far I have to rate google as still not getting social.

Re: G+ invite open again

#70
If you would like a friendly entrepreneur to be in one of your circle please send me an invite: jacobalexirwin at gmail dot com

And maybe you'd like to know a bit about me here first: linkedin dot com/in/jacobirwin

Post reply on HN