Live data from Hacker News

Amazon announces unlimited MP3 storage with any Cloud Drive plan

amazon.com

41–50 of 61 posts

Re: Amazon announces unlimited MP3 storage with any Cloud Drive plan

#41
post #32

I wonder why they are not offering ogg vorbis support. Is it just not as popular? Are the files typically larger? Either way, it's a glaring omission imo.

Almost no one uses Ogg, not a very glaring omission in my opinion. Amazon sells MP3s. Apple sells AACs. No one with any market share sells Ogg files.

Re: Amazon announces unlimited MP3 storage with any Cloud Drive plan

#42
post #32

I wonder why they are not offering ogg vorbis support. Is it just not as popular? Are the files typically larger? Either way, it's a glaring omission imo.

My assumption is that this is a strategic move against Apple and ipod/iphone doesn't support ogg, so it doesn't come into play. Just a guess.

Re: Amazon announces unlimited MP3 storage with any Cloud Drive plan

#45
Big win. I got a free 20gb account for a year just for buying a Johnny Winter CD (as MP3s) and I'll certainly pay for 20g after my free year is up.

I am using the player right now: very convenient to use from my laptop or droid. I haven't tried it from the living room on Google TV yet but that should also work fine.

Re: Amazon announces unlimited MP3 storage with any Cloud Drive plan

#46
I wonder how much offering this actually costs them.

There must be some serious file duplication between users especially if they're offering unlimited mp3 sharing, since many people will have the same MP3 files (they can profit off piracy while pretending it doesn't exist).

If they're really clever about it they might even store the data separately (which will increase duplicate collisions quite a lot due to retagging)

Re: Amazon announces unlimited MP3 storage with any Cloud Drive plan

#48

I wonder how much verification is done that the files are MP3? You could reasonably put other data inside MP3 containers and use Cloud Drive as a nice, inexpensive backup solution. Time to start writing a tool ;)

On "eligibility" requirements:

>Note: Music recordings in other formats, lossless files, or audio recordings that are not of songs and non-audio files (even if in MP3 or AAC format) are not eligible for unlimited music space and will count against your Cloud Drive storage space.

I have to wonder if this is simply a TOS issue or if Amazon is actually doing something similar to iTunes Match and creating audio fingerprints of your songs so as to de-duplicate them.

Re: Amazon announces unlimited MP3 storage with any Cloud Drive plan

#49
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I imagine through fingerprinting, checksums of files, etc. Though that's not fool-proof as people can an do change the metadata, filenames, etc of the files they download. (That's not even touching people that download FLAC and then convert to mp3 for 'actual usage').

Easy enough to claim fair use. "I had this on CD, but it was more convenient to download it rather than rip it myself." seems pretty bulletproof to me.

If they come to you with a lawsuit threat, you'll still have to pay money to argue that defense in court.

Re: Amazon announces unlimited MP3 storage with any Cloud Drive plan

#50
post #35

Wow, Amazon continues to amaze. I'd really love an iPhone app, though. This is kind of useless for me until they release one (I prefer iTunes to listening to music on my laptop, it's faster and has a nicer interface.)

You can use the web player through safari.
Post reply on HN