Live data from Hacker News

Poe’s best-selling book during his lifetime was a guide to seashells

atlasobscura.com

21–30 of 42 posts

Re: Poe’s best-selling book during his lifetime was a guide to seashells

#21

I don't know what this is supposed to prove. Poe was a failure whose writing was never popular during his lifetime. The fact that he is better known since his death is entirely due to the activist efforts by Ivory Tower academics and English teachers to make the rambling writings of an ancient hack into mandatory reading for students.

[deleted]

Re: Poe’s best-selling book during his lifetime was a guide to seashells

#22

I don't know what this is supposed to prove. Poe was a failure whose writing was never popular during his lifetime. The fact that he is better known since his death is entirely due to the activist efforts by Ivory Tower academics and English teachers to make the rambling writings of an ancient hack into mandatory reading for students.

Is being a 'failure' entirely dependent on whether or not someone was successful in accomplishing some sort of goal? There are plenty of people that might be considered non-failures that successfully engaged in behavior that was/is abhorrent and detrimental to society. Wealthy slave plantation owners wouldn't be considered 'failures' in that sense of the word. To me, it doesn't seem like failure is a useful binary metric in determining the worth of a person.

Re: Poe’s best-selling book during his lifetime was a guide to seashells

#23
Reminded of Ovid.. we may know him now for 'Metamorphoses,' but during his lifetime, his most popular books concerned dating and relationship advice. Such excellent, timeless topics as where to look for love (go for walks around the Colosseum), how to speak at dinner parties, the importance of bathing, give compliments, less is more with regard to cosmetics, etc.

Re: Poe’s best-selling book during his lifetime was a guide to seashells

#24

If you’re interested in reading Poe’s non-poetry fiction, I put together all of his short stories and novellas into a free/libre compilation for Standard Ebooks: https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/edgar-allan-poe/short-fict... Having said that, I personally prefer the writing of Leonid Andreyev (described as Russia’s answer to Poe). Coincidentally, I’ve put together a short fiction compilation for him too: https://sta…

Thank you for the links. So I take it Andreyev is also gothic fiction or do his similarities to Poe lie in some other aspects?

Re: Poe’s best-selling book during his lifetime was a guide to seashells

#25
I use 6.5 digit calibrated multimeter, precision programmable power supply and programmable load (all from Keysight) to discharge/charge my car's battery:) In total the equipment to do this is almost the cost of the car.

As a bonus I get nice chart and precise measurement of battery capacity:)

Likewise I have precision data logging laboratory thermometer, with current calibration (to 0.01C) to measure temperature of bread dough. Not strictly in category of overkill -- I am running experiments to come up with formula to calculate exact perfect bread dough recipes, taking temperature into account.

Re: Poe’s best-selling book during his lifetime was a guide to seashells

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a Russian, Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn were an important part of my childhood, just as "To kill a mockingbird".

Thank you. The 2 parent comments seem to misunderstand a couple things. Just because something is popular doesn’t mean it’s profound, and vice versa. Also, just because something goes over many students’ heads doesn’t mean it wasn’t worth trying.

I'd go farther—probably too mean for HN, but this kind of attitude gets a pass on here in part because people are too restrained in slapping down painfully-bad opinions that aren't about technology—and point to the above two comments as illustrating the difference between "literate" as in "can read words" and "literate" as in "at least knows what actually reading looks like, even if not fully capable of it oneself".

It's the equivalent of "classical music sucks, it all all sounds the same to me and is really boring" or "jazz sucks, it's all just random noise" or "hip-hop sucks, it's all just angry yelling". No, you're bad at listening to music, broadly, and are so bad that you don't even realize how bad you are. This is different from just happening not to care for a given piece or artist, but understanding why the work may be considered good, or at least important.

Re: Poe’s best-selling book during his lifetime was a guide to seashells

#27
post #25

I use 6.5 digit calibrated multimeter, precision programmable power supply and programmable load (all from Keysight) to discharge/charge my car's battery:) In total the equipment to do this is almost the cost of the car. As a bonus I get nice chart and precise measurement of battery capacity:) Likewise I have precision data logging laboratory thermometer, with current calibration (to 0.01C) to measure temperature of…

Wrong article?

Re: Poe’s best-selling book during his lifetime was a guide to seashells

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thank you. The 2 parent comments seem to misunderstand a couple things. Just because something is popular doesn’t mean it’s profound, and vice versa. Also, just because something goes over many students’ heads doesn’t mean it wasn’t worth trying.

I'd go farther—probably too mean for HN, but this kind of attitude gets a pass on here in part because people are too restrained in slapping down painfully-bad opinions that aren't about technology—and point to the above two comments as illustrating the difference between "literate" as in "can read words" and "literate" as in "at least knows what actually reading looks like, even if not fully capable of it oneself".…

Is art important because someone tells us it's important, did something different, or is it up to the beholder?

I'd wager the average american if asked throughout there life would reconcile the fact that EAP was not worth learning about.

Re: Poe’s best-selling book during his lifetime was a guide to seashells

#30
Interestingly, Poe is not alone as a famous writer of fiction who became fascinated by a particular branch of zoology. About a century later, Vladimir Nabokov was obsessed with butterflies, with one of his hypotheses (then thought of as largely insignificant and incorrect) later being borne out by genetic studies -- ironic, given the man's distaste for the idea of genetics.

Nabokov himself even went so far as to say:

> It is not improbable that had there been no revolution in Russia, I would have devoted myself entirely to lepidopterology and never written any novels at all.

Post reply on HN