Live data from Hacker News

PolarDB, yet another open source database system based on PostgreSQL

github.com

31–40 of 103 posts

Re: PolarDB, yet another open source database system based on PostgreSQL

#31

It seems that Alibaba is going more open source than Amazon for their clouds services. That’s interesting and they may use this approach as a key differentiator.

Based on what metric? Amazon took over Elastic's open source server and another major one IIRC. That was huge. PostgreSQL is not about to disappear.

Re: PolarDB, yet another open source database system based on PostgreSQL

#34
post #6

“high availability through Paxos based replication”. I thought Paxos is supposed to be a CP system.

You have N >= 3 nodes, or N >= 2 and a non-compute arbitrator. One of them goes down, stops responding. You still have quorum, data processes continue just fine. That's high-availability in a CP system.

Re: PolarDB, yet another open source database system based on PostgreSQL

#35
post #6

“high availability through Paxos based replication”. I thought Paxos is supposed to be a CP system.

No database works well across network partitions for general use (you can designate one region for active business transactions, but that means the other regions are effectively offline during the partition.)

If you understand your use cases and your application source code, you can go a long way towards some kind of multi-region HA that does something acceptable during the partition, but that's a pretty big if.

Source: DBA.

Re: PolarDB, yet another open source database system based on PostgreSQL

#37

It seems that Alibaba is going more open source than Amazon for their clouds services. That’s interesting and they may use this approach as a key differentiator.

Based on what metric? Amazon took over Elastic's open source server and another major one IIRC. That was huge. PostgreSQL is not about to disappear.

They did it only after ES decided to abandon the Apache license. I doubt that Amazon would have done it if they were not forced. Redshift is also Postgres based and Amazon never released something. So based on that metric Alibaba is more open.

Re: PolarDB, yet another open source database system based on PostgreSQL

#38

Fantastic! I was actually looking for a buggier version of postgres that won't be supported a year. That's exactly what I was looking for. > PolarDB will evolve and offer its functions and features in two major parts: Oh boy.

At least it's open source and NOT made by Google?

Also, how do you know it's a 'buggier version of postgres'? have you tried PolarDB yourself?

Post reply on HN