Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Google+: Like it/prefer it to FaceBook

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 161 posts

Re: Poll: Google+: Like it/prefer it to FaceBook

#71
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Create an empty circle. Add them by their emails. Post to that circle, G+ will send a "X shared Y with you" email which is actually an invitation. Does this work for you?

This hasn't worked for a couple of days at least. Yes, the invites go out, but the signup page only intermittently accepts logins (presumably as they open/close the floodgates).

I just joined G+ 2 hours ago with such an invite.

Re: Poll: Google+: Like it/prefer it to FaceBook

#72
post #34

G+ will be popular with the tech set (and probably their freinds), but I can't see moms, dads, grand parents really switching to it. Nor can I see it becoming as popular until there are games, etc. For better or worse, the vast proportion of FBs users will not move over. Take a look around, how many people still have yahoo, aol, and MSN email addresses? Yahoo still is a very popular destination for people (groups, et…

Wasn't that the same thing said about Facebook circa 2005-2006?

The situation then was vastly different.

The concept of social networking was still being defined. facebook is social networking in most people's minds. The concept has been solidified. Google's recent offering does nothing to reinvent the concept.

Also, social networking was still something mostly young people were into. The network-effects now are much greater in magnitude than they were then.

The biggest factor was that myspace was perceived as a "ghetto" (I had multiple people describe it to me as such). People didn't join facebook because it was more compelling, they left myspace because it had degenerated to a ghetto and facebook was the most viable option.

The social networking battle is facebook's to lose, not google's to win.

Re: Poll: Google+: Like it/prefer it to FaceBook

#73
post #12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed. Count me in the "I'd like to have a chance to test it over Facebook" section ;-)

If you guys have gmail accounts I'll invite you. EDIT: HN usability fail navigation Tip #97: The email field in your profile is invisible to others. Put your email in the About field so that others can see it.

[deleted]

Re: Poll: Google+: Like it/prefer it to FaceBook

#74
post #12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed. Count me in the "I'd like to have a chance to test it over Facebook" section ;-)

If you guys have gmail accounts I'll invite you. EDIT: HN usability fail navigation Tip #97: The email field in your profile is invisible to others. Put your email in the About field so that others can see it.

[deleted]

Re: Poll: Google+: Like it/prefer it to FaceBook

#75
post #12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed. Count me in the "I'd like to have a chance to test it over Facebook" section ;-)

If you guys have gmail accounts I'll invite you. EDIT: HN usability fail navigation Tip #97: The email field in your profile is invisible to others. Put your email in the About field so that others can see it.

[deleted]

Re: Poll: Google+: Like it/prefer it to FaceBook

#76
post #66
post #3

You should add an option for those that haven't gotten a chance to try it out yet. Some people, including me, just aren't that cool yet :)

I'm in the same boat because I have a Google Apps account, so Google Profiles (and thus Google+) isn't available to me (yet?).

I always feed like a second class citizen with my google apps account.

Re: Poll: Google+: Like it/prefer it to FaceBook

#77
post #65

My parents have a rule about new TV shows: They won't watch anything in the first season. Instead, they record the entire season, and once it is picked up for a second, they'll watch the first season and then become regular viewers. I have the same rule with social networks. I'll sign up right at the beginning, but I won't participate until I see a good chunk of my friends are on it. I don't want to invest the time i…

Your parents sound like the "early majority" on the tv show adoption life cycle.

Re: Poll: Google+: Like it/prefer it to FaceBook

#78
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wasn't that the same thing said about Facebook circa 2005-2006?

The situation then was vastly different. The concept of social networking was still being defined. facebook is social networking in most people's minds. The concept has been solidified. Google's recent offering does nothing to reinvent the concept. Also, social networking was still something mostly young people were into. The network-effects now are much greater in magnitude than they were then. The biggest factor wa…

"The concept of social networking" is very much still being defined today. The objection to having parents/bosses/other "uncool" people on Facebook is but one example. The entire idea is something like 10 years old and incredibly far from maturity and being set in stone.

Re: Poll: Google+: Like it/prefer it to FaceBook

#79
post #12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed. Count me in the "I'd like to have a chance to test it over Facebook" section ;-)

If you guys have gmail accounts I'll invite you. EDIT: HN usability fail navigation Tip #97: The email field in your profile is invisible to others. Put your email in the About field so that others can see it.

Would love an invite if you have any more

Re: Poll: Google+: Like it/prefer it to FaceBook

#80
post #12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed. Count me in the "I'd like to have a chance to test it over Facebook" section ;-)

If you guys have gmail accounts I'll invite you. EDIT: HN usability fail navigation Tip #97: The email field in your profile is invisible to others. Put your email in the About field so that others can see it.

Would love get an invite. Thanks!
Post reply on HN