Live data from Hacker News

LA pays $2600 per homeless tent, per month

npr.org

1–10 of 312 posts

Re: LA pays $2600 per homeless tent, per month

#2
> the per-tent cost covers services, meals, sanitation and staffing

OK, so $2600 gets a fair bit.

Also looking at the report [1] this rate is calculated by dividing the total cost of the pilot by the duration and number of clients. So that is including one-time set up, planning and evaluation in the cost, which is probably a decent fraction of the cost as it's only an 8 month pilot. The recurring cost for extending may be lower.

I think it's misleading to compare that dollar amount to the monthly cost of an apartment.

[1] https://clkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2020/20-0841_rpt_cao_03...

Re: LA pays $2600 per homeless tent, per month

#3

> the per-tent cost covers services, meals, sanitation and staffing OK, so $2600 gets a fair bit. Also looking at the report [1] this rate is calculated by dividing the total cost of the pilot by the duration and number of clients. So that is including one-time set up, planning and evaluation in the cost, which is probably a decent fraction of the cost as it's only an 8 month pilot. The recurring cost for extending m…

This is NPR reporting. Why would they mislead on an issue like this? I think they're a very credible source, given their progressive bent, to be asking these questions.

Re: LA pays $2600 per homeless tent, per month

#4

> the per-tent cost covers services, meals, sanitation and staffing OK, so $2600 gets a fair bit. Also looking at the report [1] this rate is calculated by dividing the total cost of the pilot by the duration and number of clients. So that is including one-time set up, planning and evaluation in the cost, which is probably a decent fraction of the cost as it's only an 8 month pilot. The recurring cost for extending m…

This is NPR reporting. Why would they mislead on an issue like this? I think they're a very credible source, given their progressive bent, to be asking these questions.

Because they're under the same competitive pressure in the attention economy as every other media outlet?

Re: LA pays $2600 per homeless tent, per month

#5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is NPR reporting. Why would they mislead on an issue like this? I think they're a very credible source, given their progressive bent, to be asking these questions.

Because they're under the same competitive pressure in the attention economy as every other media outlet?

Not really. They're funded a bit differently.

Re: LA pays $2600 per homeless tent, per month

#7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because they're under the same competitive pressure in the attention economy as every other media outlet?

Not really. They're funded a bit differently.

True. But they will still fail if they lose too many eyeballs. And the world is increasingly overflowing with distractions.

Re: LA pays $2600 per homeless tent, per month

#8

> the per-tent cost covers services, meals, sanitation and staffing OK, so $2600 gets a fair bit. Also looking at the report [1] this rate is calculated by dividing the total cost of the pilot by the duration and number of clients. So that is including one-time set up, planning and evaluation in the cost, which is probably a decent fraction of the cost as it's only an 8 month pilot. The recurring cost for extending m…

As long as the local government has tons of money doing nothing in their budget, they are going to find a way to spend it, and they're not going to care if they overpay because what else are they going to spend it on? In coastal California, the rule is never ever give that money back by lowering taxes. Taxes only go up. If there's too much money being generated by the taxes to spend, start spending it on homelessness or whatever utopian goal sounds good.

Some problems though, like healthcare and homelessness don't get better if you spend more money on them. The prices of healthcare just go up, because there is limited supply of doctors and drug companies charge whatever they want, and more homeless people show up to take advantage of the great services.

Re: LA pays $2600 per homeless tent, per month

#9

> the per-tent cost covers services, meals, sanitation and staffing OK, so $2600 gets a fair bit. Also looking at the report [1] this rate is calculated by dividing the total cost of the pilot by the duration and number of clients. So that is including one-time set up, planning and evaluation in the cost, which is probably a decent fraction of the cost as it's only an 8 month pilot. The recurring cost for extending m…

This is NPR reporting. Why would they mislead on an issue like this? I think they're a very credible source, given their progressive bent, to be asking these questions.

> Why would they mislead on an issue like this? I think they're a very credible source

Do you not agree the number is misleading?

Re: LA pays $2600 per homeless tent, per month

#10

> the per-tent cost covers services, meals, sanitation and staffing OK, so $2600 gets a fair bit. Also looking at the report [1] this rate is calculated by dividing the total cost of the pilot by the duration and number of clients. So that is including one-time set up, planning and evaluation in the cost, which is probably a decent fraction of the cost as it's only an 8 month pilot. The recurring cost for extending m…

This is NPR reporting. Why would they mislead on an issue like this? I think they're a very credible source, given their progressive bent, to be asking these questions.

I have no idea why people believe NPR to be progressive. The joke name "Nice Polite Republicans" exists for a reason. Liberal news coverage of homeless issues rarely takes a progressive framing, anyway.
Post reply on HN