Live data from Hacker News

Firefox PDF reader passes 'pixel-perfect' test

cnet.com

1–7 of 7 posts

Re: Firefox PDF reader passes 'pixel-perfect' test

#3
Someone else already corrected the link.

Commenting the article itself: If I click on the link that is supposed to show me a pixel perfect PDF in my FF 5 instance, I get a lot of gibberish (misaligned braces, text that overlaps) that is most certainly not part of the original PDF.

So - while I'd love to see something like this in the future, the author seems to see wildly different results than I do. For now, this _fails_ the pixel-perfect test and just about passes the readable test.

Re: Firefox PDF reader passes 'pixel-perfect' test

#4

Someone else already corrected the link. Commenting the article itself: If I click on the link that is supposed to show me a pixel perfect PDF in my FF 5 instance, I get a lot of gibberish (misaligned braces, text that overlaps) that is most certainly not part of the original PDF. So - while I'd love to see something like this in the future, the author seems to see wildly different results than I do. For now, this _f…

"but right now it requires a nightly build of Firefox"

Re: Firefox PDF reader passes 'pixel-perfect' test

#5
post #4

Someone else already corrected the link. Commenting the article itself: If I click on the link that is supposed to show me a pixel perfect PDF in my FF 5 instance, I get a lot of gibberish (misaligned braces, text that overlaps) that is most certainly not part of the original PDF. So - while I'd love to see something like this in the future, the author seems to see wildly different results than I do. For now, this _f…

"but right now it requires a nightly build of Firefox"

Thank you for pointing this out. I was too eager to see it in action and - after skimming the article and obviously missing that clause - proceeded to hit the nice blue "read the JavaScript paper with pdf.js online, too" in the paragraph before the quote that contains the statement about nightlies.

My bad, mea culpa.

I won't run a nightly on my main machine to give it a try, but awesome if it made the leap to pixel perfect between FF 5 and current builds.

Re: Firefox PDF reader passes 'pixel-perfect' test

#6
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"but right now it requires a nightly build of Firefox"

Thank you for pointing this out. I was too eager to see it in action and - after skimming the article and obviously missing that clause - proceeded to hit the nice blue "read the JavaScript paper with pdf.js online, too" in the paragraph before the quote that contains the statement about nightlies. My bad, mea culpa. I won't run a nightly on my main machine to give it a try, but awesome if it made the leap to pixel p…

Apparently there's a number of bugs with Firefox's implementation of canvas and web fonts that were fixed for FF7. They rely on those fixes to get correct behavior.

(They've also found a couple WebKit bugs as well)