Live data from Hacker News

Online Antipiracy firm sending copyright notices for downloading Ubuntu ISO

reddit.com

71–80 of 136 posts

Re: Online Antipiracy firm sending copyright notices for downloading Ubuntu ISO

#71
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes! I find it so ironic, in a country that prides itself for it's stance for "privacy", that random predatory lawyers can just get from ISP's the personal details behind any IP address on the basis of potential IP infringement. It is really infuriating...

They need to go and get a court order, and with that they request the personal data from the respective ISP. The whole process is pretty steamlined and partly automated though. Source: have been through many copyright claims and currently have a supreme court lawsuit pending.

Many claims by copyright predators go through the courts in Munich and Koeln which seem to rubberstamp every case. Cunts from Waldorf Frommer being among the most notorius. If only the healthcare, local administration and other services in Germany were working so seamlessly...

Re: Online Antipiracy firm sending copyright notices for downloading Ubuntu ISO

#72

One doesn't know how stressful and infuriating these copyright notices are until one lived in a country with internet hijacked by copyright predators. From the moment of receiving such notice there is only stress, misinformation, and verbal abuse. Thanks Americans. PS. It doesn't matter you downloaded free software, every person you'll contact in the process of straightening this out will be equally clueless and abus…

> a country with internet hijacked by copyright predators

Yeah, thank god my country is not among this group. We have better things to do than police imaginary american property.

I remember reading a news article years ago about some MPAA lobbyist who came here to do his thing. A journalist asked him point blank if intellectual property should be a priority in a country that can barely manage to provide basic infrastructure for its entire population. People are literally hungry and yet this guy is here talking about copyright bullshit. I wish I could find this article again...

Re: Online Antipiracy firm sending copyright notices for downloading Ubuntu ISO

#73

One doesn't know how stressful and infuriating these copyright notices are until one lived in a country with internet hijacked by copyright predators. From the moment of receiving such notice there is only stress, misinformation, and verbal abuse. Thanks Americans. PS. It doesn't matter you downloaded free software, every person you'll contact in the process of straightening this out will be equally clueless and abus…

> a country with internet hijacked by copyright predators Yeah, thank god my country is not among this group. We have better things to do than police imaginary american property. I remember reading a news article years ago about some MPAA lobbyist who came here to do his thing. A journalist asked him point blank if intellectual property should be a priority in a country that can barely manage to provide basic infrast…

This is an awful symptom of American cultural colonialism. They feed with one hand while slapping in the face with the other. Choke with your sitcoms and superheroes.

Re: Online Antipiracy firm sending copyright notices for downloading Ubuntu ISO

#74
post #34

This is why DMCA is broken. Too easy for false claims. It’s plagued the music industry, YouTube, and now free software.

Why is it that as citizens we are powerless against such clearly broken laws as DMCA? Can't we do something about the situation, declare it unconstitutional or something?

Because the copyright industry is worth literally billions of dollars and they invest a good chunk of that money into lobbying the government. They essentially buy the laws that they want. There's no way any individual can possibly hope to compete with that. Better to make subversive technology instead. We neutralize their ridiculous laws by making it impossible to enforce or punish anyone violating them.

Re: Online Antipiracy firm sending copyright notices for downloading Ubuntu ISO

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> a country with internet hijacked by copyright predators Yeah, thank god my country is not among this group. We have better things to do than police imaginary american property. I remember reading a news article years ago about some MPAA lobbyist who came here to do his thing. A journalist asked him point blank if intellectual property should be a priority in a country that can barely manage to provide basic infrast…

This is an awful symptom of American cultural colonialism. They feed with one hand while slapping in the face with the other. Choke with your sitcoms and superheroes.

Yeah. And if you don't at least look like you're cooperating, the USA will put you in a literal naughty list of bad countries and develop "action plans" for dealing with it.

https://ustr.gov/sites/default/files/2019_Special_301_Report...

You can't just isolate yourself from them either without massive economic consequences. Even if you suffered through those consequences, they'll probably just force you to trade anyway just like they did with Japan once.

Re: Online Antipiracy firm sending copyright notices for downloading Ubuntu ISO

#77

Hmmm. Linux, and intellectual property. I should say my personal hobby is walking into libertarian communities, asking if there's such a thing as intellectual property, then walking out whistling.

Don't speak in riddles, use plain language and explain your position.

Re: Online Antipiracy firm sending copyright notices for downloading Ubuntu ISO

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's on the [0] link, with the line 4ba4fbf7231a3a660e86892707d25c135533a16a ubuntu-20.04.2.0-desktop-amd64.iso 2.67GiB 120 8 1 2.67GiB

yep, but the comment I replied to said they searched for the hash and found [2] (I presume they searched on google from context). When I search for the hash I don't find [2] coming up in my search results, and when I click through to [2] I don't see the hash in the page.

Pardon for my misinterpretation. Although I don't use google much these days, but I'd assume it be due to location/preference tailor.

And yes, I don't see the hash in the page too, I should read it more carefully before commenting. Sorry for the confusion.

Re: Online Antipiracy firm sending copyright notices for downloading Ubuntu ISO

#79
post #62
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even worse, they are given free access (no warrant) to ISP information about the individuals they presume to be infringing so they can tie an identity to an IP linked to infringing material. Lawyers win either way, via the fines that they ask for (people are scared that this could escalate and just pay), or the fees to fight the fines (usually a letter highlighting the situation that personal information was obtained…

They do need a court order, see my other comment

There are ISPs who provide that information based on agreements with the law firms (what you called the automated process - quite literally there's no meaningful human intervention at any point which goes against every principle). Those cases will be dropped as soon as they receive a counter letter from a lawyer because it's the kind of thing that's supposed to stay in the shadow.

A court order is not supposed to be automated because it's exceedingly simple to make it output whatever you want while still claiming good faith.

Re: Online Antipiracy firm sending copyright notices for downloading Ubuntu ISO

#80
post #19

Interesting tidbit: the hash they have for the infringed work it's the correct hash for ubuntu-20.04.2.0-desktop-amd64.iso [0] - this removes any good faith argument on their part. There is an infinitely small chance of collisions - but I would like them to produce a DMCA notice with the actual name of the infringed upon protected media, not just the hash. I believe Canonical should step in, since this is someone cla…

Could it be some pictures or sound or some firmware blob or something like that this is in that particular ISO is the actual content they consider to be pirated ?
Post reply on HN