Live data from Hacker News

Inkscape 1.1

inkscape.org

121–130 of 167 posts

Re: Inkscape 1.1

#121
post #113

I love Inkscape. Taught my self how to use this 15+ years ago. Use it 2-10x per year since. It's always there. It does not change UI much between releases. I dont have to download a cracked version of some commercial tool because I'm to stingy to buy expensive software for a simple task at hand. Inkscape (and Gimp) have helped me a lot in this regard.

Gimp is underrated in my opinion. Most of the complaints I've seen about it boil down to it not being a 1:1 clone of Photoshop

Re: Inkscape 1.1

#122
I love Inkscape, and even more so now that I found the included tutorials. A pleasure to use. Can’t wait until it works again on the latest OS X! (Not whining, to be clear - I fully understand how little Apple cares about making it easy to support this type of software across upgrades).

Re: Inkscape 1.1

#124
post #114

Inkscape is garbage. I downloaded SVG map of the world from Wikipedia. Used bucket fill to change color of one country, it failed (it created new shape that barely resembled country but was inaccurate, as if someone traced it by hand). I mean what's the point of vector graphic app of it cannot do basic operation after two decades of development. It's not like I wanted to do something obscure.

And just another FYI, but you need to remember that an SVG is a structured document, where the structure may or not be obviously reflected in how it is rendered. I'm not sure which SVG you were playing with, but for instance if I grab https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/de/Politica... and then ungroup the top level (or 2nd level on some objects) I can easily select whole countries "colour" and manipulate and change them. And that particular file has grouped non-contiguous nations like Indonesia or Australia properly associating the islands. But as others have said here - your issue is nothing to with Inkscape but the SVG you have chosen and how you expect it to behave.

Re: Inkscape 1.1

#125
post #113

I love Inkscape. Taught my self how to use this 15+ years ago. Use it 2-10x per year since. It's always there. It does not change UI much between releases. I dont have to download a cracked version of some commercial tool because I'm to stingy to buy expensive software for a simple task at hand. Inkscape (and Gimp) have helped me a lot in this regard.

Gimp is underrated in my opinion. Most of the complaints I've seen about it boil down to it not being a 1:1 clone of Photoshop

If it was a 1:1 clone, it would have to change it's UI as much as PS does. I dont even know PS UI: Gimp was always there for me.

Gimp is much better than PS for my use case. And not having to pay some sick subscription is a big reason to stay away from them.

Re: Inkscape 1.1

#126
post #113

I love Inkscape. Taught my self how to use this 15+ years ago. Use it 2-10x per year since. It's always there. It does not change UI much between releases. I dont have to download a cracked version of some commercial tool because I'm to stingy to buy expensive software for a simple task at hand. Inkscape (and Gimp) have helped me a lot in this regard.

Gimp is underrated in my opinion. Most of the complaints I've seen about it boil down to it not being a 1:1 clone of Photoshop

I agree that it's a bit underrated, but I disagree about the complaints. People don't complain about it not being a Photoshop clone. People complain about the UX/ergonomics of gimp being decades behind compared to Adobe's tools.

It doesn't need the same workflows as Photoshop, but it definitely needs to improve them

I will add that copying Photoshop would be an easy all-around win because Photoshop has engineered their UX. I'd say it would be pretty hard to come up with better alternates than what Photoshop has probably.

There are cheaper alternatives to Photoshop that get their UX much better than Gimp. To name two: Gravit (£3/m) or Krita (FOSS), but they're not exactly photo manipulation, though.

Re: Inkscape 1.1

#127
post #123
post #4

Only thing I find annoying in Inkscape is doing simple crops of images

I think there's a new filter for that[0]. [0] https://media.inkscape.org/media/doc/release_notes/1.1/Inksc...

Excellent, thanks

Re: Inkscape 1.1

#128

I installed Inkscape the other day to try to rescale and save an simple SVG for the web. When I took a look at the text saved in the file, I was pretty shocked to discover it saved the entire path of the file in the file . In other words, it saves a directory structure that could contain your username, the name of the project you're working on, what company you're working for, etc. Felt like a pretty shocking invasio…

Always run your files through strings before sending to the web.

Re: Inkscape 1.1

#129

I installed Inkscape the other day to try to rescale and save an simple SVG for the web. When I took a look at the text saved in the file, I was pretty shocked to discover it saved the entire path of the file in the file . In other words, it saves a directory structure that could contain your username, the name of the project you're working on, what company you're working for, etc. Felt like a pretty shocking invasio…

I feel like the main mistake here is that Inkscape uses the .svg extension for what it basically it's own format. While it is essentially .svg compatible, it includes many extensions and metadata necessary for Inkscape to function. You should really save as optimized or plain .svg before publishing anything made in Inkscape.

Re: Inkscape 1.1

#130

I installed Inkscape the other day to try to rescale and save an simple SVG for the web. When I took a look at the text saved in the file, I was pretty shocked to discover it saved the entire path of the file in the file . In other words, it saves a directory structure that could contain your username, the name of the project you're working on, what company you're working for, etc. Felt like a pretty shocking invasio…

Excellent tool for removing all the fluff: https://jakearchibald.github.io/svgomg/

Another great tool is https://exiftool.org/
Post reply on HN