Live data from Hacker News

Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

techcrunch.com

51–60 of 117 posts

Re: Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

#51
post #13
post #7

The ruling party released a fake document, suggesting that the opposition is engaging in subversive activities. It was fact checked by various independent agencies and found to be a fake document. Twitter added a "manipulated media" label to those tweets. Delhi police, which is directly controlled by the Indian government raided the office of Twitter. It is not done with the intention of finding anything. It is to ha…

What is up with the comments in this thread? How are people seeing this as the Indian government taking a stand against censorship or whatever? The same government is upset that Twitter reinstated several accounts critical of the administration.

Either they are the Modi sycophants or just don't like twitter and otherwise have no clue what's going on in India.

Re: Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My guess is that people of certain political leanings have seen multiple stories "fact-checked" by Facebook/Twitter/Google as false and suppressed turn out to be true or partially true months down the line. These people are relieved to see another government, any government, give twitter/facebook/google "what's coming to it"

> people of certain political leanings have seen multiple stories "fact-checked" by Facebook/Twitter/Google as false and suppressed turn out to be true or partially true months down the line. Nothing is perfect, but what are you referring to specifically?

Early in 2020 alternative media discussions that COVID may have leaked from a lab were ruthlessly "fack-checked" and censored from social media for misinformation. Now that we know more these claims have become accepted as a very real possibility.

Re: Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My guess is that people of certain political leanings have seen multiple stories "fact-checked" by Facebook/Twitter/Google as false and suppressed turn out to be true or partially true months down the line. These people are relieved to see another government, any government, give twitter/facebook/google "what's coming to it"

> people of certain political leanings have seen multiple stories "fact-checked" by Facebook/Twitter/Google as false and suppressed turn out to be true or partially true months down the line. Nothing is perfect, but what are you referring to specifically?

Not done by a tech company, but here's an example of dubious fact checking:

@MSNBC Oct 9, 2016 FACT CHECK: Trump says Clinton "acid washed" her email server. She did not.

The Claim

Trump says Clinton 'acid washed' her email server.

The Truth

Clinton's team used an app called BleachBit; she did not use a corrosive chemical.

[0] https://twitter.com/msnbc/status/785299708730339328?lang=en

Re: Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

#54

In related news Russia plans to force tech giants to open offices on its soil specifically to raid them: https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2021/05/21/russia-moves-to-fo...

The next move: “We don’t do any real work here, but you’re getting hazard pay for a reason.”

It would be a deterrent to hire ex-KBG, ex-military, family members of key politicians...

Re: Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> people of certain political leanings have seen multiple stories "fact-checked" by Facebook/Twitter/Google as false and suppressed turn out to be true or partially true months down the line. Nothing is perfect, but what are you referring to specifically?

Politifact and COVID origin

Conspiracy theories that COVID was released intentionally by China are still false, same as they were every time this idea gets brought up.

Re: Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

#56
post #49
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is up with the comments in this thread? How are people seeing this as the Indian government taking a stand against censorship or whatever? The same government is upset that Twitter reinstated several accounts critical of the administration.

In general, Indians living abroad are highly supportive of the Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Not his party, or his government, or his policies ... just him personally. Hacker News contains many such people. They are responsible for the bizarre comments you've read on this thread. On a related note, this thread will soon be flagged, like all threads that are even mildly, indirectly critical of Narendra Modi. En…

Anyone having a different opinion than me is wrong ?

Re: Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> people of certain political leanings have seen multiple stories "fact-checked" by Facebook/Twitter/Google as false and suppressed turn out to be true or partially true months down the line. Nothing is perfect, but what are you referring to specifically?

Early in 2020 alternative media discussions that COVID may have leaked from a lab were ruthlessly "fack-checked" and censored from social media for misinformation. Now that we know more these claims have become accepted as a very real possibility.

Were they censored? IIRC they were only labeled as "not fact checked" - which at the time was true.

It seems lots of emerging stories should carry that label.

Re: Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

#58
post #35

Title does not match article. >Delhi Police raids Twitter offices over manipulated label >Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

Clickbait journalism. Its a race to the bottom to get attention of reader using raunchy titles

Re: Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Delhi Police, controlled by India’s central government, on Monday evening searched two offices of Twitter — in the national capital state of Delhi and Gurgaon, in neighboring state of Haryana — to seek more information about Twitter’s rationale to label one of the tweets by ruling partly BJP spokesperson as “manipulated media.” > An hour into the search process, Delhi Police Special Cell team, which investigates te…

They were searching for a representative to serve the notice to.

Serve notice of what? This didn't seem to be mentioned in the article.

Also, is that a thing police in India do? Here in the US, if documents need to be physically served, it's usually done by a single representative of the court, not a policeman, let alone many police.

Re: Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated media’ label

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Politifact and COVID origin

Any basis for this? The origin is unknown, afaik.

Problem is and was stating ”lab origin” as a false narrative when we truly just don’t know.

Of course a Politifact that says ”we dont know” is useless and so they have to invent truths to be relevant.

Post reply on HN