Live data from Hacker News

Poll: What's your least favorite component of MS Office

news.ycombinator.com

21–28 of 28 posts

Re: Poll: What's your least favorite component of MS Office

#26

I'm not a fan of any component in particular, well apart from one surprise, so I thought I'd have a rant: Word - separation of content and layout is an absolute bugger to manage. Hard to share and version documents. It's actually hard to write a letter or lengthy document with it if you don't have a template to hand. Excel - utter dog if you need to use it for anything more than trivial and all it does is "ugly" and…

> Word - separation of content and layout is an absolute bugger to manage.

This is the result of the WYSIWYG generation. "Ancient" systems like TeX (and even WordPerfect) did much better with this and got better looking output on balance, but with our newfangled "OOhh! Pretty!" systems, everyone thinks they're a designer. So, we get systems like Word.

Re: Poll: What's your least favorite component of MS Office

#27

I'm not a fan of any component in particular, well apart from one surprise, so I thought I'd have a rant: Word - separation of content and layout is an absolute bugger to manage. Hard to share and version documents. It's actually hard to write a letter or lengthy document with it if you don't have a template to hand. Excel - utter dog if you need to use it for anything more than trivial and all it does is "ugly" and…

> Word - separation of content and layout is an absolute bugger to manage. This is the result of the WYSIWYG generation. "Ancient" systems like TeX (and even WordPerfect) did much better with this and got better looking output on balance, but with our newfangled "OOhh! Pretty!" systems, everyone thinks they're a designer. So, we get systems like Word.

So true. I am an avid TeX user btw. I'm actually addicted to the appearance of Knuth's Computer Modern fonts really though.
Post reply on HN