Live data from Hacker News

The One Google Plus Feature Facebook Should Fear

allfacebook.com

21–30 of 93 posts

Re: The One Google Plus Feature Facebook Should Fear

#21
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're one step ahead of me: I love the ideas in Google+ and want to use it, but I haven't gotten an invite yet!

I got an invite, to my google apps domain account. Can't use it.

I don't think invites are tied to specific email addresses?

Re: The One Google Plus Feature Facebook Should Fear

#23
post #21
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I got an invite, to my google apps domain account. Can't use it.

I don't think invites are tied to specific email addresses?

They are. I attempted to use the signup invite link given on a different account, it failed.

Re: The One Google Plus Feature Facebook Should Fear

#24
post #7

This article is dead on. I already have many google apps open all day and g+ will integrate with those nicely. A friend already exclaimed this morning that the google apps integration is what will kill FB (if that's even possible - myspace still has users). He then set out to move over those he actually cared about on FB to g+. I especially like default use of groups and how it forces users to think about privacy fro…

Damn. How are these people getting invites?

Re: The One Google Plus Feature Facebook Should Fear

#25
post #7

This article is dead on. I already have many google apps open all day and g+ will integrate with those nicely. A friend already exclaimed this morning that the google apps integration is what will kill FB (if that's even possible - myspace still has users). He then set out to move over those he actually cared about on FB to g+. I especially like default use of groups and how it forces users to think about privacy fro…

Damn. How are these people getting invites?

G+ person zero in my social circle bought their invite on ebay for $2 this AM. He put everyone else in a circle and started posting. All those in the circle had received invites from him by the end of the day.

Re: The One Google Plus Feature Facebook Should Fear

#26
post #23
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think invites are tied to specific email addresses?

They are. I attempted to use the signup invite link given on a different account, it failed.

Might have been a generic failure due to a signup rate limiting. Maybe it's worth retrying for a couple of time.

Re: The One Google Plus Feature Facebook Should Fear

#27
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're one step ahead of me: I love the ideas in Google+ and want to use it, but I haven't gotten an invite yet!

I got an invite, to my google apps domain account. Can't use it.

I thought profiles are now enabled on Google Apps -- or do you mean your domain manager won't turn on the profiles?

Re: The One Google Plus Feature Facebook Should Fear

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Appleseed has already addressed this. When you comment, a push notification is sent to the group defined the context . Actions are not broadcast, contexts are. IE, Alice posts a blog, which is available to Group A. Bob posts a comment to the blog, and members of Group A are notified (even if they're not on Bob's friends list). Chris, who is on Bob's friends list, but not a member of Group A, will not receive a notifi…

That's still potentially confusing, though. Bob has no idea who is part of Group A apart from himself. He could probably check, but there's a cognitive load/uncertainty there that equals friction to every secondary action (like a comment). So there's two problems: 1. Bob might comment on Alice's post thinking he's in his own social context, which is reinforced by the fact that on Google+, he's in his own UI and Alice…

Google already has a product named Places (I think it's kind of like Yelp?), but I get your meaning.

Re: The One Google Plus Feature Facebook Should Fear

#29
So true. The red notification really hooks you back in.

It's because Google+'s social signal to noise ratio is so much higher than Facebook. I dread the red notifications in FB's upper left corner bc they're usually from some friend of friend's irrelevant spam event/survey/tagging etc. Google+ Circles really filters thats out.

Facebook's mistake was introducing Groups so late. With Circles, users can create Circles AS friends join. I will never retroactively organize my Facebook "friends" into Groups. I will, however, take a little time each day as new REAL friends come to Google+ to organize them to reflect real social structure.

Google 1. Facebook 0.

Re: The One Google Plus Feature Facebook Should Fear

#30
post #22

This is actually a misfeature -- it's hard enough to avoid procrastinating without having to summon the super-human willpower necessary to avoid clicking your notifications every time you do a simple search.

It's a misfeature if you are trying to actually get work done, but in my experience people aren't exactly going to use a different search engine so that they can avoid seeing something that they want to see. They are going to use the same one and complain "why do I have friends!" while reading their messages and procrastinating on their work.
Post reply on HN