Live data from Hacker News

FBI Has Gained Access to Sci-Hub Founder's Apple Account, Email Claims

torrentfreak.com

141–150 of 322 posts

Re: FBI Has Gained Access to Sci-Hub Founder's Apple Account, Email Claims

#141

Why is fbi interested? Can anyone explain

Because the main purpose of law enforcement is to enforce the property rights of the wealthy and well-connected. Things like catching murderers and rapists is a secondary concern that occasionally happens by accident.

Re: FBI Has Gained Access to Sci-Hub Founder's Apple Account, Email Claims

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Would they take a chance and miss a juicy account at Google/Facebook etc? I don’t think so. Therefore it’s likely they issued requests but Google/Facebook etc were less “inclined” to talk about these things.

This is the correct take. When have they ever ?

No, it's absolutely false.

https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/story/2021-03-24...

> In Google’s case, the company typically lets users know which agency is seeking their information.

Re: FBI Has Gained Access to Sci-Hub Founder's Apple Account, Email Claims

#143
post #131
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, remember that presidential candidate Bernie Sanders also got smeared with Russian interference, so it is not something only used on Trump or Trump supporters. In my country, Sweden, alleging connections to Russia or Putin is often used in the political discourse to silence individuals or groups, without any sort of proof. It has happened both on the right and the left. We have to remember that many journalists i…

Fox News and conservatives supporting sources smeared sanders that way. Part of it was likely to muddy the waters since Trump had an actual Russia thing, and part was to play up the gops age old boogie man, socialism.

What Russia thing would that be?

Re: FBI Has Gained Access to Sci-Hub Founder's Apple Account, Email Claims

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did FBI investigate Bernie Sanders and his associates?

Na, cause Bernies team did not speak with the russians unlike trumps team whom spoke with, meet with, and gave information to the russians.

What information to whom?

Re: FBI Has Gained Access to Sci-Hub Founder's Apple Account, Email Claims

#145
post #11

Why would you use Apple software/services for anything like this? You know it's backdoored.

What are you going to switch to? Android?

Sure, because at least then I can have a top-down view of my security, instead of having it abstracted away into corners where I have to trust Apple to do the right thing (see article above as for why we don't do that).

Re: FBI Has Gained Access to Sci-Hub Founder's Apple Account, Email Claims

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple has always been subject to US law, and as such, was always required to provide information that they do have access to. If it's in iCloud, most of it can be extracted by the law enforcement with court order. Nothing changed between now and the San Bernardino case. The difference was that FBI wanted Apple to compromise device encryption, which capability does _not_ exist now.

So why hasn't end-to-end encryption been utilized for years with the storage of email and other files, like they do with iMessage content?

Email can't be secured for many reasons; use a modern, secure messaging app for that, such as Signal. Regarding encryption in particular:

Encrypting email metadata prevents emails from being delivered and processed. Metadata is as valuable as the content of the email.

Encrypting emails at rest prevents server-side services from operating, such as webmail.

Re: FBI Has Gained Access to Sci-Hub Founder's Apple Account, Email Claims

#148

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> They can do it to anyone. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes. I fully expect that any American, involved in half the shit that drunk found his way into, would also be under double top secret surveillance. That's reality Jack.

That's a very low standard you are setting for your democratic government. Political prosecutions and spying on counsel is something that the Communists and Nazis did. But even they tried to follow their own laws.

If Rudy Guilliani is defending the democratically elected president of the United States, he should be beholden to the interests of the people. If our government has the legal ability to attain this data, this is a textbook example of how and why to use it.

Re: FBI Has Gained Access to Sci-Hub Founder's Apple Account, Email Claims

#149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Does this case establish precedent that the fifth amendment applies to people in Kazakhstan?

Onus of precedent would have to be that it does not . If you're able to find any such, I might have further interest in this line of questioning. Though I doubt even that.

You think the US Constitution of the United States* of America restricts what the US can do to non-citizens who aren't in the US at all?

What possible reason could you have for that thought?

Precedent is that protections like that are created by treaties like the Geneva Convention.

Re: FBI Has Gained Access to Sci-Hub Founder's Apple Account, Email Claims

#150
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is technically impossible to end-to-end encrypt email.

People routinely do end to end encryption with email every day using either OpenPGP or S/MIME. Heck, email encryption is where the term "end to end encryption" came from. When someone claims E2EE for some other sort of messaging system they have to at least be as good at it as the email case to be taken seriously.

> People routinely do end to end encryption with email every day using either OpenPGP or S/MIME.

Those solutions encrypt only the content and not the headers, which are just as important. Also, encrypting the content prevents some webmail services from functioning, such as search.

Email can't really be made secure.

Post reply on HN