Live data from Hacker News

What really drives the poor

livemint.com

1–10 of 110 posts

Re: What really drives the poor

#2
Good insights, though instead of biometric (?!) based money transfers, I'd like to see a further push on phone based transfers and other branchless banking. Recent research reported through CGAP shows branchless transfers being used increasingly by the poor, http://technology.cgap.org/2011/06/17/does-branchless-bankin... I was hoping they might discuss Microfinance's role in helping the poor reach their goals, since at kiva.org we tend to think of microloans as one of the small steps towards solving the problems they face.

Re: What really drives the poor

#6
They finally hit on the real story halfway down:

"“Generally, it is clear that things that make life less boring are a priority for the poor,” they write in their new book."

Yes, the poor spend their money unwisely when they have extra. That's the real reason.

If a rich person finds themselves down on their luck, they knuckle down and work really hard to get into a situation where they can afford to buy luxuries.

It isn't about lack of opportunity. It's about wise choices.

I can't find the story now, but there was a fairly wealthy man who decided to give all that up and see if poor people could pull themselves up. He stowed his credit cards and cash and went to live on the street. He started at day-labor sites until his work ethic paid off and he got a steady job from someone. He had goals like an apartment, a car, etc, with a certain amount of cash in the bank. He gave himself 1 year. At 9 months, he had completed his goal, and a family member fell ill. He quite before the 1 year, but he had already completed his goals and was on his way to a good life.

In other words, he spent his money wisely and was able to vastly improve his lifestyle in less than a year. But most poor people say it's impossible. Are they not trying? Are they trying, but making too many bad decisions?

Re: What really drives the poor

#7
post #5

Poor people are human beings, so I assume it's the same things that drive other people.

it's amazing how few policymakers realise that. mostly, the poor tend to be infantilised and patronised.

To be blunt, quite a few politicians really don't want changes to the current status because it would endanger their power-base. If you ran on an issue, it is helpful not to solve the issue and blame the other guy for not solving it.

One example is bilingual education. There are very effective groups and lessons that can teach students English in a short amount of time, allowing the student to be in the same classrooms as everyone else. But if that student (or anyone else) doesn't speak the language of the majority, they are easier to control because they are not independent and need "special" programs. If they were bilingual, then they would have a better chance than 1 language people to get jobs and opportunities. More language = More options. Instead we get a lot of empty political rhetoric that keeps everything the same.

Re: What really drives the poor

#9

They finally hit on the real story halfway down: "“Generally, it is clear that things that make life less boring are a priority for the poor,” they write in their new book." Yes, the poor spend their money unwisely when they have extra. That's the real reason. If a rich person finds themselves down on their luck, they knuckle down and work really hard to get into a situation where they can afford to buy luxuries. It…

For one thing, it makes a lot of difference whether or not you have a safety net when you're on a tightrope.

Re: What really drives the poor

#10

They finally hit on the real story halfway down: "“Generally, it is clear that things that make life less boring are a priority for the poor,” they write in their new book." Yes, the poor spend their money unwisely when they have extra. That's the real reason. If a rich person finds themselves down on their luck, they knuckle down and work really hard to get into a situation where they can afford to buy luxuries. It…

That story ignores so many of the issues related to growing up in poverty. If poverty is all you've ever been around, it's never as simple as just "working hard and making good decisions".
Post reply on HN