Live data from Hacker News

Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab

newatlas.com

11–20 of 250 posts

Re: Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab

#11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Anything with human levels of cognition and/or awareness should be considered a person.

What counts as human levels of cognition/awareness? There are many birds that would rank higher thank human toddlers on the cognitive and awareness scale.

Note the “should”.

Re: Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab

#14
> The announcement of the new chimeras will no doubt be labelled “unnatural” or “playing God” by some people – but the same could be said about many scientific breakthroughs. An iPhone is unnatural.

This is quite possibly the worst take about anything I've ever heard. Intelligent human-monkey hybrids brought in to the world for the purpose of having their organs harvested, vs lil pocket computer.

Re: Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab

#16
post #3

Not the first time, unlike what the article says [1]. I don't know if there was any follow-up on the previous case, but a big ethical concern was that human DNA was used to increase their brain capacity, and if they had been allowed to be born, then they would have been as intelligent as humans. So it raises the question of what counts as a human, and did the scientists effectively create "humans" in a lab, then term…

[deleted]

Re: Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab

#18
post #14

> The announcement of the new chimeras will no doubt be labelled “unnatural” or “playing God” by some people – but the same could be said about many scientific breakthroughs. An iPhone is unnatural. This is quite possibly the worst take about anything I've ever heard. Intelligent human-monkey hybrids brought in to the world for the purpose of having their organs harvested, vs lil pocket computer.

The lil pocket computer is harvesting your thoughts though.

Re: Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab

#19
post #3

Not the first time, unlike what the article says [1]. I don't know if there was any follow-up on the previous case, but a big ethical concern was that human DNA was used to increase their brain capacity, and if they had been allowed to be born, then they would have been as intelligent as humans. So it raises the question of what counts as a human, and did the scientists effectively create "humans" in a lab, then term…

Humans are created in the lab and then destroyed when no longer needed all the time during IVF procedures, but nobody seems to care.

Some of us do care. There’s a reason the Catholic church is opposed to IVF.

Re: Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab

#20

It's surprising how little legislation there is on this topic despite long being a trope in fiction.

Last I recall there's quite a lot of legislation regarding genetics stuff, too much in my opinion, believe thats why you usually here progress like this happening in other countries
Post reply on HN