Live data from Hacker News

Stranded sailor allowed to leave abandoned ship after four years

bbc.com

21–30 of 426 posts

Re: Stranded sailor allowed to leave abandoned ship after four years

#21

If he had silently sneaked off the ship, would someone have noticed? How long would it take for anyone to notice that a ship without power and crewed by just 1 person was actually abandoned?

The big problem would have likely been how to get home without drawing the attention of the local authorities.

EDIT: Apparently his passport may have been confiscated.

Re: Stranded sailor allowed to leave abandoned ship after four years

#22
post #8

It is supremely unfair for the court to assign him full responsibility for the ship, but without any power over it. If the court were serious about the situation they should have handed the ship over to him entirely. He could then put the ship up on the market for whomever wanted to buy it or sell it to a scrapping company. If you think this would be unfair to the ships owners this is exactly the point. Force them to…

Yeah that is the part I do not understand.

Isn't there a law at sea where if you find an abandoned ship, it is basically yours? Perhaps this law doesn't apply in Egyptian national waters?

If he is the legal guardian of the ship, why wouldn't he be able to just sell it for profit and move on? Was it just that there would be no buyer for it, even to scrap it? Or could there have been fines/liens on that ship such that no one would want to buy it? If that is the case it seems odd that he couldn't himself abandon the ship to the lien holders.

Re: Stranded sailor allowed to leave abandoned ship after four years

#23

If he had silently sneaked off the ship, would someone have noticed? How long would it take for anyone to notice that a ship without power and crewed by just 1 person was actually abandoned?

From the article, he did sneak off the ship routinely after it ran aground some years later. He would sneak off, buy food and recharge his phone, then return to the ship for some bizarre reason.

Re: Stranded sailor allowed to leave abandoned ship after four years

#24
post #7

How was he being supplied before the ship ran aground?

according to news articles he SWAM to shore to pick up basic supplies. Not even a small rowing boat or something was made available to him.

That was only after it ran aground. The article says that before that, he was anchored, presumably far enough out that he had no way to get to shore.

Re: Stranded sailor allowed to leave abandoned ship after four years

#25
post #2

I don't understand why he couldn't just get on another ship and leave forever. Worst case you just never go back to that shitty country right?

So... never be able to captain a ship that goes through the SuezCanal?

How many times does he need to captain a ship to make up for 4 years of lost wages? That's not even accounting for the psychological toll.

Re: Stranded sailor allowed to leave abandoned ship after four years

#26

But he is determined. He says he is good at his job and wants nothing more than to pick up where he left off. Meanwhile HN commenters be moaning every time their scrollbar is hijacked by a link or they have to deal with spaghetti code at work like "I'm so burned out"

If this guy was staring at the same code I stare at hours per day he would probably also be moaning at times.

Re: Stranded sailor allowed to leave abandoned ship after four years

#27
post #7

How was he being supplied before the ship ran aground?

according to news articles he SWAM to shore to pick up basic supplies. Not even a small rowing boat or something was made available to him.

In the article it states that he started swimming to shore only after the ship had run aground a few hundred meters from the shore. So the question remains, how did he sustain himself beforehand? Did the ship have years worth of supplies for him on board?

Re: Stranded sailor allowed to leave abandoned ship after four years

#28
post #19

If he had silently sneaked off the ship, would someone have noticed? How long would it take for anyone to notice that a ship without power and crewed by just 1 person was actually abandoned?

I was wondering about this. My guess (just a guess) was that since he wants to still work in this industry, he was afraid that abandoning the ship would hurt his career? Either that, or he's just an incredibly responsible person.

If you’ve been unjustly imprisoned for several years, you probably don’t worry too much about your career?

Re: Stranded sailor allowed to leave abandoned ship after four years

#29
post #8

It is supremely unfair for the court to assign him full responsibility for the ship, but without any power over it. If the court were serious about the situation they should have handed the ship over to him entirely. He could then put the ship up on the market for whomever wanted to buy it or sell it to a scrapping company. If you think this would be unfair to the ships owners this is exactly the point. Force them to…

> The article says there are thousands of these cases

It said 250, not thousands.

Re: Stranded sailor allowed to leave abandoned ship after four years

#30
post #8

It is supremely unfair for the court to assign him full responsibility for the ship, but without any power over it. If the court were serious about the situation they should have handed the ship over to him entirely. He could then put the ship up on the market for whomever wanted to buy it or sell it to a scrapping company. If you think this would be unfair to the ships owners this is exactly the point. Force them to…

You're assuming that it's valuable to a scrapping company. Sometimes a grounded ship is more trouble than it's worth.
Post reply on HN