The professor gets exactly what they want here, no? "We experimented on the linux kernel team to see what would happen. Our non-double-blind test of 1 FOSS maintenance group has produced the following result: We get banned and our entire university gets dragged through the muck 100% of the time". That'll be a fun paper to write, no doubt. Additional context: * One of the committers of these faulty patches, Aditya Pak…
> The thread then gets down to business and starts coordinating revert patches for everything committed by University of Minnesota email addresses. What's preventing those bad actors from not using a UMN email address?
“They introduce kernel bugs on purpose”
271–280 of 1001 posts
Re: “They introduce kernel bugs on purpose”
#272I don't think there have been any recent comments from anyone at U.Mn. So, back when the original research (happened last year) the following clarification was offered by Qiushi Wu and Kangjie Lu which atleast paints their research in somewhat better light: https://www-users.cs.umn.edu/~kjlu/papers/clarifications-hc.... That said the current incident seems to have gone beyond the limits of that one and is a new incid…
These ~200 patches from UMN being reverted might have nothing to do with these researchers at all.
Hopefully someone from the university clarifies what's happening soon before the angry mob tries to eat the wrong people.
Re: “They introduce kernel bugs on purpose”
#273Re: “They introduce kernel bugs on purpose”
#274Re: “They introduce kernel bugs on purpose”
#275Re: “They introduce kernel bugs on purpose”
#276The professor gets exactly what they want here, no? "We experimented on the linux kernel team to see what would happen. Our non-double-blind test of 1 FOSS maintenance group has produced the following result: We get banned and our entire university gets dragged through the muck 100% of the time". That'll be a fun paper to write, no doubt. Additional context: * One of the committers of these faulty patches, Aditya Pak…
Isn't this reaction a bit like the emperor banishing anyone who tells him that his new clothes are fake? Are the maintainers upset that someone showed how easy it is to subvert kernel security?
Re: “They introduce kernel bugs on purpose”
#277Unfortunately even if the latest submissions were sent with good intentions and have nothing to do with the bug research, the University has certainly lost the trust of the kernel maintainers.
Re: “They introduce kernel bugs on purpose”
#278[flagged]
Re: “They introduce kernel bugs on purpose”
#279The system appears to have worked, so that's good news for Linux. On the other hand, now that the university has been banned, they won't be able to find holes in the process that may remain, that's bad news for Linux.