Live data from Hacker News

Mastodon Renaming “Toots” to “Posts”

github.com

71–80 of 110 posts

Re: Mastodon Renaming “Toots” to “Posts”

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't find “to toot” sound any stranger than “to tweet”.

In the US, “toot” is not only a word used for something you might do with a horn. It also means “a fart.” A hilariously bad name if your humor is like that of a child. (Mine is)

A horn played badly also sounds like farting, so perhaps that's where the second meaning came from.

Re: Mastodon Renaming “Toots” to “Posts”

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s apparently a variant. I realized that the “magical” version was much more common than I’d expected a couple of years ago and did some informal research. It seems about evenly split, and I didn’t see any regional correlation.

I'm not surprised. That's why there are qualifiers. It's not intended as smack talk asserting " My variation is better than yours!" (Throws down gloves.) Sometimes, it's nigh impossible to readily come up with the wording that captures the myriad thoughts flitting about my mind and account for all possible social bits and potential misinterpretations. And I comment anyway, knowing it's likely to go sideways cuz hooma…

The "musical" form seems more refined, bringing poetry to a variant that is otherwise botanically problematic and nutritionally attenuated.

Re: Mastodon Renaming “Toots” to “Posts”

#73
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My wife, exasperated at our two teenaged boys, asked me if men ever outgrow fart jokes. I laughed, said maybe, then asked her to pull my finger. Though when primed with the word Mastodon, I did think of the large trunk and a cartoon-like trumpeting of that trunk. Right after thinking how my grandmother would call her farts toots.

Fart jokes have always been found funny at all age and maturity levels. Even Martin Luther made fart jokes: "When the argument that the Christian is without the law and above the law doesn’t help, I instantly chase him away with a fart."

The oldest known recorded joke, from ancient Sumeria, is a fart joke.

Re: Mastodon Renaming “Toots” to “Posts”

#74

I know little about Mastodon, but it seems like somebody went out of their way to make the cringiest sounding product possible. “Hey man, I just tooted on mastodon!” It really sounds like parody. I hope I am just missing the point. You might say this is a superficial criticism, but I think naming is important when it comes to social appeal. At least, it becomes important when the naming has gone so horribly wrong. If…

This is, superficially and stupid as it was, why I never really felt comfortable recommending “FogBugz” bug tracker from Fog Creek software. No disrespect to any capability it may have had, but I couldn’t bring myself to recommend something called that in serious conversation.

Re: Mastodon Renaming “Toots” to “Posts”

#75
Imagine Mastodon was planning this all along. A card up their sleeves for increasing adoption. They named them toots (which is silly to begin with and likely captures attention) JUST so they could change it to posts and get more eyes on a hn post like this.

Genius marketing.

Re: Mastodon Renaming “Toots” to “Posts”

#77
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"toot" means "fart" where I'm from. Imagine a social network where they referred to posts by users as "farts". "Your fart was shared by 230 of your followers." "This fart is NSFW" "This fart has been promoted" "Pin this fart to the top of your feed" It does seem like a poor choice of words. Tweeting on the other hand didn't have a negative connotation until Twitter became what it is today and gave it a negative conno…

fun fact: that was kind of the plot of a letterkenny episode, called "Fartbook", from season 1. it's really good! https://letterkenny.fandom.com/wiki/Fartbook

That’s a Texas-sized 10-4 buddy!

Re: Mastodon Renaming “Toots” to “Posts”

#79
post #10

> The word “toot” is a part of mastodon, it fits, people know what you mean. If you take that away you take away a part of mastodon’s soul. Proof people will react dramatically to basically any change, I guess. More importantly, as Blikkentrekker has pointed out, this hasn't been merged yet, and in fact from the comments seems to be very unpopular. Possibly it won't be merged at all.

I assumed you were referencing some obscure philosopher, but it turns out Blikkentrekker is just a hn username. I guess it's still the case!

Re: Mastodon Renaming “Toots” to “Posts”

#80
This change would be better probably, although, aren't the messages called "notes" in the W3C terminology? Of course, the verb is "post", and I think the noun should be "notes" to be consistent with the W3C terminology probably (which can reduce confusion, I hope).
Post reply on HN