Live data from Hacker News

Ten apps is all I need

37signals.com

71–80 of 130 posts

Re: Ten apps is all I need

#71
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not so with Android. My wife annoys the hell out of me showing all the crap she can do with her homescreen.

I for one would be glad if my wife would be interested in android enough to do anything but complain that it's sometimes slow, or has bugs.

My wife has the Samsung Galaxy S. I guess it's good enough for her as she never complains.

Re: Ten apps is all I need

#72
Variety is also good. Just because you know you love these ten apps doesn't mean you want to be confined to them. I have 350 apps on my ipod, I only use five weekly, but if I had to stay entertained for a few days I'd play all 100+ games. I'd still prefer my Kindle.

Re: Ten apps is all I need

#73

The iPhone had sold millions of units before the app store launched. A significant proportion of iPhone and iPad users have downloaded less than a handful of apps. I'm very much of the opinion that apps were more effective as a viral marketing strategy than as a truly attractive feature. People talk about apps, people show their friends, but most of the non-geeks I know don't actually use anything but the built in ap…

Well, there are classic geeks here, and there are "business geeks" :-) To me, the article looked like a user's report of the pleasure of using the N9, with a few comments about the product "winning" or being "dead on arrival" because everything has to be related back to making money, a typical (and tiresome) business geek compulsion. When you look at it that way, his personal experience using the N9 is real topic of the post and the only real content, and the rest is just a nervous tic that can be discarded without any loss in meaning.

No offense meant, by the way, I just wanted to point out that everybody has different priorities when reading these posts.

Re: Ten apps is all I need

#75
post #2

I feel like he's missing the point of an ecosystem. It's fine that he only uses a few apps on his phone, and that most other people probably do the same. The problem is that those "few apps" that most other people use aren't the same "few apps" that he uses.

I agree -- and not just an ecosystem, but competition. Apple's native apps have to be up to snuff because of pressure from the store. Those few apps that rise to the top did so in part from the mechanism of competition.

Re: Ten apps is all I need

#76

One can wonder if a platform becomes successful because of a rich ecosystem of apps or if rich ecosystem of apps follows success of a platform, but the undeniable fact of life is: every successful computing platform also has a rich ecosystem of apps. Be it Windows, Mac OS, web, iphone, playstation or Commodore 64. So reality strongly hints that you cannot have successful computing platform without a rich ecosystem of…

Compare and contrast A and B. A has features X and Y. B only has feature X. B is missing Y. Reviewer complains.

Re: Ten apps is all I need

#77
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except Nokia didn't abandon Meego. They're strategy is pretty straightforward and sound. 1) Focus on WP7 for the short/medium term. They'll be the premiere phone on the OS and if it takes off, they'll rake in the cash. 2) In the meanwhile MS gives them a boatload of money. 3) Develop Meego in the background and push it later down the line. The problem, as noted in the leaked stories, is that they didn't have a pipeli…

I am having problems believing the 3rd point as Nokia is just laying of a lot of Meego-developers. As for current Maemo/Meego-experience, I think not much can actually be said before the phones appear at stores this fall.

nokia are not laying off any meego developers.

Re: Ten apps is all I need

#78

I liked my Palm IIIx (1999) better than my Android. That's not to say it was better, just that its simple, snappy, tightly integrated set of base apps helped me be more productive. My Android, which comes with nothing very useful, makes me unproductive. PDAs were great time savers whereas 'smart' phones are great ways to get ads in front of people. :-)

What amazes me is that from what I can tell no modern mobile platform allows you to sync contact info as seamlessly as IRDA did in '99. I had a Palm V, but I could point the thing at my friends' Nokias and get their numbers in seconds.

The closest thing I've seen is Bump, which is cool but nowhere near as immediate. Plus it's a 3rd-party install.

Re: Ten apps is all I need

#79

The iPhone had sold millions of units before the app store launched. A significant proportion of iPhone and iPad users have downloaded less than a handful of apps. I'm very much of the opinion that apps were more effective as a viral marketing strategy than as a truly attractive feature. People talk about apps, people show their friends, but most of the non-geeks I know don't actually use anything but the built in ap…

I don't disagree with what you say about the core experience and the danger of generalising from personal experience but there have been 14 billion app downloads. That's a lot for something which a lot of people seem to be suggesting is either irrelevant or niche.

I think what you say may have been true in the past but I do think moving forward apps are playing an increasing role, even if it is just three or four for many users.

Re: Ten apps is all I need

#80

One can wonder if a platform becomes successful because of a rich ecosystem of apps or if rich ecosystem of apps follows success of a platform, but the undeniable fact of life is: every successful computing platform also has a rich ecosystem of apps. Be it Windows, Mac OS, web, iphone, playstation or Commodore 64. So reality strongly hints that you cannot have successful computing platform without a rich ecosystem of…

Compare and contrast A and B. A has features X and Y. B only has feature X. B is missing Y. Reviewer complains.

I give reviewers a little bit more credit than that and believe they are capable of telling a difference between important and marginal.
Post reply on HN