Live data from Hacker News

GitHub for Mac

github.com

71–80 of 214 posts

Re: GitHub for Mac

#71
That's cool and all, but a Windows client would make a lot more business sense. There are already a couple of nice git clients for Mac. There aren't for Windows.

And I assume github is targeting SMB with its paid offerings. Unless you're a design shop or a hip startup, odds are you're not running OS X. Based on my unscientific data, most companies have the devs working on Windows (or occasionally Linux).

Re: GitHub for Mac

#72
It looks really nice, but I don't see myself switching from command-line Git (except for maybe when viewing logs and/or diffs). This will definitely be awesome for working with designers though.

Re: GitHub for Mac

#73
post #71

That's cool and all, but a Windows client would make a lot more business sense. There are already a couple of nice git clients for Mac. There aren't for Windows. And I assume github is targeting SMB with its paid offerings. Unless you're a design shop or a hip startup, odds are you're not running OS X. Based on my unscientific data, most companies have the devs working on Windows (or occasionally Linux).

A Windows client doesn't make sense when most (all?) Github employees are on Macs. Mac is higher priority than Windows.

Re: GitHub for Mac

#74
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes. But the update experience for Mac App Store apps is so bad right now that it's a bit discouraging.

What about the update experience do you find so bad/discouraging?

It takes days/weeks for Apple to approve updates and then users have to consciously open the Mac App Store app and download them.

Re: GitHub for Mac

#75
post #73
post #71

That's cool and all, but a Windows client would make a lot more business sense. There are already a couple of nice git clients for Mac. There aren't for Windows. And I assume github is targeting SMB with its paid offerings. Unless you're a design shop or a hip startup, odds are you're not running OS X. Based on my unscientific data, most companies have the devs working on Windows (or occasionally Linux).

A Windows client doesn't make sense when most (all?) Github employees are on Macs. Mac is higher priority than Windows.

I get that dogfooding is important, but github employees aren't the target market.

Re: GitHub for Mac

#76
post #73
post #71

That's cool and all, but a Windows client would make a lot more business sense. There are already a couple of nice git clients for Mac. There aren't for Windows. And I assume github is targeting SMB with its paid offerings. Unless you're a design shop or a hip startup, odds are you're not running OS X. Based on my unscientific data, most companies have the devs working on Windows (or occasionally Linux).

A Windows client doesn't make sense when most (all?) Github employees are on Macs. Mac is higher priority than Windows.

Sure, but my point is that most of Github's potential customers are not on Macs.

Re: GitHub for Mac

#79
post #28

I hate all the visual clutter and unjustified complexity the new stylish iOS-like interfaces bring. Those interfaces are only good for Twitter and friends (and for screenshots). Some feedback: * Get rid of huge spacing everywhere (for example here: http://github-images.s3.amazonaws.com/blog/2011/mac-screensh... ) * Make animations go faster. * History should have preview pane with diffs (see Mail) instead of making m…

Have you tried GitX? What you described seems a bit more like GitX than what GitHub is trying to do here. When I first fired this up, I made a tarball of one of the repos I'm currently working in (it has uncommitted changes) and started clicking around. I'd do something in the GitHub app, then go back to my bash prompt to see what happened. I was pretty confused when I switched branches and all my changes were gone.…

Nothing in your reply addresses my points, so I'm not sure what to answer. Yes, I tried GitX, and I'm not looking for (or using) Git GUI tools. This doesn't make GitHub for Mac less visually cluttered.

I'm mostly discussing GUI trends (as a Mac developer who cares about this stuff), using GitHub as an example (which, as you say, gets job done great, but I say that it can be improved).

Post reply on HN