Live data from Hacker News

How to Read Books When You Have ADHD

untappedbrilliance.com

51–60 of 204 posts

Re: How to Read Books When You Have ADHD

#51
Step 1: find your obsession. Recently, it's been the concept of harmony in philosophy.

Step 2: download original source books on LibGen. E.g., complete works of Kant.

Step 3: keyword search to find relevant passages.

I read so many books now. Let's go ride bikes!

Re: How to Read Books When You Have ADHD

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How much time have you spent reading aloud to your kid? Does the kid have the same trouble following material heard read aloud that they have for material they are reading themselves? * * * Anecdotally the times in the past when I would forget material I was reading came from either being profoundly sleep deprived (e.g. pulling an all-nighter in college) or mentally highly engaged with some other idea/problem and the…

I have been reading more aloud to the child at night for about 20-30 minutes before bed. Sometimes the material is well received other times the child has snuck a book or device into bed and has no idea what was read. I haven’t determined how well the information is retained yet. On an unrelated note playing games with the child results in conditions that look like sleep deprivation. They cannot slow the game down wi…

One thing I learned tutoring fellow students in math while in high school / college was that trying to do hard unfamiliar things (or just something they didn’t choose to do) makes plenty of people who do not have ADHD feel overwhelmed/fearful/anxious/tired, especially when they are put on the spot. Some people have a “play dead” kind of response to stress, while others get angry and start fighting.

It’s not clear to what extent these board game / reading issues are related to ADHD per se. Plenty of people with ADHD are excellent at learning/playing board games and are fast fluent readers with careful attention to detail and excellent retention of what they read.

Re: How to Read Books When You Have ADHD

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's actually the basis of... I forget the name... There's a new-ish product doing the rounds on YouTube sponsorships. Basically, they distill every book into its core ideas, and present them as a 15-minute chunk. I like the idea, not because I dislike reading, but because it's handy to have an "idea map" of a book. The ToC is ostensibly that, but it's hard to figure out what their points are from the titles alone.…

I think you mean https://www.blinkist.com/ . I used it for a year, it's great for those low-density books. But really I'd like to read books, only the ones that are really interesting and valuable. My problem is that I don't want to spend money on ones that I then find are not worth the time. Perhaps someone can recommend a good subscription service with decent selection? How does scribd selection compare to amazon?

The local public library has excellent pricing.

Re: How to Read Books When You Have ADHD

#56
I don't think things need to be this complicated. I have a few books that I haven't read, many that I have, and some that are on their way. If a fiction book hooks me, I'll probably read it cover-to-cover and move on. If it doesn't, it's probably just not that good, and can go away or be finished when I have nothing more interesting to do. If it's non-fiction and non-reference, I tend to just work my way through them slowly, and go to a coffee shop with only the book to get a chapter done at a time. This is the case with Zen Motorcycle; I like it, but not so much that it needs to be read right now, so I'm slowly getting through it. The God Delusion took me about a year, while The Greatest Show on Earth took me 2 weeks or so, and The Selfish Gene took a few months probably. I retain some of the ideas, and don't expect much more, but if I want to, I'd just take notes. With reference books that I hope to come away with something useful from, I don't even bother anymore unless I'm prepared to act on it with an implementation or something. I read Secrets of the JavaScript Ninja cover-to-cover, and retained a bit, but revisiting it I'd just do the code along with it. Likewise, I read a tiny book on the history of Greenland, and didn't take notes and didn't hope to get more than a high level amount of retained information, because it's not important to anything I do, and that would be an unreasonable expectation. If however I did want to retain the data on how much fish was traded between 1750 and 1850, I'd just write it down and write an essay on it.

I think what I've decided is that the value from books is an accumulation of some ideas from all the books you read, and you should just set your expectations accordingly. My bet is that people who listen to audiobooks while working on a treadmill desk are just fooling themselves into thinking they've lived a sufficiently productive life, when really you should really read on your own accord, and go to the gym; getting to the end of a book isn't remotely as important as getting the value you set out to get from the text.

TL:DR; "I finished x books this month" is worthless, determine the value a book has before or during your reading of it, and adjust accordingly.

Re: How to Read Books When You Have ADHD

#57
Ironically I could not finish this article.

Here is the one thing, that works for me, if I must read a text:

While reading I use a Text-To-Speech-Engine to read out the text at the same time. TTS-reading speed should be at least 1.5x. It should not be too easy to keep up.

I have no explanation why this works, but it does. Maybe someone else with ADHD finds it useful.

Re: How to Read Books When You Have ADHD

#58
I have heavy ADHD. My strategy is the same as some other people in the tread have: skip the parts I find uninteresting without any guilt about it (and, if a book really interesting and entertaining, I do not need to worry about finishing it — I need to worry about other things I can't go back to right now).

Re: How to Read Books When You Have ADHD

#60

Ironically I could not finish this article. Here is the one thing, that works for me, if I must read a text: While reading I use a Text-To-Speech-Engine to read out the text at the same time. TTS-reading speed should be at least 1.5x. It should not be too easy to keep up. I have no explanation why this works, but it does. Maybe someone else with ADHD finds it useful.

I find this helpful. It satisfies my need to be doing 2 things at once, like turning the subtitles on when watching TV/movies
Post reply on HN