Will also be an interesting case study if the community shifts to this project and it dwarfs elastic for features.
OpenSearch: AWS fork of Elasticsearch and Kibana
11–20 of 438 posts
Re: OpenSearch: AWS fork of Elasticsearch and Kibana
#12It's hard for me to know whether to feel bad for ES in this case. Did they bring it on themselves? Is Amazon too big and a bully? From my perspective, Amazon has made most of its profit price gouging consumers on bandwidth after vendor locking them into their ecosystem, where they bootstrap new services by wrapping open source software with some provisioning scripts, management dashboards and cookie-cutter API / cons…
It's not "lock-in", it's providing a great all-in-one solution. You can host everything you want to host on AWS, which has good stability, good latency, etc. People are locked in because the DX around using AWS for everything your platform needs is just better than other platforms / having different services on different cloud providers (at least for many people).
Re: OpenSearch: AWS fork of Elasticsearch and Kibana
#13It's hard for me to know whether to feel bad for ES in this case. Did they bring it on themselves? Is Amazon too big and a bully? From my perspective, Amazon has made most of its profit price gouging consumers on bandwidth after vendor locking them into their ecosystem, where they bootstrap new services by wrapping open source software with some provisioning scripts, management dashboards and cookie-cutter API / cons…
Re: OpenSearch: AWS fork of Elasticsearch and Kibana
#14It's hard for me to know whether to feel bad for ES in this case. Did they bring it on themselves? Is Amazon too big and a bully? From my perspective, Amazon has made most of its profit price gouging consumers on bandwidth after vendor locking them into their ecosystem, where they bootstrap new services by wrapping open source software with some provisioning scripts, management dashboards and cookie-cutter API / cons…
Re: OpenSearch: AWS fork of Elasticsearch and Kibana
#15Re: OpenSearch: AWS fork of Elasticsearch and Kibana
#16It's hard for me to know whether to feel bad for ES in this case. Did they bring it on themselves? Is Amazon too big and a bully? From my perspective, Amazon has made most of its profit price gouging consumers on bandwidth after vendor locking them into their ecosystem, where they bootstrap new services by wrapping open source software with some provisioning scripts, management dashboards and cookie-cutter API / cons…
Is it really price gouging for bandwidth? Or is bandwidth just really expensive in general? I honestly don't know. I would assume if it was actually much cheaper one of the cloud's would undercut the other to get customers.
Re: OpenSearch: AWS fork of Elasticsearch and Kibana
#17Re: OpenSearch: AWS fork of Elasticsearch and Kibana
#18It's hard for me to know whether to feel bad for ES in this case. Did they bring it on themselves? Is Amazon too big and a bully? From my perspective, Amazon has made most of its profit price gouging consumers on bandwidth after vendor locking them into their ecosystem, where they bootstrap new services by wrapping open source software with some provisioning scripts, management dashboards and cookie-cutter API / cons…
Re: OpenSearch: AWS fork of Elasticsearch and Kibana
#19From the announcement: "You should consider the initial code to be at an alpha stage — it is not complete, not thoroughly tested, and not suitable for production use. We are planning to release a beta in the next few weeks, and expect it to stabilize and be ready for production by early summer (mid-2021)." Given that Amazon announced the fork in January and they don't expect it to be production-ready until summer, I'…
I don't remember AWS saying something like "it will be ready in weeks" in Jan...
Re: OpenSearch: AWS fork of Elasticsearch and Kibana
#20It's hard for me to know whether to feel bad for ES in this case. Did they bring it on themselves? Is Amazon too big and a bully? From my perspective, Amazon has made most of its profit price gouging consumers on bandwidth after vendor locking them into their ecosystem, where they bootstrap new services by wrapping open source software with some provisioning scripts, management dashboards and cookie-cutter API / cons…
As a longtime ElasticSearch cluster admin/developer and Elastic Cloud customer, I don't feel bad for Elastic in the slightest and I'm psyched about this fork. The way they operate their cloud service leaves a lot to be desired and encourages maximum spend if you end up wanting to use it for anything demanding in production.
At my current client we started with their cloud and in a few months deployed our own in Kubernetes using the official operator.
It's a lot cheaper and gives us fewer headaches this way.