Live data from Hacker News

Why cats won’t punish a stranger who harms you

bbc.com

11–20 of 93 posts

Re: Why cats won’t punish a stranger who harms you

#11
post #6
post #2

I think the 'why' isn't really explained in the article. 'Cats are less social aware' seems to be the tldr summary followed by call for more research.

Somewhat explained: because they were solitary hunters before domestication, unlike dogs who hunt in groups.

Is it? There is some sociability in feral cats.

Re: Why cats won’t punish a stranger who harms you

#12

They don't bring the stick back either

Back in the 90s we had a cat that liked to play fetch. Every now and then it would come to you with a bobble (a hairy ball) and you were supposed to throw it and it would bring it back (it would even drop it to your open hand).

She also liked to eat cheese puffs.

Re: Why cats won’t punish a stranger who harms you

#13
post #8
post #2

I think the 'why' isn't really explained in the article. 'Cats are less social aware' seems to be the tldr summary followed by call for more research.

Your "social aware" is very different from they are not "social pack" animals like dogs. The tldr isn't what you just made up. It's we don't know. It's literally summarized in the last paragraph: > Despite their popularity, we still know relatively little about how cats think. Future research might show cats’ understanding of humans is even more limited than we currently realise. Alternatively, it might turn out that…

Sort of a misleading conclusion given the title.

Re: Why cats won’t punish a stranger who harms you

#14
post #11
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Somewhat explained: because they were solitary hunters before domestication, unlike dogs who hunt in groups.

Is it? There is some sociability in feral cats.

Feral cat is an un-owned domestic cat

Re: Why cats won’t punish a stranger who harms you

#15
The answer to the title question was never scientifically answered. They described the experiment, the results, and then lead into a conclusion that didn't match the science. Then they finally reverted to anecdotal evidence to support the original claim which the scientific evidence does not support.

Re: Why cats won’t punish a stranger who harms you

#17
post #12

They don't bring the stick back either

Back in the 90s we had a cat that liked to play fetch. Every now and then it would come to you with a bobble (a hairy ball) and you were supposed to throw it and it would bring it back (it would even drop it to your open hand). She also liked to eat cheese puffs.

Every one of my cats liked to play that way. It was like a video game form of play hunting to them. I miss all of those furry assholes.

Re: Why cats won’t punish a stranger who harms you

#18
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've seen a few cats that'll bring back toys you throw for them so you can throw it again.

Cats can be trained quite well do to activities and if you can understand them correctly. It is still very rare, tho. I've seen videos of cats doing skateboard and other things their human trained them to do, but he was a cat behaviourist.

I always wanted a dog growing up. My parents finally agreed to a cat, so I made do. She knew sit, shake, high five, would "play" the piano, and could be sent off to touch a mark. When my sister's cat came to live with us for a few months, I taught him to sit and to jog on the treadmill. The treadmill trick was no longer allowed after the day mom was running on the treadmill and he jumped on and ran up between her feet.

Re: Why cats won’t punish a stranger who harms you

#19
there's also the obvious fact that a cat isn't a credible threat to a human. there's no point in "punishing" a creature that weighs 15-25 times as much as you do. would you try to "punish" an elephant if you were unarmed? conversely, any creature that a cat can credibly deter is not a lethal threat to a human. I imagine a large dog understands, at least on some level, that it can actually win a fight against a human. small dogs seem to believe the same thing, just incorrectly.

it would be interesting to study how/if cats defend other cats against roughly cat-sized threats.

Post reply on HN